The persistent Internet hoax endures, now on Facebook

January 12, 2015 by Andrew Smith, The Conversation
Try and pay more attention. Credit: lculig/Shutterstock

With somewhere in the region of 1.3 billion users, Facebook is the largest ever internet social engagement phenomenon. With so many people interconnected through the site, information can speedily propagate around the world – without any clear indication whether it is correct – and this has given new life to the phenomenon of the internet hoax.

Once hoaxes arrived as urgent steps to carry out to remove viruses that didn't exist from your computer, or warnings about waking up in a bath of ice with no kidneys. On Facebook, one of the most frequently repeated is of the supposed power of making a declaration of rights over the user's own content to prevent Facebook from using it for . For the record, declaring that under various (non existent) conventions that Facebook has no right to use your data is wholly meaningless.

Here we have the dilemma of using a service provided for free by Facebook, yet we are all keen to protect our privacy. Facebook, a commercial organisation, makes its money from mining our data to offer ever more accurate advertising. Our data is the company's bread and butter, and it can easily manipulate our feeds to make sure that we see something that of interest.

Of course the company sets valid and, in its view, reasonable terms and conditions – if users don't like it, they can easily leave. But of course hundreds of millions of people enjoy Facebook, like it (pun intended) for its social aspect, for being able to communicate with friends, family and find like-minded others. Many community organisations, charities and even companies rely heavily on the power of their Facebook presence to reach wider audiences. Yet the hoaxers know that we all react strongly to the word "privacy".

Perhaps you’ve not thought this through. Credit: knowyourmeme

So, back to privacy. Will you fall for this hoax or any others? Those researching the phenomenon have established that we are likely to fall for one, at some point. The reality is, if a friend who is someone you trust posts something the tendency is to believe it, and be willing to share it with others.

If it seems plausible and relates to something you care about, the chances are you will consider re-posting. This is no different to telling others about something you have discovered. I do not know how many times I have seen articles on the untimely death of Macaulay Culkin (which are not true).

This is not new, and there have been many famous historical hoaxes, especially those involving the then new techniques of radio or photography. Though a misunderstanding rather than a hoax, Orson Welles' rendition of HG Wells' War of the Worlds on radio was convincing to many in the 1930s. Think about it: the world's political climate was tense, the radio news broadcast is a trusted social communication medium, you can forgive their confusion.

The risk with hoaxes on social media is that they can be used as click bait, encouraging victims to follow the link to a website which could compromise or infect their computer or device. Hoaxes purporting to represent apparently authentic campaigns for environmental causes, for or against government policy, or for human rights abroad, can acquire an email and password and use them for malicious intent.

So while some hoaxes are simply childish entertainment, others do have a cynical side. If you are ever unsure, no matter how well you know whichever friend posted it to Facebook, websites such as Hoax Slayer or Snopes are well-informed and filled with information debunking or explaining the origins of almost every dubious internet claim.

If you discover your friend is sharing a hoax, be a great friend and show them the error of their ways, as the chances are it is spreading through Facebook to thousands of other contacts even as you read it.

Explore further: Facebook boosts search on mobile, desktop

Related Stories

Facebook boosts search on mobile, desktop

December 9, 2014

Facebook said Monday it is rolling out upgraded search capabilities for mobile and desktop users who want to find favorite posts from their friends on the huge social network.

Facebook rolls out 'privacy checkup'

September 5, 2014

Facebook on Thursday began rolling out its "privacy checkup" aimed at helping users of the huge social network better manage sharing their information and postings.

Facebook nixes rumors on copyright shift

November 27, 2012

Facebook is telling its users to ignore rumors spreading on the social network that they need to post a statement to protect their copyrights of their comments and other materials.

Recommended for you

1 comment

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

5 / 5 (1) Jan 14, 2015
Since I value my privacy, I decline to be a used of Facebook. The Free Software Foundation, a charity of which I am president, also declines to try to connect with anyone through Facebook; we have a web site,

I hope you too will take a stand for privacy by refusing to be used by Facebook. See

Dr Richard Stallman
President, Free Software Foundation (,
Internet Hall-of-Famer (
MacArthur Fellow

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.