Processing arrested juveniles as adults has small effect on criminal recidivism, study finds

June 9, 2015 by Jacquie Posey, University of Pennsylvania

Researchers at the University of Pennsylvania have found a three to five percent reduction in the probability of criminal recidivism among a sample of juveniles arrested for felony drug offenses, some of whom were processed as adults due to their age at the time of their arrests.

In a study published in the Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency, Charles Loeffler, an assistant professor of criminology in the School of Arts & Sciences, and Ben Grunwald, a doctoral candidate in the department, analyzed the effect of processing juveniles as adults using a regression discontinuity design.

The study, titled "Processed as an Adult: A Regression Discontinuity Estimate of the Crime Effects of Charging Nontransfer Juveniles as Adults," estimated the effect of the juvenile and adult justice systems on recidivism for non-transfer-eligible by comparing the four year re-offending rates of juveniles arrested for drug distribution just a few weeks before and after they reached adulthood.

The results suggested that processing these juveniles as adults slightly reduced the probability of recidivism. Based on the rapid onset and limited change in size of the effects over a four-year follow-up and the concentration of the effects within a sub-group having the lowest risk of incarceration. The researchers attributed this finding to a combination of enhanced deterrence and incapacitation in the adult .

"These results suggest that processing juveniles in the adult system may not uniformly increase offending, as many scholars have thought, and may actually reduce offending in some circumstances," Loeffler said.

The study examined the recidivism of felony drug offenders arrested a few weeks before their 17th birthday who were processed in the and those arrested just a few weeks after their 17th birthday who were processed in the adult .

Past studies have found that serious juvenile offenders transferred into the adult system as part of automatic, presumptive or discretionary transfer mechanisms re-offend much more often than similar juvenile offenders retained in the juvenile system. Such findings have led scholars and policymakers to conclude that exposing youth to the adult justice system exacerbates criminal offending.

However, Loeffler said that the existing empirical literature is primarily focused on the most serious or frequent juvenile offenders. There is relatively little information on the effects of processing more typical juveniles in the adult system. Similarly, the existing literature has used research designs that make it difficult to separate the effects of processing juveniles as adults from pre-existing differences in the risk of recidivism between juveniles who are processed in the two different legal systems.

The results of Loeffler and Grunwald's study, which differed from some of the early empirical literature examining the effects of processing juveniles as , adds to a growing number of studies observing that offending among older is relatively insensitive to the exact legal system in which they are prosecuted. The researchers attributed this divergence between earlier and newer studies to both the samples of offenders examined and the estimation strategies employed.

Explore further: Forest canopies buffer against climate change

More information: "Processed as an Adult: A Regression Discontinuity Estimate of the Crime Effects of Charging Nontransfer Juveniles as Adults Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency." 0022427815581858, first published on June 4, 2015 DOI: 10.1177/0022427815581858

Related Stories

Forest canopies buffer against climate change

April 29, 2015

When temperatures rise and less water falls, forests respond. Forest canopies can buffer juvenile trees from drought and heat by providing shade for the younger trees below the leaf and needle cover. Adult trees have deep ...

Recommended for you

A decade on, smartphone-like software finally heads to space

March 20, 2019

Once a traditional satellite is launched into space, its physical hardware and computer software stay mostly immutable for the rest of its existence as it orbits the Earth, even as the technology it serves on the ground continues ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.