Plate tectonics thanks to plumes?

November 11, 2015, ETH Zurich

Plate tectonics thanks to plumes?
Venus as a model: Today this planet looks like the Earth might have looked before the onset of plate tectonics. Credit: NASA/JPL
"Knowing what a chicken looks like and what all the chickens before it looked like doesn't help us to understand the egg," says Taras Gerya. The ETH Professor of Geophysics uses this metaphor to address plate tectonics and the early history of the Earth. The Earth's lithosphere is divided into several plates that are in constant motion, and today's geologists have a good understanding of what drives these plate movements: heavier ocean plates are submerged beneath lighter continental plates along what are known as subduction zones. Once the movement has begun, it is perpetuated due to the weight of the dense subducting plate.

But just as in the past, scientists still do not understand what triggered in the first place, nor how the first subduction zone was formed. A weak spot in the Earth's lithosphere was necessary in order for parts of the Earth's crust to begin their descent into the Earth's mantle. Was this weak spot caused by a gigantic meteorite that effectively smashed a hole in the Earth's lithosphere? Or did mantle convection forces shatter the lithosphere into moving parts?

Venus as a model

Gerya is not satisfied with any of these potential explanations. "It's not trivial to draw conclusions about what set the tectonic movements in motion," he says. The ETH professor therefore set out to find a new, plausible explanation.

Among other things, he found inspiration in studies about the surface of the planet Venus, which has never had plate tectonics. Gerya observed (and modelled) huge, crater-like circles (coronae) on Venus that may also have existed on the Earth's surface in the early period (Precambrian) of the Earth's history before plate tectonics even began. These structures could indicate that mantle plumes once rose from Venus' iron core to the outer layer, thus softening and weakening the planet's surface. Plumes form in the deep interior of the planet. They rise up to the lithosphere, bringing with them hot partially molten mantle material that causes the lithosphere to weaken and deform. Halted by the resistance of the hard lithosphere, the material begins to spread, taking on a mushroom-like shape.

Such plumes also likely existed in the Earth's interior and could have created the weaknesses in the Earth's lithosphere needed to initiate plate tectonics on Earth.

Mantle plumes create weaknesses

The ETH geophysicist worked with his team to develop new computer models that he then used to investigate this idea for the first time in high resolution and in 3D. The corresponding publication has recently been published in Nature.

The simulations show that and the weaknesses they create could have actually initiated the first .

In the simulations, the plume weakens the overlying lithosphere and forms a circular, thinning weak point with a diameter of several dozen to hundreds of kilometres. This is stretched over time by the supply of hot material from the deep mantle. "In order to make a ring larger, you have to break it," explains the researcher. This also applies to the Earth's surface: the ring-shaped weaknesses can (in the model) only be enlarged and subducted if the margins are torn.

Water lubricates the plate margin

The tears spread throughout the lithosphere, large slabs of the heavier rigid lithosphere plunge into the soft mantle, and the first plate margins emerge. The tension created by the plunging slabs ultimately sets the plates in motion. They plunge, well lubricated by the buried seawater of the ocean above. Subduction has begun - and with it, plate tectonics. "Water acts as a lubricant and is an absolute necessity in the initiation of a self-sustaining subduction," says Gerya.

In their simulations, the researchers compare different temperature conditions and lithosphere states. They came to the conclusion that plume-induced plate tectonics could plausibly develop under the conditions that prevailed in the Precambrian around three billion years ago. Back then the Earth's lithosphere was already thick and cool, but the mantle was still very hot, providing enough energy to significantly weaken the lithosphere above the plumes.

Had the lithosphere instead being thin and warm, and therefore soft, the simulations show that a ring-shaped rapidly descending structure called drip would simply have formed around the plume head. While this would have steadily sunk into the mantle, it would not have caused the soft lithosphere to subduct and tear and therefore would not have produced plate margins. Likewise, the computer simulations showed that under today's conditions, where there is less temperature difference between lithosphere and plume material, plume-induced subduction is hard to initiate because the lithosphere is already too rigid and the plumes are barely able to weaken it sufficiently.

