First ultraluminous pulsar: NuSTAR discovers impossibly bright dead star

October 8, 2014 by Kimm Fesenmaier
High-energy X-rays streaming from a rare and mighty pulsar (magenta), the brightest found to date, can be seen in this new image combining multi-wavelength data from three telescopes. The bulk of a galaxy called Messier 82 (M82), or the 'Cigar galaxy,' is seen in visible-light data captured by the National Optical Astronomy Observatory's 2.1-meter telescope at Kitt Peak in Arizona. Starlight is white, and lanes of dust appear brown. Low-energy X-ray data from NASA's Chandra X-ray Observatory are colored blue, and higher-energy X-ray data from NuSTAR are pink. Credit: NASA/JPL-Caltech/SAO/NOAO

Astronomers working with NASA's Nuclear Spectroscopic Telescope Array (NuSTAR), led by Caltech's Fiona Harrison, have found a pulsating dead star beaming with the energy of about 10 million suns. The object, previously thought to be a black hole because it is so powerful, is in fact a pulsar—the incredibly dense rotating remains of a star.

"This compact little stellar remnant is a real powerhouse. We've never seen anything quite like it," says Harrison, NuSTAR's principal investigator and the Benjamin M. Rosen Professor of Physics at Caltech. "We all thought an object with that much energy had to be a black hole."

Dom Walton, a postdoctoral scholar at Caltech who works with NuSTAR data, says that with its extreme energy, this takes the top prize in the weirdness category. Pulsars are typically between one and two times the mass of the sun. This new pulsar presumably falls in that same range but shines about 100 times brighter than theory suggests something of its mass should be able to.

"We've never seen a pulsar even close to being this bright," Walton says. "Honestly, we don't know how this happens, and theorists will be chewing on it for a long time." Besides being weird, the finding will help scientists better understand a class of very bright X-ray sources, called ultraluminous X-ray sources (ULXs).

Harrison, Walton, and their colleagues describe NuSTAR's detection of this first ultraluminous pulsar in a paper that appears in the current issue of Nature.

"This was certainly an unexpected discovery," says Harrison. "In fact, we were looking for something else entirely when we found this."

This animation shows a neutron star—the core of a star that exploded in a massive supernova. This particular neutron star is known as a pulsar because it sends out rotating beams of X-rays that sweep past Earth like lighthouse beacons. Credit: NASA/JPL-Caltech

Earlier this year, astronomers in London detected a spectacular, once-in-a-century supernova (dubbed SN2014J) in a relatively nearby galaxy known as Messier 82 (M82), or the Cigar Galaxy, 12 million light-years away. Because of the rarity of that event, telescopes around the world and in space adjusted their gaze to study the aftermath of the explosion in detail.

Besides the supernova, M82 harbors a number of other ULXs. When Matteo Bachetti of the Université de Toulouse in France, the lead author of this new paper, took a closer look at these ULXs in NuSTAR's data, he discovered that something in the galaxy was pulsing, or flashing light.

"That was a big surprise," Harrison says. "For decades everybody has thought these ultraluminous X-ray sources had to be . But black holes don't have a way to create this pulsing."

But pulsars do. They are like giant magnets that emit radiation from their magnetic poles. As they rotate, an outside observer with an X-ray telescope, situated at the right angle, would see flashes of powerful light as the beam swept periodically across the observer's field of view, like a lighthouse beacon.

The reason most astronomers had assumed black holes were powering ULXs is that these X-ray sources are so incredibly bright. Black holes can be anywhere from 10 to billions of times the mass of the sun, making their gravitational tug much stronger than that of a pulsar. As matter falls onto the black hole the gravitational energy turns it to heat, which creates X-ray light. The bigger the black hole, the more energy there is to make the object shine.

Surprised to see the flashes coming from M82, the NuSTAR team checked and rechecked the data. The flashes were really there, with a pulse showing up every 1.37 seconds.

The next step was to figure out which X-ray source was producing the flashes. Walton and several other Caltech researchers analyzed the data from NuSTAR and a second NASA X-ray telescope, Chandra, to rule out about 25 different X-ray sources, finally settling on a ULX known as M82X-2 as the source of the flashes.

