Healing the soil: Repurposing abandoned urban lots starts with soil test

February 10, 2016, American Society of Agronomy
Students from DePaul University Ellen Webb (left) and Yarency Rodriguez (right) collect soil from empty lots on Chicago's South Side to gauge the health of the soil and better inform the next steps for the lots. Credit: James Montgomery.

Four empty lots in Chicago's South Side bear scars of the past. Their surfaces are strewn with construction debris and foundation rubble. However, the most incriminating evidence of the past lies beneath the surface, in the soil.

Chicago's history of industrialization and urbanization left its mark on the . Soil acts as a sponge, and can host contaminants for years. In Chicago, the waste from industrial manufacturing causes undesirable toxic organic chemicals, , and other chemicals to linger in the soil. This can pose problems for the health of the humans and plants that inhabit the land years later.

The four empty lots are owned by the Gary Comer Center, a non-profit youth development center in the Greater Grand Crossing neighborhood. The Comer Center's long-term hope is to repurpose the lots into useful spaces for the community. However, the poor quality soils in the lots create challenges.

"They are going to need some serious TLC to bring them back," says urban soil scientist James Montgomery.

Montgomery is an associate professor in the Department of Environmental Science and Studies at DePaul University. He and his team trained a group of undergraduate students from DePaul to test the soil on the lots in collaboration with the Comer Center. The soils are all in poor shape. They have a high alkaline level, and contain chemical and lead levels above the amount recommended by the EPA.

DePaul University student Katy Rico tests soil from an empty lot on Chicago's South Side. Poor quality urban soils require remediation to improve functioning and ecosystem services. Credit: James Montgomery.

To Montgomery, this isn't a hopeless case: "We want to work with the Comer Center and help them realize their vision for using these lots, whatever that might be," he says.

The Comer Center's eventual goal, whether it's the installation of urban gardens, parks, or buildings, will dictate how much cleanup is needed to improve the soil. Remediation can be as intensive as physically removing and replacing the soil, or as simple as tilling it up and adding amendments.

The presence of lead, heavy metals, and excess chemicals may call for containment using . One purpose of green infrastructure is to interrupt the journey of contaminants into water sources, where they can spread or infiltrate drinking water sources. It can include bioswales, rain gardens, or vegetative buffers. Plans can include plant species capable of ingesting heavy metals or excess chemicals in the soil.

Montgomery says that soil testing should come first when deciding what to do with a piece of property. "You go to a doctor for a preventative check-up and we should do the same with soil."

Testing the soil is usually inexpensive and can indicate what's needed—and what isn't needed—to improve it. "It's part of understanding your home," says Montgomery. "If you have a soil test done and it's showing you've got excess chemicals, then maybe you don't need to spend as much money on amendments to the soil."

For Montgomery, soil health is an environmental justice issue. Low-income and underserved neighborhoods are rife with poor soils. There has been little reconstruction in the Greater Grand Crossing neighborhood since the 1930's. Approximately 78 percent of the residents are below the poverty line. "We definitely need to be at the table advocating for environmental justice in these communities that are wracked by poor soil quality," says Montgomery.

Montgomery notes that community participation in this project is particularly important. "The point is not to have the university come in and dictate," he says. "The Comer Center is driving this bus and that's how it should be."

Montgomery says they plan to hold planning sessions with the community to discover what they envision for the lots. They will use the results of the soil test to better inform their next move.

Explore further: Ecologist's warning on Earth's imperiled soils

More information: James A. Montgomery et al. Soil Quality Assessment Is a Necessary First Step for Designing Urban Green Infrastructure, Journal of Environment Quality (2016). DOI: 10.2134/jeq2015.04.0192

Related Stories

Ecologist's warning on Earth's imperiled soils

February 1, 2016

Neglect of the soil beneath our feet could have far-reaching consequences for future generations in the UK and the rest of the world, an ecologist from The University of Manchester has warned.

Urban soil quality and compost

October 15, 2013

With higher populations and limited space, urban areas are not often thought of as places for agriculture. A recent surge in community gardens, though, is bringing agriculture and gardens into the cities. And certain byproducts ...

One crop, two ways, multiple benefits

January 6, 2016

Nitrogen fixation is one of the best examples of cooperation in nature. Soil microbes - naturally occurring bacteria in the soil - work with plants to pull nitrogen from the air. They turn the nitrogen into a form the plant ...

Recommended for you

Afromontane forests and climate change

January 17, 2019

In the world of paleoecology, little has been known about the historical record of ecosystems in the West African highlands, especially with regard to glacial cycles amidst a shifting climate and their effects on species ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.