DNA mutations get harder to hide

May 26, 2015, Rice University
Rice University researchers have developed a highly accurate system to locate specific mutations in DNA. David Zhang and J. Sherry Wang tested their work on 44 DNA samples with known cancer-related single-nucleotide variants. Their goal is to advance the development of personalized medicine by helping clinicians catch signs of disease earlier and help determine treatment. Credit: Amanda Shih/NABLab

Rice University researchers have developed a method to detect rare DNA mutations with an approach hundreds of times more powerful than current methods.

The technique allows the researchers to find a figurative needle in a haystack that's smaller than any needle.

Rice researchers David Zhang, an assistant professor of bioengineering, and lead author and graduate student J. Sherry Wang applied their new molecular tools to 44 DNA samples with known cancer-related single-nucleotide variants. Their proof-of-principle study located the variants with a high level of accuracy.

They view their results, which appear today in Nature Chemistry, as a significant step toward advancing personalized medicine. The ability to accurately find mutations that are biomarkers for disease will help clinicians determine treatment paths for patients, Zhang said. It may also help identify rare mutations and subtypes of infectious diseases as well as drug-resistant strains.

A single-nucleotide variant occurs when one of the four basic components that make up DNA or RNA mutates. Nucleotide variations are responsible for an individual's characteristics, like eye color, but mutations can leave the body vulnerable to disease, or even be the root cause. The ability to accurately find rare single-nucleotide mutations is becoming increasingly important as scientists drill down into genomes to find biomarkers for early cancer detection.

"We're trying to solve the needle-in-a-haystack problem," Zhang said. "Basically, how do you detect a very rare mutation in a large pile of healthy DNA molecules? The needle you're looking for might be a cancer-mutation DNA or bacterial-pathogen DNA, and the hay is healthy human DNA, maybe from blood.

"Traditionally, researchers build a magnet that's very good at fishing out the needle," Zhang said. "It's supposed to bind to the needle, but not to the hay. But that only works to a certain extent, and even the best magnets so far can barely pull one needle from 20 pieces of hay or so.

"We decided to add a goat, which goes around and eats hay, so you have a much smaller pile and can pull out your needles."

The challenge, Zhang said, is to keep the competing forces balanced. "There's a very difficult Goldilocks zone of how strong you want your magnet to be and how hungry you want your goat to be," he said. "Our paper basically shows there's a small window in which you can design them to get very high specificity. We can find, on average, one needle for every thousand pieces of hay."

The Rice team's tool involves "competitive compositions" of synthetic reagents that bind to particular gene sequences. What they call the probe (the magnet) and sink (the goat) are sequence-specific DNA molecules that root out single-nucleotide variant targets in solutions that also include healthy "wild-type" sequences. The toehold-based sinks bind to the wild-type DNA and leave the probes to seek out mutations in the target DNA.

Zhang and Wang carried this hybridization technique a step further as they determined the optimal conditions—the window—for each experiment, based on simulations. By simulating experiments in computers and observing the results, they were able to design actual chemistry experiments and reagents with much better performance than traditional trial-and-error approaches. Because the probes' specificity and sensitivity tend to be mutually exclusive except in the narrow Goldilocks zone, finding the zone for each was critical.

Under the right conditions (based on the sequences, the simulation-aided design of the probe and sink, the reagent concentrations and the assay conditions), the lab's custom X-Probes attached to mutant DNA with a particular binding affinity and fluoresced; they ignored wild-type sequences that had slightly different affinity.

Tests on amplified human genome samples showed excellent accuracy as well, they said.

Zhang noted the technique should lead to significant savings, especially for research labs. "Cost is not the primary contribution here, although we did reduce it by a factor of five to 10," he said. "For researchers, it matters whether a test costs $20 or $300, especially if you're doing a multiplexed assay that checks for a few hundred different target mutations.

"The real benefit is still being able to do more specific detection, basically being able to detect mutations at a much earlier phase when there's not as much cancer DNA floating around," he said.

Explore further: Sequencing technique unveiling the realm of viral mutations

More information: "Simulation-guided DNA probe design for consistently ultraspecific hybridization" Nature Chemistry (2015) DOI: 10.1038/nchem.2266

Related Stories

Sequencing technique unveiling the realm of viral mutations

May 13, 2015

Researchers at A*STAR have devised a sequencing technique that can track specific viral variants produced when viruses such as hepatitis B rapidly mutate within individual patients. The breakthrough allows an unprecedented ...

DNA 'cage' could improve nanopore technology

February 10, 2015

Despite having a diameter tens of thousands of times smaller than a human hair, nanopores could be the next big thing in DNA sequencing. By zipping DNA molecules through these tiny holes, scientists hope to one day read off ...

DNA blood test detects lung cancer mutations

April 17, 2015

Cancer DNA circulating in the bloodstream of lung cancer patients can provide doctors with vital mutation information that can help optimise treatment when tumour tissue is not available, an international group of researchers ...

Recommended for you

EPA adviser is promoting harmful ideas, scientists say

March 22, 2019

The Trump administration's reliance on industry-funded environmental specialists is again coming under fire, this time by researchers who say that Louis Anthony "Tony" Cox Jr., who leads a key Environmental Protection Agency ...

Coffee-based colloids for direct solar absorption

March 22, 2019

Solar energy is one of the most promising resources to help reduce fossil fuel consumption and mitigate greenhouse gas emissions to power a sustainable future. Devices presently in use to convert solar energy into thermal ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.