Apple's growing patent portfolio offers clues about future products

Apple logo

A computer mouse that doubles as a scanner. A coating that keeps gadgets safe and dry even in the event of a spill. And a smartphone that rotates like a cat midair to avoid landing on its pretty glass face.

You may not see them on shelves anytime soon, but they are among the inventions that Apple protected in 2014 as it took in a bumper crop of new patents. The U.S. Patent and Trademark Office granted Apple 2,003 utility patents, which recognize new and useful processes and machines. That's a 13 percent increase over 2013 and more than triple the 's 2010 haul, according to IFI Claims, a patent analysis firm. The steady increase in patents comes as Apple is doubling down on research and development, pouring $6 billion into its labs in fiscal year 2014, which ended in September. The investments suggest the company is laying the groundwork to find its next lucrative products, recognizing that it can't coast if it wants to stay in investors' good graces, Gartner analyst Van Baker said.

"When you're that big, and you want to continue to grow at a rate that the market is going to reward, you have to expand your business," he said.

Although companies commonly patent ideas they do not ultimately use, the evolving makeup of Apple's portfolio points to spaces the company may be mining for future growth. Among other areas, the company has amassed more intellectual property related to television, a household staple ripe for reinvention, and cybersecurity, one of the tech industry's greatest headaches after a series of worrisome hacks.

The tech titan's burgeoning patent portfolio mirrors a shift underway in Silicon Valley and across the globe as companies worldwide are racing to protect nearly everything their engineers come up with, said Larry Cady, vice president of product marketing at IFI Claims. Grants climbed more than 8 percent to cross the 300,000 threshold for the first time in 2014, with many companies besting their records. Apple ranked 11th on IFI's list of top patent recipients and, in the Bay Area, second only to Google, which took eighth place with 2,566 patents in 2014, up nearly 39 percent from the previous year. IBM brought home the most patents, as it has for 22 years running, and valley stalwarts such as Hewlett-Packard and Cisco also showed solid gains, upping their tallies by 16 percent and 24 percent, respectively.

While Cady says many companies are investing more in research and development, he suspects they are also building their portfolios with an eye toward the courtroom, where they can use their patents as either a sword to try to knock out competing products or a shield against such attacks. Cady thinks it's more than coincidental that Apple, Google and Samsung - the three key players in a series of high-stakes patent trials over smartphone technology that have been unfolding in San Jose federal court - are among the top patent recipients this year.

"If you can't beat them, join them," David Maizenberg, who consults on matters, said of the patent race.

A patent gives a company the right to use an invention exclusively for a limited period of time. But the trade-off is that the firm must offer up a glimpse of what it is working on, which is notoriously hard to come by at Apple headquarters.

A spokesman for Apple declined to comment on the company's patents.

According to data supplied by IFI, the types of technology for which Apple won the most patents in 2014 were computer graphics, mobile communications and computer software. That suggests the company is continuing to focus on its strengths, such as the powerhouse iPhone, which drives more than half its sales.

But the company also has steadily earned more patents related to television, bringing home 73 in 2014, up from 28 in 2012 and a mere eight in 2011, according to IFI. That may be good news for Apple fans and investors who have long been waiting for the company to reimagine the television set. One patent granted in December describes technology that would stream content simultaneously on a fixed device such as an Apple TV and a portable gadget such as a smartphone, letting users leave their living rooms to grab snacks without missing a moment of their favorite shows. Another patent describes a new-age wand that users would wave to pick shows, rather than clicking old-fashioned remotes.

The company's also suggests a growing interest in security, with grants related to information security climbing 44 percent to 39 patents and grants related to cryptography climbing 25 percent to 15 patents, according to IFI. The company must keep security top of mind as it designs its gadgets, Baker noted.

"It's an important consideration in mobile devices because we're living in a world where there are more and more threats in terms of malware, cyberespionage, identity theft and hacks," he said.

IFI tracks utility patents, the most common type of award granted by the patent office.

To be sure, are an imperfect predictor of future products, often revealing more about the breadth of engineers' imaginations than the next gadgets they plan to build.

"Sometimes companies are just covering themselves for research they've invested in, even though it's not really in the product road map," Cady said.

But when it comes to Apple, the faintest possibility of a new device is enough to cause investors to sit up and take notice. Patently Apple, a blog that tracks patent filings from Apple, recently spotted that the company had earned a patent for a wearable video camera that sounded a lot like GoPro's specialty. The action-camera maker's stock sank about 12 percent on the news.

Despite the threat some perceive to GoPro, many ideas Apple pitched to the last year don't seem ready for market. One patent the company earned described an elaborate system to protect mobile phones when they fall. Sketches show a smartphone using sensors to change its orientation so it lands on a metal side and deploying jets, fans and gas canisters to slow its descent. Meanwhile, particularly delicate parts of the device such as the screen and home button would retract before impact.

Furthering the bid for an indestructible iPhone, Apple also landed a patent for a coating that would cause moisture to form beads, posing less danger to delicate electronics. The company also dreamed up creative accessories for the Mac. One patent covers a computer mouse that uses a sensor to capture the images it glides over and then displays them on its face.

In other instances, Apple appeared to be thinking further outside the bounds of its current product lineup. The company won a patent for a display that would allow users to view real-world objects with information overlaid, perhaps telling tourists more about the sites they're glimpsing through the windows of a bus.

Regardless of what Apple has cooking in its tightly veiled labs, experts say it is encouraging to see patent grants and R&D spending on the rise.

"I take it as a strong indication that innovation is alive and well at the company," said Stephen Haber, a senior fellow at Stanford University and the Hoover Institution.

Explore further

Apple camera patent gives GoPro stock jitters

©2015 San Jose Mercury News (San Jose, Calif.)
Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC

Citation: Apple's growing patent portfolio offers clues about future products (2015, January 29) retrieved 17 August 2019 from
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

Feedback to editors

User comments

Jan 29, 2015
6 billion in R&D by a company that isn't supposed to be able to innovate any more? They must either be doing black hole research or all the negative Apple analysts are full of cr(a)p. Amazing, Apple has a blow out quarter and a moron was on within an hour with the same tired cliches about Apple that have been proved wrong almost every quarter and will continue to be proved wrong. Apple is doing everything right and its detractors are liars who just try to keep the stock down.

Jan 29, 2015
I think intellectual property is a good concept and is well intended 98% of the time. But why fill zillion patent you will never use? Ok some time used to sue competitor who would make round corner edge devices or icon looking to close but other than that? I'm a happy apple user, willing to pay extra 35% more to benefit of it but happy they did not deviated in car industry fearing they patent the wheel... I just don't get it.

Jan 30, 2015
"... The company won a patent for a display that would allow users to view real-world objects with information overlaid, ...."
Every sh.t coming from this company is granted by the USPTO... :-(
Concepts as the above are hardly new or inventive.
But maybe the patent is about displaying said information on a
screen on a phone with rounded edges...

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more