Domestic violence victims may be hurt by mandatory arrest laws

Domestic violence victims may be hurt by mandatory arrest laws
Credit: University of Akron

"Just call the police, they have to do something," is sometimes the advice given to a woman who reveals that she is a victim of intimate partner violence (IPV), more commonly called domestic violence. The thinking behind the advice is a positive opinion that mandatory arrest—a policy that was created in an effort to curb domestic violence—is an effective way to stop the abuse. The law, active in 22 states including Ohio, says that police officers responding to a call for help would no longer need to determine whether one person was truly violent or out of control; every time someone reported abuse, the police would simply be required to make an arrest. But research suggests that the law may be intimidating victims from actually calling the police to report an instance of abuse.

A recent study by sociologists Dr. Robert Peralta at The University of Akron and Meghan Novisky of Kent State University looked at how victim perceptions of mandatory arrest policies, perpetrator substance use, and presence of children are related to decisions to invoke assistance. In "When Women Tell: Intimate Partner Violence and the Factors Related to Police Notification," published in January 2015 in the journal Violence Against Women, the researchers evaluated survey responses of 101 women receiving care in shelters.

Their study found that as victim support for mandatory arrest increases, the odds of law enforcement notification of the abuse also increase. But accordingly, mandatory arrest may simply be reducing the probability of reporting (IPV) among those who do not support the policy.

"A reason a woman may not report abuse because of mandatory arrest policies is that they fear retaliation by the abuser may be worse because an arrest is mandatory," comments Novisky. Another reason is that a woman may believe the police will mistakenly arrest her as the aggressor, so she won't report it. This reasoning supports the data that mandatory arrest policies result in higher arrest rates of battered women, which could deprive them of the support they need.

While their study focused only on three factors, Peralta asserts that "it is important to note that race, ethnicity, sexuality, and social class background may also shape or inform decisions to contact the police." Based on their findings regarding mandatory arrest, he continues, "Variations in experiences and attitudes toward should also be considered in the development and implementation of policy decisions that will have a direct impact on the safety and wellbeing of members of our community."

Peralta and Novisky conclude their study with a caution that mandatory arrest policies may be increasing perceptions among women that the costs of reporting are too high for the consideration of involving law enforcement. "The utility of mandatory arrest for the long-term assistance of victims of IPV must be questioned," they write.


Explore further

Mandatory arrest in domestic violence call-outs causes early death in victims

Citation: Domestic violence victims may be hurt by mandatory arrest laws (2015, March 26) retrieved 23 August 2019 from https://phys.org/news/2015-03-domestic-violence-victims-mandatory-laws.html
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.
26 shares

Feedback to editors

User comments

Mar 26, 2015
As a former victim of long-term domestic violence I learned to NEVER call the police. The police often did not believe me because there were no obvious physical marks on my body. Some officers were condescending and one officer even told me to never call them again. On another occasion I was arrested (but not charged with anything) instead of my boyfriend and held over the weekend. The arresting officer thought that the experience would encourage me to leave my abusive boyfriend. After that my boyfriend would threaten to get me arrested again if I tried to talk to the police. He was always calm and in control and would sound so reasonable plus he often did have marks on him from where I fought back. Meanwhile I would be hysterical and in tears and not a mark on me (although bruises were often visible later). I learned over the years that police do not understand domestic violence and that they often hold its victims in contempt.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more