We're all mammals – so why do we look so different?

February 23, 2015 by Diego Villar Lozano, The Conversation
Family values. Credit: Shutterstock

It is easy to distinguish a mouse from a cow. But for members of the same class of mammal, where do such differences begin? In 2011, scientists discovered there were differences in cow and mice blastocysts, the tiny hollow spheres of cells which precede the development of the embryo.

So while adult are easily distinguishable, it was remarkable that the researchers were able to still tell the difference at this extremely early stage of development. This early difference was largely due to the crucial process of .

Mammalian species are all quite different in look and size, and have colonised all – they can be terrestrial (like humans and mice), aquatic (dolphins and whales) and even aerial (bats). Like humans, all mammals have large, complex genomes – the DNA sequences in our cells. These contain the instructions which are used to construct our bodies and brains. However, the best-understood functional units in our DNA – our genes – take up only 2% of our genome sequence, and are extremely similar across non-marsupial mammals. So what makes us so different?

Classical studies – for example, those by geneticists Mary-Claire King and Allan Wilson, have shown that the major differences between lie not in the genes themselves, but where genes are switched on and off – that is, in gene regulation.

Understanding gene regulation in mammals is very challenging. The DNA sequences that regulate our genes – so-called – are painstaking to identify. These sequences are spread across our vast genome, and are largely different for each of our tissues. To decipher gene regulation in mammals, we need to locate them and understand how they change as the animal evolves.

Gene regulation evolves

Not your average looker. Credit: Buffenstein/Barshop Institute/UTHSCSA, CC BY

As evolution progresses and mammalian species diverge, various genes are switched on an off. So which aspects of our genome stay the same and where are the changes taking place?

New experimental and computational tools for DNA sequencing are now making it possible to identify regulatory elements and their activity with unprecedented accuracy and speed. These tools allow us to study gene regulation across mammalian genomes, as has been done for humans and mice, but much less so for recently sequenced genomes, such as those of species with unique adaptations - dolphins or subterranean cancer-resistant naked mole rats among them.

In a recent study published in Cell, we found the extent of gene regulation differences – the "on/off" switching – across mammals was astonishing. It is rare that the DNA sequences that regulate our genes show similar activities across mammals. More commonly, gene regulatory activities change rapidly as mammals evolve (though still over millions of years – for example, humans and chimps are separated by 6m years of evolution), and such differences probably lead to different genes switching on and off.

In fact, a good fraction of the regulatory elements that we identified in each mammalian genome were active in a single mammal (out of the 20 analysed), which suggests that these regulatory elements may be associated with recent evolutionary adaptations unique to a few species.

Repurposing

So how do such vast numbers of newly active regulatory sequences arise? Our findings suggest that, rather than acquiring wholly new DNA sequences that regulate genes, mammals derive most regulatory innovations from existing DNA – sequences shared to some extent by all mammals today and likely present in the ancestral species from which they evolved – but repurposed in a particular species.

This process resembles evolutionary tinkering, where continuous tweaking of existing DNA sequences can result in new patterns of gene regulation. The prevalence of this mechanism, as opposed to the generation of regulatory elements from newly acquired DNA, could in part explain the rapid evolution we see in mammals, and may have been pivotal in allowing mammals to efficiently colonise Earth's ecosystems. Essentially, continuous modifications in vast mammalian genomes within relatively small populations likely contributed to new evolutionary paths that allowed mammal species to diverge.

Many questions remain. Our results indicate how rapidly gene regulation can change in mammalian genomes, but further work will be required to fully understand the relative importance of the retained and new DNA sequences that regulate our genes, and how they cooperate to create species diversity while maintaining the organ functions found across vertebrates. And our findings could have profound implications for our understanding of human disease – in particular, the mechanisms by which rapidly evolving pathologies, such as cancer, hijack normal gene regulation and alter it to their advantage.

Explore further: Why is a dolphin not a cat? How repurposing non-coding elements in genome gave rise to great 'mammalian radiation'

Related Stories

Rare form of active 'jumping genes' found in mammals

January 3, 2013

Much of the DNA that makes up our genomes can be traced back to strange rogue sequences known as transposable elements, or jumping genes, which are largely idle in mammals. But Johns Hopkins researchers report they have identified ...

Cancer risk linked to DNA 'wormholes'

February 19, 2015

Single-letter genetic variations within parts of the genome once dismissed as 'junk DNA' can increase cancer risk through wormhole-like effects on far-off genes, new research shows.

Scientists map mouse genome's 'mission control centers'

November 19, 2014

When the mouse and human genomes were catalogued more than 10 years ago, an international team of researchers set out to understand and compare the "mission control centers" found throughout the large stretches of DNA flanking ...

Recommended for you

Paleontologists report world's biggest Tyrannosaurus rex

March 22, 2019

University of Alberta paleontologists have just reported the world's biggest Tyrannosaurus rex and the largest dinosaur skeleton ever found in Canada. The 13-metre-long T. rex, nicknamed "Scotty," lived in prehistoric Saskatchewan ...

NASA instruments image fireball over Bering Sea

March 22, 2019

On Dec. 18, 2018, a large "fireball—the term used for exceptionally bright meteors that are visible over a wide area—exploded about 16 miles (26 kilometers) above the Bering Sea. The explosion unleashed an estimated 173 ...

1 comment

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

Moebius
5 / 5 (1) Feb 23, 2015
We don't look different actually. We see animals as being different for the same reason we see each other as being different. If you took one of us and any 5 land animals about the same size, skinned them and showed them to an alien he would think they were all almost the same thing. Even with a close look at anatomy he would still see us being slight variations on a theme.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.