Tracking down MH370 black boxes a Herculean challenge

March 25, 2014 by Delphine Touitou
A ground controller guides a Royal Australian Air Force AP-3C Orion after a search operation for the flight MH370 over the Indian Ocean

Recovering the black boxes from the Malaysia Airlines jet that crashed into the southern Indian Ocean is a Herculean task, even with the wealth of sophisticated equipment being deployed.

Any hope of finding survivors from the missing plane was extinguished on Monday when Malaysia's prime minister announced satellite data showed MH370's journey had "ended in the southern Indian Ocean" off the west coast of Australia.

Seventeen days after the Boeing 777 disappeared, distraught relatives were forced to accept what they had long feared—that the 239 passengers and crew on board were never coming home.

The plane's two black boxes are key to solving the mystery of why the plane veered so far off course and its final fate, but experts say that the search for them will be long and difficult.

In theory, the black boxes containing flight data and cockpit voice recordings will continue emitting tracking signals for about another two weeks, with an average audible range of two to three kilometres (nearly two miles).

But with no debris in the remote search area confirmed as linked to the plane, it is still a case of looking for a needle in a haystack.

"Picking up a signal from the beacon seems an outside chance," said a member of the team that hunted the black boxes from Air France flight AF447 that crashed in the Atlantic in 2009.

Vast search zone

The investigator, who asked to remain anonymous, noted that in the Air France case the signals were not heard at all. One transmitter had failed and the other had fallen off on impact and was never found, he said.

"So I'm fairly pessimistic about this approach," he said, recommending that the immediate priority should be to catalogue every piece of debris that is discovered.

"Then, ideally, data buoys should be deployed," he said. These instruments, commonly used for meteorological data, are tracked by satellite and give an idea of ocean currents in the area to help confirm mathematical models.

It took 23 months to locate the main wreckage and retrieve the black boxes of doomed Air France flight AF447 at a depth of 3,900 metres

But he warned that the 17 days that have elapsed since the crash and the "uncertainty associated with these models will combine to make the search zone quite vast".

Commercial airliners are obliged to carry two black boxes—the Digital Flight Data Recorder which logs the speed, altitude and direction, while the Cockpit Voice Recorder keeps track of cockpit conversations and other sounds and announcements.

Even before the official announcement that the plane had crashed, the US navy said it was flying a locator to Perth. The Pinger Locator, weighing 35 kilogrammes (80 pounds), is attached to a cable and towed by a ship.

It is equipped with a listening device that can detect the signals of a black box at a depth of up to 6,000 metres (20,000 feet).

Scouring the sea floor

If a signal is not picked up, the next stage would be to deploy lateral scanning sonars after determining the variations of the sea floor to pick up any anomalies.

All the experts who spoke to AFP believed the search operation could last a very long time—months or more.

In the Air France crash it took 23 months to locate the main wreckage and retrieve the black boxes at a depth of 3,900 metres.

"An underwater phase to try to locate the plane from flight MH370 can only be started if the activity under way allows us to define a search zone more limited than the current search zone," France's air accident investigation bureau (BEA) said Monday.

Once such a zone is set, if it is over a flat and sedimentary seabed, investigators can use "towed sonars and get a good coverage".

Co-Pilot, Flying Officer Marc Smith turns his RAAF AP-3C Orion aircraft whilst searching for flight MH370 over the Indian Ocean on March 24, 2014

If, however, the zone is over a broken, irregular seabed, they could call in the Remus submarine drones used for the Air France search plane.

Remote operating vehicles (ROVs) could also be used in a later stage to check topographical anomalies with high-definition cameras.

"These remote-controlled robots, which have a cable linking them to the surface, move forward slowly and thus have a more reliable coverage," said the investigator, who was formerly with the BEA.

"But there as well, a very precise position is needed to use them at depth."

And even if the black boxes are found, there are no guarantees they will be in a state to give up their data.

The Malaysian authorities have said a deliberate act made MH370 disappear from civilian air control radars—and the big question is whether the Cockpit Voice Recorder was immobilised.

"You only need to pull the breaker that is by the pilot's seat and it is taken off-line electrically," explained one aviation expert.

MH370's disappearance has prompted a major debate over inflight communications, including the benefits of live streaming black box data.

Explore further: Ways eyed to make planes easier to find in ocean

Related Stories

Ways eyed to make planes easier to find in ocean

March 12, 2014

For nearly five years, government and industry officials have been exploring ways to make it easier to find airliners and their critical "black boxes" that end up in the ocean. But their efforts are too late to help in the ...

Malaysian plane drama fuels aviation security rethink

March 23, 2014

As the hunt for Malaysia Airlines Flight 370 enters a third week, the piecemeal returns from one of the most intense, international searches in living memory have delivered a public and institutional shock that could force ...

Why locating MH370 in the Southern Ocean is so difficult

March 24, 2014

Searching for the debris of flight MH370 in the Southern Ocean is not just a case of looking for a needle in a haystack; it is a case of searching for a needle that moves hundreds of kilometres every day in one of the most ...

Thailand gives radar data 10 days after plane lost (Update)

March 18, 2014

Thailand's military said Tuesday that its radar detected a plane that may have been Malaysia Airlines Flight 370 just minutes after the jetliner's communications went down, and that it didn't share the information with Malaysia ...

Plane search spreads through Australia-sized zone

March 18, 2014

Investigators trying to solve the mystery of a missing Malaysian jetliner received some belated help Tuesday from Thailand, whose military said it took 10 days to report radar blips that might have been the plane "because ...

Recommended for you

Microbes help turn Greek yogurt waste into fuel

December 13, 2017

Consumers across the world enjoy Greek yogurt for its taste, texture, and protein-packed punch. Reaching that perfect formula, however, generates large volumes of food waste in the form of liquid whey. Now researchers in ...

1 comment

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Mar 25, 2014
In short, the best bets are that will never know--and that might be good thing--it might sober us up--a bit like the "unsinkable" Titanic in 1912--about what technology can and cannot do.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.