Could gamification enhance biodiversity decision making tools?

June 20, 2013 by Thijs Westerbeek
Could gamification enhance biodiversity decision making tools?

Decision making tools used for policy could benefit from adding features inspired from video games to entice more people to use them. But will they still be credible to policy makers?

Making decision that may affect the environment is not that simple. For example, if a EU maker believes that biofuels can reduce . And then decide to convert all unused into, say, willow-biomass plantations capable of generating energy to replace up to 20% of fossil fuels. Their plan may not be readily adopted, should biodiversity specialists points out that the semi-wild unused are a perfect habitat for butterflies.

The tool developed by the Bioscore research project is designed to provide a perspective on the consequence of proposed policies on biodiversity. Created with EU funding, it is online since 2009 and answers the 'What if?' question: 'What will happen to species X, if we install policy Y in region Z?' A large database with the of more than a thousand European species, , gives the answer in the form of data, graphics, and European maps.

But Bioscore is not perfect. Project coordinator Ben Delbeare, senior programme manager at the European Centre for Nature Conservation (ECNC) in Tilburg, the Netherlands, admits the test panel could include more precision, more species, and a more refined geographical grid. Project scientists hope that the tool will eventually help answer questions such as 'If I put this new road near that little swamp, what will happen to this toad that only survives there?' Until it is further refined, Delbeare and colleagues considered Bioscore as no more than "possibly useful."

Experts acknowledge its value, however. "I like it. It's new to me that you get an answer on biodiversity related to species and location," notes, landscape ecologist Timo Kaphengst, coordinator for biodiversity of the Ecologic Institute in Berlin, Germany. But he agrees that more precision is needed. His colleague Markus Geupel of Germany's Federal Environment Agency in Dessau-Rosslau is "delighted such a tool is being developed." Nevertheless, both experts doubt policy makers will be influenced by Bioscore. Indeed, the results as they appear are not terribly engaging. Graphics, percentages and a few maps aren't speech material for a politician. What's more; you need to really know about biodiversity to fully grasp the meaning of all those data.

So could 'gamification' make Bioscore more effective? 'Gamification' or rather its spin-off 'serious gaming' is the hottest thing in learning technology. It means applying the laws of computer gaming into learning programs. It makes the task more fun, and users learn quickly because the game forces them to apply whatever they learn.

Two French specialists on gamification think it could work. "Gamification can be applied to a decision making tool like Bioscore," Francois Escolier tells He is the owner and CEO of Getzem in Paris, a company that creates these learning programs. "The answers will be much clearer, quicker to understand, and the sheer fun and speed of such a game will invite the policy maker to continue playing with it, to instantly try another policy and see what happens," he adds. Ultimately, Escolier continues, this must result in better policies.

Applying the design and laws of computer gaming could result in better policies, agrees Sylvain Haudegombe, a cognitive psychology researcher, who is co-founder of the 'Play Research Lab' at the University of Valenciennes. But whether politicians will allow themselves to be influenced by something they perceive as a game is another matter. He tells " fear these politicians won't take such a game seriously, never mind how well it's made."

Explore further: When cuddly bees influence the rules

Related Stories

When cuddly bees influence the rules

May 7, 2013

It may be easier to show concern about cuddly animals like bees than about some of the millions of indigenous insect and microorganisms found in the European biodiversity.

When energy-saving becomes a game

March 22, 2013

( —A smartphone application bringing gaming dimensions to energy awareness has helped householders in Finland, Sweden and Italy reduce their electricity consumption by up to 19%.

Dragonflies, as climate change indicators

March 6, 2013

Monitoring communities of climate sensitive species, such as insects, could enable scientists to develop indicators for climate change effects on biodiversity and help devise policies to protect it.

Local input key in multi-risk planning decisions

May 3, 2013

Land use planning and management now has all the scientific tools required for decisions making. But scientists have yet to have an opportunity to collaborate with local authorities to implement them.

Recommended for you

Re-cloning of first cloned dog deemed successful thus far

November 22, 2017

(—A team of researchers with Seoul National University, Michigan State University and the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign has re-cloned the first dog to be cloned. In their paper published in the journal ...

Camponotini ant species have their own distinct microbiomes

November 22, 2017

Camponotini ant species have their own distinct microbiomes and the bacteria may also vary by developmental stage, according to a study published November 22, 2017 in the open-access journal PLOS ONE by Manuela Oliveira Ramalho ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.