New climate model better predicts changes to ocean-carbon sink

February 24, 2016
Credit: Tiago Fioreze / Wikipedia

Since pre-industrial times, the world's oceans have absorbed 41 percent of the carbon dioxide humans have released into the atmosphere. The remainder stays airborne, warming the planet.

The relationship between our future carbon dioxide emissions and future climate change depends strongly on the capacity of the ocean-carbon sink. How efficiently will it continue to soak up what we emit?

That is a question climate scientists have so far been unable to answer because of limited opportunities to take robust ocean-atmosphere measurements around the planet and because of inherent challenges in existing computer models.

In a new paper published in Nature Thursday, Feb. 25, 2016, a research team headed by Galen McKinley, professor in the University of Wisconsin-Madison Department of Atmospheric and Oceanic Sciences, describes the best modeling approach to date for arriving at an answer to this and other crucial climate questions.

"It's an evolution in our ability to use to make predictions, particularly on timescales of a few decades," says McKinley, also an affiliate of the Center for Climatic Research at UW-Madison's Nelson Institute for Environmental Studies.

This improved predictive capacity could allow scientists to better understand what changes to expect, where to expect them, and their magnitude. It could also lead to better allocation of limited resources to enhance monitoring efforts, or to the creation of specific policies to mitigate change.

McKinley will present the Community Earth System Model findings on Tuesday, Feb. 23, at the 2016 Ocean Sciences Meeting, which is co-sponsored by the Association for the Sciences of Limnology and Oceanography, The Oceanography Society and the American Geophysical Union.

A variety of natural factors influence global climate, from solar variation to volcanoes, but anthropogenic greenhouse gas emissions also change the nature of the planet. Researchers want to distinguish the difference, especially in the context of large fluctuations in annual weather. They want to discern the role humans play in a changing climate.

"In Wisconsin, we might have a winter that is very cold, even though the overall climate is slowly and steadily warming," McKinley explains. "The swing to a very cold year is natural variability, and what we want to be able to uncover and understand is the magnitude of the slow and steady trend occurring at the same time as these large swings."

Prior climate models have lacked the fundamental computing power necessary to find the human signal above the noise of a variable climate system, McKinley says. This has been particularly true of the ocean-carbon sink.

The new study employed massive computing resources at the National Center for Atmospheric Research (NCAR), funded by the National Science Foundation (NSF), to perform a large number of simulations using a single model. This meant any variability detected would be inherent to the modeled climate system itself and not because of differences between models.

"What this does is let us determine how big that variability is and how it changes as timescales lengthen. We're better able to see when human activity begins to affect the ocean-carbon sink," she explains. "This is really a first step in using this new technique to understand a host of issues in terms of , and it's not restricted to ocean carbon or biogeochemistry or physics. People are also using it to look at precipitation and temperature changes."

For assessing the global ocean-carbon sink, McKinley and her co-authors from the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) Pacific Marine Environmental Laboratory, NCAR and the University of Colorado Boulder used the model to establish a long-running climate scenario from historical data. Then, on model date Jan. 1, 1920, the researchers created a "slight perturbation" within the system: a slight rounding of the calculations for air temperature. Then, they looked at what happened.

"It was just a butterfly effect, a small change in the atmospheric temperature fields," McKinley says. "You perturb it oh-so-slightly and the model takes distinct paths of variation."

With this single, slight change the researchers elicited 32 different simulations—built on all the same assumptions—that represented some of the different ways the same climate system could evolve.

"It's like a swirl of creamer in your coffee cup," says McKinley. "You can stir it today and it will look like this, but you stir it tomorrow and the pattern is different. You're using the same spoon, the same cup, the same coffee, the same creamer, but the swirls look different. This is how our climate system works."

And yet, she says, regardless of the shape the swirl initially takes, the coffee will still end up the same lighter color, unless something else changes, like pouring in additional creamer.

"We know that if we put carbon in the atmosphere, we will get an ancillary effect, the climate will warm," she says. "But how we get there are those swirls ... we are now starting to realize that variability is still strong on timescales of decades and we don't have as much ability as we would like to predict it."

