Study looks at "social recessions" during hard economic times

July 9, 2015, University of Manchester

The number of people helping out their friends and neighbours dropped significantly following the recession, new research from The University of Manchester finds.

A study of habits in the UK over the 2008 financial crash points to a country also going through a 'social ' and the decline in our ability to help others, including strangers in need.

'Doing good when times are bad: volunteering behaviour in economic hard times' is published in the British Journal of Sociology this week.

The paper, co-authored by Dr James Laurence, research fellow in sociology at The University of Manchester, finds that formal volunteering (eg. unpaid help through organisations such as charities, schools or community groups) dropped by over 5% in two years, following the onset of the recession. By comparison, informal volunteering (eg. everyday acts of kindness done outside of organisations, such as babysitting, shopping or driving for a neighbour or friend) dropped by 12%. In both cases, even amongst those who continued to help, the amount of time that they gave also decreased.

One of the most staggering findings was the speed at which volunteering declined.

Dr Laurence said: "For informal helping especially, the kind of drop we saw over two years is normally seen over decades.

"This translates into hundreds of thousands of people dropping out of volunteering and the loss of thousands of hours of helping behaviours.

"Negative shocks to our economic system can have deep, caustic effects on the social fabric of our communities. Understanding both the economic and social impacts of recessions is vital to fully understanding their costs. Volunteering is an excellent example of this. You have a huge amount of social support and help just disappearing. However, these helping behaviours are also a useful diagnostic sign of community health."

The new paper questions the burgeoning 'blitz spirit' that was reported by some commentators in the early days of the recession.

Dr Laurence and his co-researcher, Chaeyoon Lim, of the University of Wisconsin-Madison, also found that the social cost was not borne equally across communities. Volunteering in the UK's 20% least barely registered the recession with no change in the level of formal volunteering and an 8% change in informal help. By contrast, the 20% most disadvantaged communities experienced a 9% drop in formal volunteering and a 16% drop in informal action. Disadvantaged communities, which had been hit hardest by the recession, were also the communities least able to absorb its shocks.

However, when the academics explored the reason for the decline they found it was not simply that unemployment had gone up or incomes down. The communities and networks people were embedded in had a clear influence, so more affluent areas, which typically have more reciprocal, trusting networks and stronger 'civic infrastructure', could better withstand the shocks of the crisis. Meanwhile disadvantaged areas took a double hit; not only do they typically have weaker civic networks and fewer resources to start with but funding cuts may have further reduced their capacity to recruit volunteers and offer help.

Dr Laurence added: "Without examining the consequences of the for our communities and society we may still be paying for the social deficit long after the budget deficit has disappeared from the national debate."

Explore further: Value of volunteering more than economic

Related Stories

Value of volunteering more than economic

December 14, 2009

With rising unemployment and fewer job vacancies, the current financial crisis has seen renewed policy emphasis in both Europe and the UK on volunteering as a route to employment, according to a new report from the Economic ...

Recommended for you

On-chip, electronically tunable frequency comb

March 18, 2019

Lasers play a vital role in everything from modern communications and connectivity to bio-medicine and manufacturing. Many applications, however, require lasers that can emit multiple frequencies—colors of light—simultaneously, ...

Alligator study reveals insight into dinosaur hearing

March 18, 2019

To determine where a sound is coming from, animal brains analyze the minute difference in time it takes a sound to reach each ear—a cue known as interaural time difference. What happens to the cue once the signals get to ...

1 comment

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

katesisco
not rated yet Jul 09, 2015
The shocking info was that in the most advantaged groups fully 8% of the informal volunteering that is essentially the society's tie dropped. And there would have been no reason for that to happen as they were well buffered from the shock. So it would appear there is another reason for the drop. The 'informal' volunteering is the most essenital as it is done on a one to one basis often out of sight of the members of the society. So once the hard times hit it appears to threaten our security--perhaps financially--so that the informal volunteering may create an unintended reliance --even a greater reliance--that the volunteer is not prepared to fill. A fear that they will be called upon to do even more.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.