WTO rules against US in tuna label feud with Mexico, again

April 14, 2015
US requirements on "dolphin safe" tuna labelling still discriminate against Mexican-caught tuna, according to a World
US requirements on "dolphin safe" tuna labelling still discriminate against Mexican-caught tuna, according to a World Trade Organization ruling published Tuesday

US requirements on "dolphin safe" tuna labelling still discriminate against Mexican-caught tuna, according to a World Trade Organization ruling published Tuesday.

The United States overhauled its requirements for slapping required "dolphin safe" labels on products after the WTO's dispute settlement body in 2012 found its rules discriminated against Mexican tuna.

But in Tuesday's ruling, a WTO panel agreed with Mexican charges that the US labelling was still violating rules.

The panel found that the US rules were being "applied in a manner that constitutes unjustifiable and arbitrary discrimination contrary to" global trade laws.

For more than 20 years, the United States has required all tuna sold in the country to carry a dolphin-safe stamp, certifying that no dolphins were harmed or killed when it was caught.

The move came amid international efforts to protect the dolphins that often swim alongside tuna and were getting swept into large fishing nets and dying by the millions.

Mexico meanwhile has for the past two decades been challenging the US labelling rules as discriminatory.

The main problem, according to the WTO rulings, is that the US measures are not even-handed in the way they address the risks to dolphins from different fishing techniques in different areas of the ocean.

The global trade body found that US regulations in the eastern tropical Pacific, where the Mexican fleet fishes, are more restrictive than in other waters.

The stakes are high because the tuna trade with the United States is worth billions of dollars, Mexican officials have said.

The United States has 60 days to appeal Tuesday's ruling, a WTO spokesman said.

Once the two months are up, the procedure will be considered closed and Mexico will be permitted to take retaliatory action against the United States if it does not bring its rules in line with the WTO decision.

Explore further: WTO upholds 'rare earth' ruling against China (Update)

Related Stories

WTO upholds 'rare earth' ruling against China (Update)

August 7, 2014

The World Trade Organization has upheld a ruling that China violated trade rules with restrictions on the export of "rare earths," the minerals used in mobile phones, hybrid cars and other high-tech products.

WTO rules against EU on hi-tech duties

August 16, 2010

The World Trade Organization has backed the United States, Japan and Taiwan in their complaint against EU duties on high-technology products, according to a ruling published Monday.

Recommended for you

Machine learning identifies links between world's oceans

March 21, 2019

Oceanographers studying the physics of the global ocean have long found themselves facing a conundrum: Fluid dynamical balances can vary greatly from point to point, rendering it difficult to make global generalizations.

How fluid viscosity affects earthquake intensity

March 21, 2019

Fault zones play a key role in shaping the deformation of the Earth's crust. All of these zones contain fluids, which heavily influence how earthquakes propagate. In an article published today in Nature Communications, Chiara ...

0 comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.