Dominant mechanism

"Our new models explain how plate tectonics came about," says the geophysicist. Plume activity was enough to give rise to today's plate mosaic. He calls the power of the plumes the dominant trigger for global plate tectonics.

The simulations can also explain how so-called triple junctions, i.e. zones in which three plates come together, are nucleated by multi-directional stretching of the induced by plumes. One such example of a triple junction can be found in the Horn of Africa where Ethiopia, Eritrea and Djibouti meet.

A possible plume-weakened zone analogous to a starting point for global plate tectonics likely exists in the modern world: the researchers see such a zone in the Caribbean plate. Its shape, location and spread correspond largely to the new model simulations.

Indeed it is arguably impossible to prove how global plate tectonics started on Earth based solely on observations: there is no geophysical and only a small amount of geological data from the Earth's early years, and laboratory experiments are not possible for extremely large-scale and very long-term tectonic processes, says the ETH researcher. "Computer models are therefore the only way we can reproduce and understand the events of the Earth's early history."

Explore further: Ascent or no ascent? How hot material is stopped in the Earth's mantle

More information: T. V. Gerya et al. Plate tectonics on the Earth triggered by plume-induced subduction initiation, Nature (2015). DOI: 10.1038/nature15752

Related Stories

Impact origin of archean cratons: Learning from Venus

August 28, 2015

Earth was a completely different planet more than 2.5 billion years ago. Little is known about this critical time when cratonic continental seeds formed; life emerged; and precious mineral resources concentrated.

Mantle plumes crack continents

September 4, 2014

Using a simulation with an unprecedentedly high resolution, Earth scientists from University of Paris VI and ETH Zurich have shown that magma columns in the Earth's interior can cause continental breakup—but only if the ...

Recommended for you

Researchers engineer a tougher fiber

February 22, 2019

North Carolina State University researchers have developed a fiber that combines the elasticity of rubber with the strength of a metal, resulting in a tougher material that could be incorporated into soft robotics, packaging ...

A quantum magnet with a topological twist

February 22, 2019

Taking their name from an intricate Japanese basket pattern, kagome magnets are thought to have electronic properties that could be valuable for future quantum devices and applications. Theories predict that some electrons ...

Solving the jet/cocoon riddle of a gravitational wave event

February 22, 2019

An international research team including astronomers from the Max Planck Institute for Radio Astronomy in Bonn, Germany, has combined radio telescopes from five continents to prove the existence of a narrow stream of material, ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

5 / 5 (4) Nov 11, 2015
According to jeffensley, using computer models to simulate this activity means that plate tectonics must be wrong.
5 / 5 (2) Nov 12, 2015
Most people who can read know it's the other way around, computer algorithms can model larger, more complex systems than our analytical predictions out of theories. [ https://en.wikipe...mulation ]

Tellingly no one claims that using computer models to steer interplanetary crafts with high precision means gravity must be wrong, or that using GPS technology means general relativity is the wrong theory for it. (Ironically GPS has allowed to observe plate tectonics in situ. It is a fairly common and popular study in elementary classes I hear - every year students can see how much their plate has moved in relation to others.)

I have come to think cranks suffer from math & science envy, few seem able to write or add single digit numbers and - related - grok testing. Now, how to test that idea...?
5 / 5 (1) Nov 12, 2015
Actually using CS on theory is a good test of CS and other theory resilience. No code is bug free, yet different software can be made to agree.

Nor am I especially bothered by system parts that are hidden from observation.

It is an elementary result in control theory that nodes can be unobservable under some constraints. "A physical example of uncontrollable and unobservable modes is provided by the plucked vibrating string of an electric guitar with one (very thin) magnetic pick-up. ... All modes of vibration having a node at the plucking point are uncontrollable at that point, and all modes having a node at the pick-up are unobservable at that point." [ https://ccrma.sta...ity.html ]

YMMV of course.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.