Are scientists finally on the brink of understanding where proton spin comes from?

June 1, 2015 by Sophie Hetherton, Institute of Physics
The quark structure of the proton. There are two up quarks in it and one down quark. The strong force is mediated by gluons (wavey). The strong force has three types of charges, the so-called red, green and the blue. Note that the choice of green for the down quark is arbitrary; the "color charge" is thought of as circulating among the three quarks. Credit: Arpad Horvath/Wikipedia

For nearly three decades, physicists have been unable to answer a seemingly simple question: where does proton spin come from?

Summing the spins of the three that make up the seems, in principle, straightforward, however, have been faced with a particularly stubborn imbalance. In 1988 the European Muon Collaboration (EMC) at CERN shocked the physics community by announcing that the sum of the spins of the three quarks that make up the proton is much less than the of the proton itself. This discovery questioned the fundamental idea in physics that the amount of any physical quantity on one side of an equation must equal that on the other side.

EMC researchers discovered that the net spin of the three quarks actually accounted for no more than 24% of the proton's spin and may even contribute as little as 4% – in other words, practically none.

This discovery sparked the beginning of the "spin crisis". Gerhard Mallot, a senior physicist at CERN, recalls how nervous people were and how there were conjectures that the experiment was flawed or even that the underlying theory, known as quantum chromodynamics (QCD), might not be correct.

Further scattering experiments at the Stanford Linear Accelerator Center (SLAC), CERN and the DESY laboratory in Germany eventually confirmed that quark spin contributes 30% (+/-5%) of the total , but that still leaves 65–70% unaccounted for.

In the June 2015 issue of Physics World, science writer Edwin Cartlidge describes how researchers have since devoted their energy to finding alternative possible sources of the proton spin, such as the momenta that quarks and gluons – particles that mediate the strong nuclear force by bonding together quarks of various types – acquire as they rotate around the proton's spin axis, or perhaps the spin of the gluons themselves.

The hot debate between theorists is just how much each of these components contributes to the overall proton spin, and the latest round of data from the Relativistic Heavy Ion Collider (RHIC) at the Brookhaven National Laboratory on Long Island in New York suggests that gluon spin may be the chief culprit.

Werner Vogelsang, a theorist at the University of Tubingen in Germany, says that these results pinning down the gluon spin contribution to 40% have lifted the "crisis mood" surrounding the hunt for the missing spin.

With these confident estimates in, one might expect that only a third of the proton's spin remains up for grabs. However, some physicists believe that the spin problem is far from being solved and are calling for a new machine, the Electron–Ion Collider (EIC), which would combine the punch of proton-beam experiments with the precision of electrons and reach collision energies in the region of 140 GeV.

Vogelsang points out that more data are needed to settle the issue and adds that "The only thing to do is push experiments down to these scales and see what happens there. There might still be surprises lurking."

Explore further: Particle physicists measure the spin contribution of the proton's antiquark

Related Stories

Smashing polarized protons to uncover spin and other secrets

February 11, 2015

If you want to unravel the secrets of proton spin, put a "twist" in your colliding proton beams. This technique, tried and perfected at the Relativistic Heavy Ion Collider (RHIC)—a particle collider and U.S. Department ...

New tool for proton spin

May 6, 2011

How the particles that constitute a proton give rise to is to its rotation, or ‘spin’, is an intriguing open question of contemporary particle physics. A technique that could provide some answers has been developed ...

Protons - Everything Revolves Around Spin

December 17, 2007

Current understanding of the spin structure of protons has been summarised in a single book for the first time. The book examines attempts to solve one of the greatest puzzles of physics. Models and experiments to date have ...

Moving Quarks Help Solve Proton Spin Puzzle

September 11, 2008

( -- New theory work at the U.S. Department of Energy’s Thomas Jefferson National Accelerator Facility has shown that more than half of the spin of the proton is the result of the movement of its building blocks: ...

Recommended for you

Reducing the impact forces of water entry

November 20, 2018

When professional divers jump from a springboard, their hands are perpendicular to the water, with wrists pointed upward, as they continue toward their plunge at 30 mph.

Tiny lasers light up immune cells

November 20, 2018

A team of researchers from the School of Physics at the University of St Andrews have developed tiny lasers that could revolutionise our understanding and treatment of many diseases, including cancer.


