Microsoft, US clash in court on overseas email warrant

September 9, 2015 by John Biers
Microsoft and the US government clashed Wednesday in an appellate court hearing on law enforcement access to emails stored overs
Microsoft and the US government clashed Wednesday in an appellate court hearing on law enforcement access to emails stored overseas

Microsoft and the US government clashed Wednesday in an appellate court hearing on law enforcement access to emails stored overseas, in a case with important implications for global data protection.

Allowing the government to carry out its warrant for its emails stored in Ireland could create "a rule for global chaos," said Joshua Rosenkranz, an attorney arguing for Microsoft in the New York .

Siding with the US in the case could give free rein to foreign governments to demand comparable records from US interests, Rosenkranz said.

"If we can do this to them, then they can do that to us," Rosenkranz said. "We would go crazy if China did this to us. Why? Because this case is about sovereignty."

US officials in December 2013 persuaded a magistrate judge to grant a warrant to access to a Microsoft-based email account that was suspected of being used in narcotics trade.

But Microsoft refused to comply, saying the records were stored at a data center in Dublin, Ireland. A US district court sided with the government.

Rosenkranz said the 1986 US law cited by the government in the case predates modern communication systems, including the use of overseas data storage, and that there is nothing in the statute that implies that it governs overseas operations.

The government has argued that the specific location of the records is irrelevant because Microsoft, as a US company, is subject to US rules.

"Under international law... the norm is that sovereigns have jurisdiction over entities before them and can compel them to produce materials," said Justin Anderson, an assistant US attorney.

A legal brief outlining the government's case quoted an earlier ruling on overseas records that said: "the test for production of documents is control, not location."

Since Microsoft officials in the US maintained control over the Dublin , they must hand over the records, Anderson said.

Members of the three-judge panel seemed open to both sides and extended an oral argument originally scheduled for 24 minutes well past an hour.

"The implications of what we do here are obviously broad," said appellate judge Gerard Lynch.

Microsoft has won backing from numerous tech, media and telecom heavyweights, including Apple, the Washington Post and Verizon.

The Center for Democracy and Technology, which has supported Microsoft, warned of an international "Wild West" if the warrant is upheld as foreign governments seek to seize data held in the US.

"The economic consequences of this case could be huge," said Greg Nojeim, an attorney at CDT.

"It could make it even more difficult for US providers to sell services abroad when the US claims special rights to access content conveyed over those services. Many potential customers will conflate such access with NSA (National Security Agency) surveillance, to the detriment of US cloud providers."

Explore further: Federal appeals court set to hear Microsoft 'cloud' case

Related Stories

Federal appeals court set to hear Microsoft 'cloud' case

September 6, 2015

Microsoft Corp. gets a second chance to prove it's entitled to keep data stored overseas out of the hands of U.S. investigators when its lawyers appear before a federal appeals court Wednesday, but the computer software giant ...

Microsoft challenging US on overseas data

July 31, 2014

In a case closely watched by the tech sector, Microsoft will challenge Thursday a US court order requiring it to give prosecutors electronic mail content associated with an overseas server.

Tech giants seek to halt overseas snooping by US

June 16, 2014

Microsoft Corp. and four other large American technology companies are using a Manhattan court case to draw a line in the cloud, saying the U.S. government has no right to seize computer data stored outside the country.

Microsoft builds support over Ireland email case

December 15, 2014

Microsoft said Monday it had secured broad support from a coalition of influential technology and media firms as it seeks to challenge a US ruling ordering it to hand over emails stored on a server in Ireland.

Recommended for you

Technology near for real-time TV political fact checks

January 18, 2019

A Duke University team expects to have a product available for election year that will allow television networks to offer real-time fact checks onscreen when a politician makes a questionable claim during a speech or debate.

Privacy becomes a selling point at tech show

January 7, 2019

Apple is not among the exhibitors at the 2019 Consumer Electronics Show, but that didn't prevent the iPhone maker from sending a message to attendees on a large billboard.

China's Huawei unveils chip for global big data market

January 7, 2019

Huawei Technologies Ltd. showed off a new processor chip for data centers and cloud computing Monday, expanding into new and growing markets despite Western warnings the company might be a security risk.


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.