In using the model to assess the ocean-carbon sink, the researchers assumed a "business as usual" trajectory, the Representative Concentration Pathway 8.5 scenario found in the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change for 2006-2010, where emissions continue to rise throughout the 21st century.

The model also accounted for natural drivers of change, including the direct influence of increased carbon dioxide on ocean-carbon uptake and the indirect effect that a changing climate has on the physical state of the ocean and its relationship to . For example, carbon dioxide is less soluble in water in a warmer .

The model showed that regions of the subpolar and equatorial Atlantic Ocean are undergoing changes that can already be detected through the noise of variability. Here, the ocean-carbon sink has increased, absorbing more carbon dioxide. However, changes to the sink in the Pacific and Indian Ocean subtropical regions will be too low-resolution to detect before at least 2050.

The researchers also checked the model against actual ocean observations. "What we find is that observations today are not sufficient to be able to see change in the ocean-carbon sink," McKinley explains. "We can see that there is a sink, but at any one location, we don't have enough data to say that the sink is increasing or decreasing."

The ability of any particular ocean or region of an ocean to absorb depends in part on local features like how much exchange there is between surface and deep sea water. Taking measurements in some of these areas can be complicated. The model may help guide efforts to focus on particular regions and devote resources to these areas.

But the models themselves aren't easy to develop, which is why they are another step in the process and an improvement upon the tools previously available.

"If you want to calculate how all the wind moves, how the ocean circulates, how the chemistry in the atmosphere happens, the productivity on land, that's a lot of computer code and you want to do it at the highest resolution possible," McKinley says. "What we're really trying to do is represent all the complexity of planet Earth with a computer, so you can imagine how complicated that would be."

McKinley's goals are to continue to build upon the capabilities of the model."What does Wisconsin look like 10 years from now? That's really hard to say," she says. "But we can provide ranges of expectations with broad variability, and use these techniques to quantify it."

"You know you can't be sure on any given day that it's going to be too cold to go skiing, or there's going to be enough snow," she adds. "But we want to know: What is the likelihood that we'll have winters where skiing isn't doable or ice fishing on the lake is a lot less possible?"

Explore further: Ocean's carbon dioxide uptake reduced by climate change

More information: Timescales for detection of trends in the ocean carbon sink, DOI: 10.1038/nature16958

Related Stories

Ocean's carbon dioxide uptake reduced by climate change

July 10, 2011

( -- How deep is the ocean's capacity to buffer against climate change? As one of the planet's largest single carbon absorbers, the ocean takes up roughly one-third of all human carbon emissions, reducing atmospheric ...

Hurricanes not likely to disrupt ocean carbon balance

March 30, 2009

( -- Hurricanes are well known for the trail of damage and debris they can leave on land, but less known for the invisible trail left over the ocean by their gale-force winds — a trail of carbon dioxide.

Ocean carbon uptake more variable than thought

November 13, 2014

The Earth's oceans are thought to have taken up about one quarter of the carbon dioxide (CO2) that humans pumped into the atmosphere in the past 2 decades. While this drives acidification and has consequences for sea life, ...

NASA takes part in airborne study of Antarctic seas

January 29, 2016

A team of scientists has launched a series of research flights over the remote seas surrounding Antarctica in an effort to better understand how much carbon dioxide the icy waters are able to lock away.

A lower limit for future climate emissions

February 24, 2016

In a comprehensive new study published in the journal Nature Climate Change, researchers propose a limit to future greenhouse gas emissions—or carbon budget—of 590-1240 billion tons of carbon dioxide from 2015 onwards, ...

Recommended for you

Carbon coating gives biochar its garden-greening power

October 20, 2017

For more than 100 years, biochar, a carbon-rich, charcoal-like substance made from oxygen-deprived plant or other organic matter, has both delighted and puzzled scientists. As a soil additive, biochar can store carbon and ...

Cool roofs have water saving benefits too

October 20, 2017

The energy and climate benefits of cool roofs have been well established: By reflecting rather than absorbing the sun's energy, light-colored roofs keep buildings, cities, and even the entire planet cooler. Now a new study ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.