With the pulsar and its location within M82 identified, there are still many questions left to answer. It is many times higher than the Eddington limit, a basic physics guideline that sets an upper limit on the brightness that an object of a given mass should be able to achieve.

"This is the most extreme violation of that limit that we've ever seen," says Walton. "We have known that things can go above that by a small amount, but this blows that limit away."

NuSTAR is particularly well-suited to make discoveries like this one. Not only does the space telescope see high-energy X-rays, but it sees them in a unique way. Rather than snapping images the way that your cell-phone camera does—by integrating the light such that images blur if you move—NuSTAR detects individual particles of X-ray light and marks when they are measured. That allows the team to do timing analyses and, in this case, to see that the light from the ULX was coming in pulses.

Now that the NuSTAR team has shown that this ULX is a pulsar, Harrison points out that many other known ULXs may in fact be pulsars as well. "Everybody had assumed all of these sources were black holes," she says. "Now I think people have to go back to the drawing board and decide whether that's really true. This could just be a very unique, strange object, or it could be that they're not that uncommon. We just don't know. We need more observations to see if other ULXs are pulsing."

Explore further: Pulse of a dead star powers intense gamma rays

More information: An Ultraluminous X-ray Source Powered by An Accreting Neutron Star, Nature,

Related Stories

The search for medium-sized black holes

November 27, 2013

Black holes can be petite, with masses only about 10 times that of our sun—or monstrous, boasting the equivalent in mass up to 10 billion suns. Do black holes also come in size medium? NASA's Nuclear Spectroscopic Telescope ...

NuSTAR celebrates two years of science in space

August 1, 2014

( —NASA's Nuclear Spectroscopic Telescope Array, or NuSTAR, a premier black-hole hunter among other talents, has finished up its two-year prime mission, and will be moving onto its next phase, a two-year extension.

Dead star and distant black holes dazzle in X-rays

January 9, 2014

( —Two new views from NASA's Nuclear Spectroscopic Telescope Array, or NuSTAR, showcase the telescope's talent for spying objects near and far. One image shows the energized remains of a dead star, a structure ...

NuSTAR sees rare blurring of black hole light

August 12, 2014

NASA's Nuclear Spectroscopic Telescope Array (NuSTAR) has captured an extreme and rare event in the regions immediately surrounding a supermassive black hole. A compact source of X-rays that sits near the black hole, called ...

Recommended for you

Solar eruptions could electrify Martian moons

October 18, 2017

Powerful solar eruptions could electrically charge areas of the Martian moon Phobos to hundreds of volts, presenting a complex electrical environment that could possibly affect sensitive electronics carried by future robotic ...

Potential human habitat located on the moon

October 18, 2017

A study published in Geophysical Research Letters confirms the existence of a large open lava tube in the Marius Hills region of the moon, which could be used to protect astronauts from hazardous conditions on the surface.

In search of the ninth planet

October 17, 2017

A University of Michigan doctoral student has logged two pieces of evidence that may support the existence of a planet that could be part of our solar system, beyond Neptune.

Microbes leave 'fingerprints' on Martian rocks

October 17, 2017

Scientists around Tetyana Milojevic from the Faculty of Chemistry at the University of Vienna are in search of unique biosignatures, which are left on synthetic extraterrestrial minerals by microbial activity. The biochemist ...

To keep Saturn's A ring contained, its moons stand united

October 17, 2017

For three decades, astronomers thought that only Saturn's moon Janus confined the planet's A ring - the largest and farthest of the visible rings. But after poring over NASA's Cassini mission data, Cornell astronomers now ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

1.3 / 5 (13) Oct 08, 2014
Like I have been saying, Black holes are simply Grey Holes in the quiescent state.
2.3 / 5 (3) Oct 08, 2014
Yah I don't think photon torpedoes work that way in real life.
2 / 5 (1) Oct 08, 2014
I find it impossible to believe that *any* object in the universe can be deemed 'unique', hard to find, yes, but not 'unique'. Nevertheless it's an exciting discovery for sure.
Oct 08, 2014
This comment has been removed by a moderator.
Oct 08, 2014
This comment has been removed by a moderator.
1 / 5 (10) Oct 08, 2014
Mainstream theories falling apart right in front of you!
3 / 5 (4) Oct 09, 2014
damn but I wish Oliver would come back. At least his crackpot theories were entertaining.
5 / 5 (6) Oct 09, 2014
At least Oliver kept to the same crackpot theory and didn't try to be the unique genius that knew EVERYTHING about EVERYTHING and use multiple sockpuppets to promote his belief. But at the end of the day he was a pseudoscience crackpot and was banned accordingly.
3.3 / 5 (6) Oct 09, 2014
Although these objects are called pulsars, it's actually a misnomer because the pulses are what we see. In fact these objects constantly radiate. Yes?

