Talking to aliens

November 17, 2014 by Seth Shostak, SETI

What do you say to a space alien? This question might not be the foremost puzzle in your life, but it was the subject of a lively two-day conference at California's SETI Institute this week.

Here's why: A decade of research by astronomers now suggests that a trillion planets dot the Milky Way. It takes a real Debbie Downer to believe that they're all as dead as the Equal Rights Amendment. Unless Earth is special beyond reason, you can confidently assume there are plenty of societies out there.

That doesn't mean that they'll come to Earth (or, as many believe, already have). Interstellar travel, despite what you've seen at the local multiplex, is hard. But we could easily get in touch via or flashing laser lights.

SETI—the Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence—is already scanning the skies, looking for such signals. So far, they haven't found any. But some practitioners figure we should also transmit signals; that we should try speaking without first being spoken to.

Doing so would raise a lot of questions. For example, in which directions should you beam your broadcast, and how do you encode the message? In addition, there's the prickly argument over whether betraying our existence could lead to trouble.

All worthy of consideration. But this week's conference had a narrower focus: message content. If we decide to pick up the phone, what are we going to talk about?

To get as wide a range of viewpoints as possible, the conference organizer, the Institute's Director of Interstellar Message Composition Doug Vakoch, brought together an international crowd of anthropologists, philosophers, linguists, astronomers, archaeologists, social psychologists, journalists and designers. As you might imagine, this inhomogeneous group frequently arrived at opposite conclusions despite starting with similar premises.

For example, what's the best way to make a message understandable to minds that might be organized in ways far different than our own? Some argued that any society with the kit necessary for detecting broadcasts from Earth will have mastered mathematics and chemistry. We should use these as touchstones to encode our messages. But try writing an essay about love or local government using only mathematical symbols, and you'll quickly discover that this isn't easy (and seldom poetic).

"Send the equivalent of a Rosetta Stone," was the cry of other participants. And after all, that does sound like a great way to help the aliens quickly learn some earthly language. Of course, the "stone" needs to have parallel texts with another language or two, but maybe you could substitute pictures—a kind of picture dictionary. Easy squeezy.

But a linguist precipitated on this parade by noting that—given the uncertainties about why Homo sapiens even has language (is it merely a talent conferred by a random genetic mutation that hit our species 150,000 years ago?), there's no guarantee that the extraterrestrials will be blessed with the gift of gab. They might not have language any more than we have a great sense of smell.

Which brings us back to pictures. Why not simply tell them about ourselves by sending images of artifacts? Time capsules are precedent, one participant noted. They're small collections of contemporary culture that are sealed, buried and sent to the future, if not into space. Clever idea, but if we send the Klingons the radio equivalent of a time capsule, do we put in everything? Do we tell them about our cruelties, and about poverty and war? Or is it better to only display our better natures?

A leitmotiv of the conference—one thing that just about everyone felt they could agree on—was to beware of anthropocentrism. Don't assume that the way we think or describe things will be the same for the extraterrestrials. Context and local knowledge are the frameworks of our daily lives, and it's easy to forget that these are peculiar to us, both in place and in time. The aliens will not get our jokes, our literature, or our reality TV. Their minds, presumably vast and deep, could be as different from ours as those of bats and beetles.

It's a tough problem, and my own contribution was to opine that—rather than wrestle endlessly with what we should say—we send it all. Or at least send a lot. I suggested that we transmit the contents of the Internet, or some large subset thereof, rather than offering up more "greeting cards" similar to those that have been bolted onto some of our spacecraft. Sure, there's a lot of silly stuff on the web—it's not curated, to use the language of museums. But it's wide-ranging, covers a lot of human activity, and is highly redundant. For example, the concept of "automobile" is present in descriptions, photos, and videos. That redundancy will help them—assuming they have the processing power—to figure out a lot of what we've sent.

In movies, the aliens are almost always fluent in colloquial, American English. That's handy, and it eases the burden on both actors and audience. Communicating with these well-spoken beings from beyond Earth is a slam dunk.

But if and when we decide to send a shout-out to other worlds, we should first abandon the idea that the inhabitants of those distant locales have our mind set—or even a similar mind.

