With hacking case, US hopes fade that China can play by 'rules'

May 20, 2014 by Shaun Tandon
L-R: US Attorney General Eric Holder, US Attorney for Western District of Pennsylvania David Hickton, and Assistant Attorney General for National Security John Carlin take questions on May 19, 2014 at the Department of Justice in Washington

In choosing a major escalation with China over cyber-espionage, the United States has laid bare its frustrations after years of hoping the Asian power would accept a US-led international order.

President Barack Obama and his predecessors have long recited a mantra that the United States welcomes China's rise but wants it to join a "rules-based order" and take a greater responsibility in global affairs.

"I think that the Obama administration over the past six years has been frustrated that the Chinese have not played the role that we hoped they would in supporting the system," said Adam Segal, a senior fellow at the Council on Foreign Relations.

"The Chinese say that we didn't write any of these rules and we don't necessarily agree with them, so do not expect us to uphold them," he said.

The United States on Monday indicted five Chinese military officers for allegedly hacking into US computers to steal trade secrets, with prosecutor David Hickton saying the case vindicated "hard-working men and women" around the world who "play by the rules."

China responded swiftly and angrily, summoning the US ambassador and charging hypocrisy as former government contractor Edward Snowden has revealed widespread US snooping inside China.

The United States has insisted that it is playing by "the rules" as its intelligence operations are purportedly for national security, not for commercial advantage.

Frustration over sea disputes

While US officials said that the case was years in the making, it comes as China moves assertively and unilaterally in maritime disputes with Japan, Vietnam and the Philippines despite pleas from the United States to respect international standards.

US officials have voiced alarm at China's assertions of legal authority over foreign vessels in the 200-mile exclusive economic zone from its coast, a sharp divergence from the positions of most nations that ships enjoy freedom of navigation in such waters.

China's "sails are full of wind because they think they're rising, we're falling, and in time—as in the past, when the US started writing rules from World War II—they will start writing the rules," said Douglas Paal, a former senior US policymaker on Asia.

This combination of images released by the FBI on May 19, 2014 shows five Chinese hacking suspects

Paal, a vice president at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, said the United States had a delicate task of trying to determine how far to accommodate China.

The US message has been "we'll change the rules for you—for example at the IMF, to increase your voting shares—but you can't go out and rewrite the law of the sea," Paal said.

The world's two largest economies have also clashed over solar energy, with each side accusing the other of unfair trade practices.

Will a court case matter?

Paal questioned whether court action was the best approach with China.

He said that the Obama administration has started to sound like George W. Bush-era neoconservatives who come off as "looking for confrontation," fueling anti-US sentiment among young people in China.

"Probably the best response to this would have not been in public, but instead some sort of American cyber-attack on Chinese treasure and then leaving a calling card saying, 'You want more of that, keep it up.' Spy-versus-spy stuff," he said.

Robert Daly, director of the Kissinger Institute on China and the United States at the Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars, said that the "name-and-shame tactics" against Chinese officers could backfire by making them lose face and may also set back the Pacific powers' military cooperation which had finally been improving.

"China cares more about face than we do and will fight harder to save it. Bilateral and multilateral consultation will yield better results over an arduous, imperfect long run," Daly said.

But James Lewis of the Center for Strategic and International Studies said that China had not responded to four years of private discussions on hacking.

"The Chinese now know that this is a serious problem in the bilateral relationship, and one they can't simply ignore," he said.

Explore further: Cyber case puts more strain on US-China relations

Related Stories

Cyber case puts more strain on US-China relations

May 20, 2014

The indictment of five Chinese military officials on cyber espionage charges will intensify friction between Beijing and Washington that has been growing as China gets bolder in asserting its territorial claims in disputed ...

Obama to confront Xi on cyber spying

June 5, 2013

President Barack Obama will tell Chinese counterpart Xi Jinping that he must deal with cyber spying and hacking of US targets that originate inside his country when they meet for talks this week.

Report: NSA uses radio waves to map pathway into computers

January 15, 2014

The National Security Agency has implanted software in nearly 100,000 computers around the world—but not in the United States—that allows the U.S. to conduct surveillance on those machines, The New York Times reported ...

Recommended for you

What do you get when you cross an airplane with a submarine?

February 15, 2018

Researchers from North Carolina State University have developed the first unmanned, fixed-wing aircraft that is capable of traveling both through the air and under the water – transitioning repeatedly between sky and sea. ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet May 21, 2014
More US hypocrisy
5 / 5 (1) May 21, 2014
the Asian power would accept a US-led international order.

Good. A US led international order would be pure hell.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.