Scarlet macaw skeletons point to early emergence of Pueblo hierarchy (Update)

June 22, 2015, University of Virginia
This skull of a scarlet macaw (Ara macao) was excavated from Pueblo Bonito in New Mexico by researchers from the American Museum of Natural History in 1897. Credit: © AMNH/D. Finnin

Somehow, colorful tropical scarlet macaws from tropical Mesoamerica—the term anthropologists use to refer to Mexico and parts of northern Central America—ended up hundreds of miles north in the desert ruins of an ancient civilization in what is now New Mexico.

Early scientists began excavating the large Pueblo settlements in Chaco Canyon in northwestern New Mexico and found the birds' remains in the late 1890s, but only recent radiocarbon dating of the physical evidence has pushed back the time period of sophisticated Pueblo culture by at least 150 years, according to a paper published today in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

Co-author and archaeologist Stephen Plog, the University of Virginia's David A. Harrison Professor of Anthropology, worked with Adam S. Watson of the American Museum of Natural History, Douglas J. Kennett of Pennsylvania State University and a team of researchers from the museum and other universities to have macaw bones dated and interpret the results.

Using accelerator mass spectrometry radiocarbon methods with high precision in dating, the researchers found the macaw skeletal remains were much older than previously thought—from as early as the late A.D. 800s—signaling what researchers theorize was a Pueblo culture established enough to form relationships with Mesoamerican cultures to the south. Plog said archaeologists had typically put the beginning of the apex of ancestral Pueblo civilization in Chaco at A.D. 1040, based on other means such as tree-ring dating that suggested a major architectural expansion began at that time.

Anthropologists had already determined that the ancient Pueblo developed a complex social and religious hierarchy in the canyon, reflected in their distinctive architecture. They have posited that Chaco's 'golden century' or the Chaco 'florescence' occurred from A.D. 1040 to 1110, coinciding with a major expansion of the 'great houses.' These great houses contained clustered complexes of rooms for large gatherings, lodgings, storage, burial and religious rituals. Pueblo Bonito, with about 650 rooms in the largest of the great houses of Chaco Canyon, is where most of the macaws were recovered.

'In general, most researchers have argued that emergence of hierarchy, and of extensive trade networks that extended into Mexico coincided with what we see as other aspects of the Chaco florescence: Roads being built outward from Chaco and the formation of what are called Chaco outliers that mimic the

architecture seen in the cultural center,' Plog said.

The radiocarbon dating project, led by Plog, Watson, and Kennett, showed that the bird remains came from as early as the late A.D. 800s to mid 900s. The earlier dating suggests that the rise of Pueblo sociopolitical complexity developed earlier than previously thought.

A modern view of Pueblo Bonito, the largest of the 'great houses' in the pre-Hispanic cultural center of Chaco Canyon, which was occupied between about AD 900 and 1500. Pueblo Bonito had about 650 rooms. Credit: © AMNH/A. Watson

The scarlet macaw is a species of large parrot with red, blue and yellow feathers. The rare birds, which probably came from the Gulf Coast region of Mexico, were a sign of prestige and their feathers used in religious ritual, Plog said. The macaw remains, along with other items including turquoise, shells, and copper bells,,were concentrated in certain areas of Pueblo Bonito, the most extensively excavated great house, particularly an area that included the burial sites of elites who lived in Chaco Canyon's great houses.

The great houses exemplify the distinctiveness of Chaco culture: their size and construction are unusual for early architecture of southwestern Native Americans, whose descendants include the Hopi, Zuni and the many Pueblo groups of the Rio Grande Valley. The structures were made of thick walls of carefully shaped masonry and reinforced with timber; some rooms were unusually large in area and four to five stories high. Pueblo Bonito could have housed up to 500 people, Plog said, although the population numbers are a topic of great debate, he added.

How certain people obtained the scarlet macaws is the subject of conjecture. Archaeologists have several ideas about how relationships might have brought the exotic birds more than 1,000 miles north of their natural range in Mexico and other regions of Mesoamerica but no definitive proof has been found.

'There is no way to tell exactly how they got there,' he said.

'By directly dating the macaws, we have demonstrated the existence of long-distance networks throughout much of this settlement's history,' said Watson, a postdoctoral fellow in the American Museum of Natural History's Division of Anthropology and lead author of the paper. 'Our findings suggest that rather than the acquisition of scarlet macaws being a side-effect of the rise of Chacoan society, there was a causal relationship. The ability to access these trade networks and the ritual power associated with macaws and their feathers may have been important to forming these hierarchies in the first place.'