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

Mark Thomas
4.6 / 5 (5) Jun 01, 2015
It is a fair bet that if physicists can solve the spin problem they will have made progress on the mass problem as well.
1.7 / 5 (6) Jun 01, 2015
What problem? A proton is a helical loop of charge.
The self repulsion and magnetic pinch of the charge causes spin.
The rotating charge cause a magnetic moment perpendicular to the spin.
The mass is apparent only. Mass is the resonant angular momentum.
And so is the inertia. The simple reason for energy steps is because angular momentum can only resonate at certain diameters or radii.
What's so hard about that.
Modern science is kindergarten science. You will not find answers there.
That's the real problem.
5 / 5 (1) Jun 01, 2015
"This discovery questioned the fundamental idea in physics that the amount of any physical quantity on one side of an equation must equal that on the other side."

Wow. And here I was thinking that the quantities on both sides of an equation are equal by definition.
Steve 200mph Cruiz
not rated yet Jun 02, 2015
Why do specific isotopes have the properties of hadrons if the spins of protons are so weird
not rated yet Jun 02, 2015
The real question is why is the proton spin always +- 1/2: When the three quarks can have unrelated +- spin directions not some simple classical additive fractional relationship.
Its behaving more like a normalisation phenomena; its always exactly 1/2 and we don't know why.
(just like so many quantum sums have to be fudged/normalised to be =1 and we don't know why)
3.4 / 5 (5) Jun 02, 2015
quark spin contributes 30% (+/-5%) of the total proton spin, but that still leaves 65–70% unaccounted for

Hmmm.... dark spin??
not rated yet Jun 02, 2015
So a rotating electron has nothing to do with it? Or magnetic fields? Or circular polarized waves? Or if your head is spinning?
3.7 / 5 (3) Jun 03, 2015
So, if
quarks go from point to point = 25% (measured), and
gluons go from point to point = 40% (measured), then maybe
quarks emit/absorb gluons = 35% ?
Whydening Gyre
3 / 5 (2) Jun 03, 2015
So, if
quarks go from point to point = 25% (measured), and
gluons go from point to point = 40% (measured), then maybe
quarks emit/absorb gluons = 35% ?

Hmmm.... it would appear the sum (proton) really IS greater than the parts (quarks)...
5 / 5 (3) Jun 03, 2015
"Are scientists finally on the brink of understanding where proton spin comes from?" Nope. well done, another informative physorg article. Im no physicist but i seem to recall that the protons have a similiar problem with the mass of its components vs the mass of the whole. Hell of a coincidence if you ask (the lacking higher knowledge) Me.
Whydening Gyre
3 / 5 (2) Jun 04, 2015
So a rotating electron has nothing to do with it? Or magnetic fields? Or circular polarized waves? Or if your head is spinning?

My money is on magnetic fields...
Whydening Gyre
3 / 5 (2) Jun 05, 2015
My money is on magnetic fields...

(making the electrons rotate)
1 / 5 (1) Jun 07, 2015
If electrons (and their spin types) are the fundamental perpetuating force of proton spin; then the solution may rely at the origin of controlling electron spin. The "seat" of consciousness is an excellent candidate for this. From the ideas of Huping Hu, and exemplified in the link below - the conscious may be the origin point for control/influence on the spin of individual electron/quanta; which would then have the effect of exponential outward propagational influence to a larger # of gluon-quark interconnected quantas with eventual dissipation of influence as the numbers increase. With so many availablevconsciousnesses in real-world, this could fill in the 'blanks' and be the true constant source of electron variability within QM, and ultimately the origin of proton spin. The template-like characteristic of the +-1/2 charge proton spin may result from the electron exertion constant of consciousness. @yaboynov
1 / 5 (1) Jun 07, 2015
This will also still allow for the seemingly 'random' (but not truly random) quantum dynamics that occur within this QCD lattice universe, in which photons are the excitation-inducing medium, and the systemic function is resemblant of a warm beer in an ice chest, a form of quantum thermodynamics displayed in a figurative example in which the only observer alive ever looks at the "quantum" of a currently observed situation (1), but in which that "quantum" is immediately dissipated, but not entirely, as the observer shifts their observation about-face to a completely different situation (2). The "quantum" has dissipated immediately, but not entirely, away from situation (1); but the 'not entirely' aspect comes from the quantum template storage of situation (1) in the observers mind/hippocampus (Penrose) - allowing us to revert back to situation (1) with the accompanying quantum shift and it still remain the same without any trace that it had left in the first place.


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.