Can you grow potatoes on Mars?

September 23, 2015 by Helen Maynard-Casely, The Conversation
If you can grow potatoes here, why not on Mars? Credit: Helen Maynard-Casely, CC BY-SA

This is not as odd a question as it sounds, and by next week I reckon a good lot of you will be pondering it. Why? Well the 30th September sees the opening of The Martian in Australia, director Ridley Scott's latest offering. It's a survivor tale, telling the plight of a lone astronaut trapped on Mars.

To be honest I'd be surprised if you hadn't heard of this movie. If you're reading this column you're probably somewhat of a nerd and this movie has been artfully targeting you since the get go.

It first came to my attention when a number of my (nerdier) facebook friends started announcing that they were going to greet their next day by 'sciencing the shit out of it'. A new nerd-cry to rival the immortal 'back off man I'm a scientist', The Martian has firmly announced itself as a geek movie. It's the latest in an increasing trend of films that prides itself on its scientific accuracy.

I admit, the trailer intrigued me, and watching it as I did back in June I was rather infuriated to learn that I'd have to wait until spring to find out what all the fuss is about. So I did what any self-respecting scientist does at this point – I looked to gather more information. I read the book.

The Martian is based on the best-selling book by Andy Weir. The book was released in parts as an e-book after he struggled to get a publishing contract (which seems a bit laughable now, after he sold the movie rights for hundreds of thousands). But this trickle of story meant that Wier could gather feedback about the accuracy of the science in it (some parts read like an XKCD comic) and revise where needed.

It's a good, copy-inducing, tool to say that your book is 'accurate' in one way or another as it ensues a raft of articles confirming/denying your work (c.f. this piece). And we're always being told that no publicity is bad….

The book starts by introducing us to Mark Watney, who has been stranded on Mars after an unfortunate incident. To survive, given that he only has rations for 31 days, he is going to have to grow some more food. The best thing he has to start this off is some freeze-dried potatoes that were meant for a Thanksgiving meal. This, of course is only one of his issues, but is one that I can at least ponder on. Can you grow the humble tattie on Mars?

Thanks to Curiosity, we know this – at least – is possible. One of the instruments hidden in Curiosity's belly is a diffractometer (which I've gone on about before) which gives us a pretty unambiguous picture of what minerals make up the surface of Mars. The upshot is, Mars is a lot like Iceland.

What I've got in this picture is two patterns of data – one taken by Curiosity on Mars and one taken by me of a sample of volcanic ash from Iceland at the Australian Synchrotron (at ~3 am in the morning I'd like to add). The black line in each is the measured pattern and the red one the model of minerals I'm fitting. In both I've fit a mixture of the minerals pyroxene and feldspar as well as a big hump to account for the glassy stuff. It's not a perfect model for both of the patterns, but it does account for most of the features. What you'll (hopefully) notice is the astonishing similarity between both patterns. The great thing about this is, well, we know a lot about Iceland – we've studied the minerals there for hundreds of years. We can now apply that knowledge to Mars.

Comparing minerals on Mars to those on Earth. The Martian pattern was taken by the CheMin instrument within Curiosity and I downloaded the data from the NASA public data server http://pds-geosciences.wustl.edu/missions/msl/ the ‘Earth’ sample is one of volcanic ash that my friend Kate collected in Iceland. Credit: Helen Maynard-Casely

I admit that when I first collected the Icelandic ash data I wasn't really thinking 'Mars' – I was thinking 'here's a cool bunch of samples that no-one has ever put in a synchrotron beamline before'. But I came across the work of Emily, a PhD student at UTS. She was building a library how minerals respond to light spectra, specifically Raman and FTIR. She is doing this because the next Mars rovers (Mars2020 and ExoMars) won't carry diffraction machines, but will carry Raman and FTIR instruments. I realised that she might like some 'Mars-like' samples to try her library out on, and offered her the use of the Icelandic ash – and the diffraction patterns to go with them. You can read more about this in the nice paper Emily published about it all.

But, as any soil scientist will tell you, the minerals are only the start. These need to be processed and have the ability to hold in a community of bacteria. I won't give away the spoiler of how Mark Watney achieves that…. But the premise is sound, Mars is like Iceland and they can grow potatoes on Iceland (though, with a bit of help from the abundant geothermal heat they have there).

So that's one bit of The Martian which is pretty accurate. All in all I loved the book, so the next question is….. will the movie be any good?

Explore further: Astronauts have read 'The Martian,' now can't wait for movie

Related Stories

Ridley Scott's 'The Martian' takes off in Toronto

September 12, 2015

Matt Damon got to relive his childhood fantasies of being an astronaut in Ridley Scott's 3D space epic "The Martian," where he portrays a character left for dead on the Red Planet.

The fact and fiction of Martian dust storms

September 21, 2015

For years, science fiction writers from Edgar Rice Burroughs to C. S. Lewis have imagined what it would be like for humans to walk on Mars. As mankind comes closer to taking its first steps on the Red Planet, authors' depictions ...

Recommended for you

Comprehensive model captures entire life cycle of solar flares

January 15, 2019

A team of scientists has, for the first time, used a single, cohesive computer model to simulate the entire life cycle of a solar flare: from the buildup of energy thousands of kilometers below the solar surface, to the emergence ...

Team discovers new way supermassive black holes are 'fed'

January 14, 2019

Supermassive black holes weigh millions to billions times more than our sun and lie at the center of most galaxies. A supermassive black hole several million times the mass of the sun is situated in the heart of our very ...

The orderly chaos of black holes

January 14, 2019

During the formation of a black hole, a bright burst of very energetic light in the form of gamma rays is produced, these events are called gamma ray bursts. The physics behind this phenomenon includes many of the least understood ...

1 comment

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

baudrunner
not rated yet Sep 23, 2015
I assume that you're an Australian scientist working in that synchrotron lab because as a scientist in your chosen field of study you should at least have access to an instrument small enough to be confiscated out of my carry-on bag at the airport, given that one is currently part of that rover package doing the same thing. And oh, I really don't see much of a similarity in those spectrometer outputs other than that is certain matters generally found on planetary surfaces and even then, Mars looks to be pretty different, judging from the results.

As I see it, and am I just being pessimistic, but the first Mars colonists will probably begin to die after six months, and the last after about a year. That's when the meat runs out.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.