Loss of altruism (and a body plan) without a loss of genes

August 4, 2015 by Brian Zimmerman, Earlham College
Workers of the rough harvester ant, Pogonomyrmex rugosus, one of the host species used by the social parasites, and one of the genomes sequenced as part of the study. Credit: Chris R. Smith, used with permission

An international team of researchers found that the evolutionary loss of the "altruistic" worker caste in ants is not accompanied by a loss of genes.

Social insects, such as , are typically characterized by two distinct female castes: workers and queens. Previous research has found that workers and queens each express different sets of leading scientists to speculate that there are worker specific or "altruistic" genes that promote sociality.

Testing this "novel gene" hypothesis is difficult given that all ants are social. However, not all ants make workers. Some ants are "workerless social parasites" whose queens exploit the worker force of other species by invading and setting up shop in their colonies. The authors took advantage of the unusual biology of these ants that have lost their worker caste to determine if worker genes really exist.

The research team, led by Chris R. Smith (Earlham College) and Alexander (Sasha) Mikheyev (Okinawa Institute of Science and Technology), sequenced and compared the genomes of six ants (3 hosts and 3 workerless social parasites) and looked for evidence that genes that are typically over expressed in the worker caste would degenerate through time when workers are no longer produced. Instead of finding degeneration in "worker" genes, they found that there are no "worker" genes and the majority of the protein coding genome is maintained in species that stopped producing workers even after one million years. Their research is online early in the journal Molecular Biology and Evolution.

"This was a total surprise, we hypothesized the opposite—when you lose a trait then the genes for that trait should disappear over time," said Smith. "This result has two interesting implications: first, there don't seem to be any genes that are explicitly 'worker' and thus truly 'altruistic', and two, that the loss of an entire body plan is not accompanied by a loss of genes."

This result suggests that any organism's genome may harbor the potential to produce historic phenotypes that are no longer under selection (for ~1 million years) – one need only speculate about what ancient human traits may continue to lurk in our own genomes, waiting to be expressed in a different environmental context.

When looking across developmental stages in an ant (the red harvester ant, Pogonomyrmex barbatus), the researchers found that most genes are expressed in both queens and workers, but often at different points in development. For example, there are no uniquely "worker" or "queen" genes. They then looked at whether genes with a greater bias in workers were more likely to get lost in species that no longer produce workers (social parasites).

To do this the researchers sequenced the genomes of two host species and two of their social parasites. The answer was no, the entire protein coding genome was under selection to maintain the genes present in both hosts and workerless social parasites.

The researchers found their results so surprising that they sequenced the genomes of another host-social parasite pair in the genus Vollenhovia, which are evolutionarily independent. Once again, the result was the same. Again surprised, they tested whether they could even expect to see the deterioration of genes in the mere 700,000 to million years of divergence between worker and -less species. Indeed, models do predict gene loss, yet none was evident in their actual samples.

"Social parasitism is relatively widespread in , and our results suggest why – most changes are regulatory, and don't require complex genome-wide alterations," Mikheyev said.

The results reported in this new research add to a growing body of literature suggesting that many traits (and whole body plans, as shown here) may evolve by tweaks in the regulation of pre-existing genes and networks. Phenotype gain and loss may be facilitated by changes in the environment within and outside of the organism, not necessarily requiring changes to genes, just changes to when and how they are used).

"This research reminds us of the importance of studying organisms with unusual natural history in order to get insight into the processes that govern diversity more generally," said Andrew Suarez from the University of Illinois and a co-author of the study.

While this work was on species far removed from the origin of sociality, it does suggest that sociality may have evolved from regulatory changes in a solitary ancestor rather than requiring novel altruism genes for social living and division of labor.

Explore further: From worker to queen at the drop of a gene

Related Stories

From worker to queen at the drop of a gene

May 26, 2015

Biologists from the University of Leicester have discovered that one of nature's most important pollinators - the buff-tailed bumblebee – either ascends to the status of queen or remains a lowly worker bee based on which ...

Wasp transcriptome creates a buzz

February 25, 2013

New research delivers a sting in the tail for queen wasps. Scientists have sequenced the active parts of the genome – or transcriptome – of primitively eusocial wasps to identify the part of the genome that makes you ...

Novel genes determine division of labor in insect societies

January 30, 2014

Novel or highly modified genes play a major role in the development of the different castes within ant colonies. Evolutionary biologists at Johannes Gutenberg University Mainz (JGU) came to this conclusion in a recent gene ...

Ants shape their thoraces to match the tasks they perform

January 7, 2014

It was now discovered that the specialization of queen and worker ants goes beyond the presence or absence of wings. In a study published in the open access scientific journal eLife, Roberto A. Keller and Patrícia Beldade ...

Recommended for you

Overspending on defense arsenal bankrupts a plant's economy

October 22, 2018

Defend or grow? Can plants do both at the same time? Michigan State University scientists might be inching closer to answering these questions. The answers matter. They could someday help us understand natural ecosystems ...

Cells that change jobs to fight diabetes

October 22, 2018

Diabetes is characterized by persistent high blood sugar levels that occur when certain cells in the pancreas—the insulin-producing β cells—are destroyed or are no longer able to secrete insulin. Researchers at the University ...

Spotlighting differences in closely-related species

October 22, 2018

There are millions of fungal species, and those few hundred found in the Aspergillus genus play important roles in areas ranging from industrial production to agricultural plant pathogens. Reported October 22, 2018, in Nature ...

1 comment

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

1 / 5 (2) Aug 05, 2015
Re: "... any organism's genome may harbor the potential to produce historic phenotypes that are no longer under selection (for ~1 million years) – one need only speculate about what ancient human traits may continue to lurk in our own genomes, waiting to be expressed in a different environmental context."

No experimental evidence of biologically-based cause and effect suggests the selection for either morphological or behavioral phenotypes has occurred (for ~1 million years) in any species. All experimental evidence suggests that nutrient-dependent RNA-mediated gene duplication and the RNA-mediated fixation of amino acid substitutions in the context of the physiology of reproduction determines all cell types in all individuals of all genera via as little as a single amino acid substitution and mutations linked to the loss of receptors that are no longer required for the organism's survival.

That's where our olfactory receptor pseudogenes come from.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.