As they rotate, an outside observer with an X-ray telescope, situated at the right angle, would see flashes of powerful light

What do these objects look like when viewed from other angles? Something familiar?

Captain Stumpy
3.9 / 5 (7) Oct 09, 2014
In particular, the AWT predicts
@TEP320 - Zephir
first off, tinyurl to a pseudoscience site
second off: aw/daw philosophy (NOT a theory) is based upon a fallacious premiss which has been debunked for a century... but more importantly, it is proven wrong to a stupidly high degree of accuracy with these links: http://exphy.uni-...2009.pdf


so you can stop pushing a known pseudoscience any time you want
maybe you can learn real physics here:

It is FREE and open to the public, and they have quantum physics in there as well

feel free to go learn about reality and the basics before commenting further, as you've only shown by your acceptance of aw/daw that you support a pseudoscience like it was a religion (which is why you run that site)
5 / 5 (3) Oct 09, 2014
Maybe whatever it has has a very narrow beam concentrating the energy more than for a normal pulsar?
4.8 / 5 (5) Oct 09, 2014
Bluehigh: Yes, they only pulse because we see the beam as it rotates, just like a lighthouse or airport beacon.

From other angles they would look like a common neutron star, with a fairly steady UV and X-ray glow, possibly detectable in visible light if close enough, and, if the surrounding gas/dust is thick enough, showing extended emission where the beams impact the gas/dust. If they're in a binary system, with the companion close enough for mass transfer, there will also be emission from the gas as it forms an accretion disc and/or impacts the surface, and those can randomly flicker due to variations in gas flow.
5 / 5 (3) Oct 10, 2014
Derekemery: That wouldn't be surprising. I don't know what would produce a tighter beam, but possibly a stronger than usual magnetic field, or one configured a little different than usual, could provide better focusing.
1 / 5 (5) Oct 12, 2014
"We took it for granted that the powerful ULXs must be massive black holes," Dr. Matteo Bachetti, an astrophysicist at the University of Toulouse in France and the lead author of a new study about the pulsar, said in the statement. "When we first saw the pulsations in the data, we thought they must be from another source."


Yes, just like so many other assumptions that are just taken for granted based on fanciful math models. Wonder why Physorg ignored this telling admission from the released statement?? Why should we trust these guys when they missed the mark so broadly? Black holes, dark matter, dark energy, unseen dimensions, curved space-time (huh?), blah, blah, blah....

Until they answer this, I give them no credibility: What is the physical mechanism that results in a field?
1 / 5 (2) Oct 13, 2014
Hollow black holes solves all.
Oct 13, 2014
This comment has been removed by a moderator.
Oct 13, 2014
This comment has been removed by a moderator.
5 / 5 (4) Oct 13, 2014
Mainstream theories falling apart right in front of you!

No. Science at work right in front of you. Reality trumps theory every time.
no fate
not rated yet Oct 15, 2014
Mainstream theories falling apart right in front of you!

No. Science at work right in front of you. Reality trumps theory every time.

You're both right.
5 / 5 (1) Oct 28, 2014
Rotation of 1.37 seconds... that's rather ordinary. Slow, even.

Okay, since this site is already swarmed by pseudoscience cranks, I guess I won't hold back.

If I were an advanced alien race and wanted to send messages a really long way, I'd use a neutron star/pulsar like this one and modulate the pulse as a carrier wave.

Unfortunately, receiving in the X-ray bands using our technology, we would miss the message. All we see is the flash, and we're doing really good to see that much.

The bandwidth offered at those frequencies, however, could be enormous, if we could tease out the signal.

Meh, even at my crankiest, I don't believe that hypothesis, but if we're serious about looking for advanced civilizations, it's one place to look.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.