Explore further: How to Respond When E.T. Says Hello

Related Stories

How to Respond When E.T. Says Hello

April 1, 2010

Scientists are studying the best ways to compose messages meant for alien eyes in case we ever do get the chance to communicate with extraterrestrials.

Preparing for alien life

November 10, 2014

At a recent event sponsored by NASA and the Library of Congress, a group of scientists and scholars explored how we might prepare for the inevitable discovery of life beyond Earth.

Refining the search for what's 'out there'

October 15, 2010

Gregory Benford, his brother James and his nephew Dominic decided to combine their knowledge of astrophysics, space, microwaves and economics to look at the search for extraterrestrial life from a money perspective. They ...

Recommended for you

Engineering cellular function without living cells

March 25, 2019

Genes in living cells are activated – or not – by proteins called transcription factors. The mechanisms by which these proteins activate certain genes and deactivate others play a fundamental role in many biological processes. ...

What ionized the universe?

March 25, 2019

The sparsely distributed hot gas that exists in the space between galaxies, the intergalactic medium, is ionized. The question is, how? Astronomers know that once the early universe expanded and cooled enough, hydrogen (its ...

Catalyst advance removes pollutants at low temperatures

March 25, 2019

Researchers at Washington State University, University of New Mexico, Eindhoven University of Technology, and Pacific Northwest National Laboratory have developed a catalyst that can both withstand high temperatures and convert ...

6 comments

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

Whydening Gyre
not rated yet Nov 17, 2014
Every other universe in the Mega/multiverse might be teeming with intelligence but it doesn't, by definition, matter.

That's because all the REALLY good lookin girls are gonna go out with the guys from Camp Northstar - ANYway...
kochevnik
1 / 5 (1) Nov 17, 2014
Earth must be a wilderness preserve. Or perhaps it's being held fallow until the prices for unobtanium go up again, then the inhabitants will be served for dinner
Scroofinator
not rated yet Nov 17, 2014
I thought the movie Contact hit it on the head - math - the universal language.
Mimath224
not rated yet Nov 17, 2014
I thought the movie Contact hit it on the head - math - the universal language.

Mmmm, I haven't seen that movie and I'm not sure that math IS the U.L. Suppose one has a 'first contact' where no prior messages were sent or received. The situation will depend on Physics, a hand shake, nod of head, a smile. Remember that Klatu in the 1950's original 'The day the Earth stood still', got shot for offering a gift. Yes, okay that was all English script but the message there was 'beware of strangers bearing gifts'. So perhaps the idea might be to have explorers on hand who have experience in communicating with unknown tribes, not mathematicians. I agree that math could then used afterward as a tool for constructing a language. Unfortunately, I don't think that's how it would happen more like in the movie I mentioned, military at the ready.
db_sciencex
not rated yet Nov 18, 2014
In talks with some experienced & trained observers some things to consider when it comes to messaging aliens fall along the lines of their reasons for coming to earth in the first place and the fact that their advanced capabilities and intelligences do not rule out criminal intent as well as the real possibilities for them to look at earth's inhabitants very much as the explorers of old did with Native Indian peoples of The Americas.

According to famed physicist Stephen Hawking If intelligent alien life forms do exist out in the vastness of the space, they might not be the friendly cosmic neighbors the people of Earth are looking for.
Here are some other thoughts he shared in a documentary: "An advanced spacefaring extraterrestrial civilization could end up wandering the universe in enormous spaceships on the prowl for vital materials after consuming the natural resources of their own world, Hawking explains in an episode of the show "Into the Universe with Stephen Hawking
Mimath224
not rated yet Nov 18, 2014
Here are some other thoughts he shared in a documentary: "An advanced spacefaring extraterrestrial civilization could end up wandering the universe in enormous spaceships on the prowl for vital materials after consuming the natural resources of their own world, Hawking explains in an episode of the show "Into the Universe with Stephen Hawking

Yeah, I have that movie. If that be the case then we probably wouldn't know until it's too late...assuming they wanted the same resources as we do. So perhaps our only hope would be that we meet the friendly aliens first.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.