Researchers test whether Red Queen hypothesis makes species resilient

May 20, 2014 by Gary Galluzzo
In this illustration, Alice meets the Red Queen. Credit: ©John Tenniel [Public domain], via Wikimedia Commons

In Lewis Carroll's 1871 classic novel Through the Looking Glass, the Red Queen tells Alice: "Now, here, you see, it takes all the running you can do, to keep in the same place."

Over the years, evolutionary biologists have used the Red Queen's statement to refer to the "Red Queen" hypothesis, which describes how living organisms, including humans, manage to survive in a changing environment by adapting through . According to a University of Iowa researcher, the hypothesis is supported.

In a paper published in the journal Biology Letters, lead author Deanna Soper, postdoctoral researcher in the UI Department of Biology and currently visiting assistant professor at Beloit College, Beloit, Wisconsin, and her colleagues write about testing a version of the Red Queen hypothesis.

In particular, they addressed whether a particular prediction of the hypothesis was met—that exposure to parasites increases multiple mating in New Zealand freshwater snails (Potamopyrgus antipodarum).

What they found was that a challenge to the health of the snails caused the snails to respond by increasing their rate of mating and their number of mates.

Researchers test whether Red Queen hypothesis makes species resilient
Biologists used New Zealand freshwater snails in their research. Credit: Bart Zijlstra

"Under the Red Queen hypothesis, sexual reproduction gives an advantage over because sexually reproducing organisms 'shuffle' their genes during sex cell formation and fusion of sex cells from two individuals," says Soper. "This means that the resulting offspring of sexually reproducing individuals may have an increased likelihood of escaping infection due to the production of unusual genetic backgrounds.

"Here, we test the prediction that exposure to parasites would increase mating behavior and number of sexual partners. We found that indeed parasites cause an increase in mating activity and promiscuity when exposed to parasites," she says.

What Soper and her colleagues did was to expose the fresh-water snails to the eggs of a parasite that have the effect of sterilizing the snails. Interestingly, they found that such exposure caused both male and female snails to increase their sexual behavior.

At issue was the mystery of why sexual reproduction is so common among organisms and why it evolved in the first place—central questions in the field of evolutionary biology. After all, asexual females—which exist among freshwater snails and some other organisms—should be able to produce twice as many daughters as sexual females who produce both male and female offspring. Asexual reproduction would appear to have an advantage because only females produce offspring and females thus limit the rate at which populations grow.

In her summary, Soper speculates that multiple mating could increase genetic diversity among offspring, thereby making them more resistant to the risk of infection from parasites found in nature. She suggests that future studies investigate how other environmental factors influence behavior.

Explore further: Sexual reproduction works thanks to ever-evolving host, parasite relationships: study

More information: The paper, whose title is "Exposure to parasites increases promiscuity in a freshwater snail," can be found here: rsbl.royalsocietypublishing.or … t/10/4/20131091.full

Related Stories

Parasites keep things sexy in 'hotspots'

July 23, 2009

The coevolutionary struggle between a New Zealand snail and its worm parasite makes sex advantageous for the snail, whose females favor asexual reproduction in the absence of parasites, say Indiana University Bloomington ...

Study finds role for parasites in evolution of sex

July 6, 2009

What's so great about sex? From an evolutionary perspective, the answer is not as obvious as one might think. An article published in the July issue of the American Naturalist suggests that sex may have evolved in part as ...

Study finds 'Goldilocks' effect in snail populations

December 3, 2013

A University of Iowa researcher has discovered that a "Goldilocks" effect applies to the reproductive output of a tiny New Zealand snail—considered a troublesome species in many countries—that may one day help environmentalists ...

Recommended for you

Big brains in birds provides survival advantage: study

September 25, 2017

Given how proud we are of our big brains, it's ironic that we haven't yet figured out why we have them. One idea, called the cognitive buffer hypothesis, is that the evolution of large brains is driven by the adaptive benefits ...

Panda habitat shrinking, becoming more fragmented

September 25, 2017

A study by Chinese and U.S. scientists finds that while populations of the iconic giant panda have increased recently, the species' habitat still covers less area and is more fragmented than when it was first listed as an ...

With extra sugar, leaves get fat too

September 25, 2017

Eat too much without exercising and you'll probably put on a few pounds. As it turns out, plant leaves do something similar. In a new study at the U.S. Department of Energy's Brookhaven National Laboratory, scientists show ...

Towards pesticidovigilance

September 25, 2017

A fascinating insight paper, "Towards pesticidovigilance" published in Science today by Dr Alice Milner, Lecturer in Physical Geography at Royal Holloway and Professor Ian Boyd (School of Biology, University of St Andrews), ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

1 / 5 (1) May 20, 2014
Does this imply that increased promiscuity amongst H. sapiens, is the best way to combat STD's in the long term? Shall we all sacrifice ourselves to pernicious diseases in order to breed immunity into the 22nd century.
not rated yet May 20, 2014
Not really - promiscuity does not equal more babies in the age of birth control.

But it does show that racism and other "racial purity" bullshit decreases genetic diversity and therefore long-term resilience.
1 / 5 (1) May 20, 2014
Today, our life is full of stress with a hectic lifestyle, too much work, and increasingly too little money. Could it be that this kind of stressors work the same as having parasites? Then promiscuity would follow. Contrast that with pastoral settings (Little House on the Prairie), where life is secure, stable and peaceful, and where you see people married to high school sweethearts and lasting marriages.

Just a thought.
1 / 5 (2) May 20, 2014
"The most likely explanation for the fitness advantage conferred by genomic and metabolic "streamlining" in both natural and experimental populations is that it reduces the amount of carbon and other limiting nutrients required to produce a new cell (12, 15, 16)." -- http://mbio.asm.o...abstract

That fact pits the Black Queen hypothesis against the Red Queen hypothesis.

However, no experimental evidence of biologically based cause and effect supports the Red Queen hypothesis, which is based on the pseudoscientific nonsense of population genetics. For comparison, the Black Queen hypothesis integrates all that is currently known from physics, chemistry, and conserved molecular mechanisms about nutrient-dependent pheromone-controlled reproduction in species from microbes to man. For examples, see:


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.