The birds did not appear to have thrived in the environment of Pueblo Bonito and other sites. Prior analysis of the bones by specialists found the macaws discovered did not live to adulthood. Plog speculated that the rooms they were kept in might've been too dark and cold.

Scarlet macaw feathers were important as ceremonial objects for their colorful variety, not locally common among the area's native birds. The bright colors signified different directions, such as red for south and blue or green for west, for example, Plog said.

The Hyde Exploring Expedition (1896-1900), sponsored by the American Museum of Natural History, excavated the now well-known site of Pueblo Bonito in Chaco Canyon, a pre-Hispanic cultural center in northwestern New Mexico. Credit: © AMNH Library/411866

The macaws, as well as studies of the human burial crypts, provide some of 'the earliest evidence of social hierarchy,' Plog said. High-status individuals would have controlled access to procuring these sacred objects and their ritual power, and likely had the religious knowledge needed to use them, Plog said.

The religious beliefs of Pueblo and nearby indigenous populations have been well-documented and certain aspects continued for a long time.

The paper, 'Early procurement of scarlet macaws and the emergence of social complexity in Chaco Canyon, N.M.,' says 'historical accounts also demonstrate the presence of scarlet macaws at pueblos in the Rio Grande Valley from the 16th to the 20th centuries. A caged macaw observed at Zuni in the 1930s uttered Zuni words and knew the names of several people—surely a significant clue to the value of macaws in general, beyond their iridescent and colorful feathers, as a symbolic vehicle bearing multiple, quasi-human qualities.'

Plog elaborated: 'Birds are in part agents with the power to convey messages. They could bring rain or favorable conditions through their interaction between the Earth and the powers that be.'

Scarlet macaw. Credit: Public Domain

To this day, the Pueblo consider Chaco Canyon a sacred place, Plog said, and not much archaeological excavation is currently being done.

Named a national monument in 1907, Chaco Canyon was added as a national historical park in 1980 and designated a UNESCO World Heritage Site in 1987. Parts of it are open to visitors.

In 2002, Plog and other Southwest archaeologists founded the Chaco Research Archive to preserve the wealth of archaeological data and photographs that were collected, starting in the 1890s and continuing midway through the 20th century, from research conducted by the American Museum of Natural History, the National Geographic Society the Smithsonian Institution, and the University of New Mexico. With funding from the Andrew Mellon Foundation and support from U.Va.'s Institute for Advanced Technology in the Humanities, the Chaco Research Archive team has processed more than 15,000 images from these early excavations, created an architectural database of another 25,000 images, entered more than 40,000 specimens and described excavation data for over 500 rooms from multiple settlements.

Explore further: In Brief: Social inequality among Pueblo Indians

More information: Early procurement of scarlet macaws and the emergence of social complexity in Chaco Canyon, NM, PNAS,

Related Stories

In Brief: Social inequality among Pueblo Indians

November 9, 2010

A study in this week's Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences finds that social hierarchies may have emerged within Southwestern Native American society as early as the 9th century.

Brazil receives macaw pair from Germany

March 4, 2015

A pair of endangered blue macaws of the kind made famous by the hit animated "Rio" movies arrived in Brazil from Germany on Tuesday as part of a drive to ensure the bird's survival.

With many parrots endangered, team sequences macaw genome

May 9, 2013

( —In a groundbreaking move that provides new insight into avian evolution, biology and conservation, researchers at Texas A&M University have successfully sequenced the complete genome of a Scarlet macaw for the ...

New Mexican skies protected with Dark Sky Park designation

September 2, 2013

The 34,000-acre Chaco Culture National Historical Park is home to many ancient wonders including the remains of a civilization that thrived over 1,000 years ago. The park, which has been protecting its archaeological riches ...

Recommended for you

Preventing chemical weapons as sciences converge

November 15, 2018

Alarming examples of the dangers from chemical weapons have been seen recently in the use of industrial chemicals and the nerve agent sarin against civilians in Syria, and in the targeted assassination operations using VX ...

1 comment

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Jun 29, 2015
Mayan traders.
Ancient cultures were highly cosmopolitan.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.