Ice tubes in polar seas—'brinicles' or 'sea stalactites'—provide clues to origin of life

April 24, 2013, American Chemical Society
Life on Earth may have originated not in warm tropical seas, but with weird tubes of ice — sometimes called “sea stalactites” — that grow downward into cold seawater near the Earth's poles. Credit: Credit: Rob Robbins; image archived by

Life on Earth may have originated not in warm tropical seas, but with weird tubes of ice—sometimes called "sea stalactites"—that grow downward into cold seawater near the Earth's poles, scientists are reporting. Their article on these "brinicles" appears in ACS' journal Langmuir.

Bruno Escribano and colleagues explain that scientists know surprisingly little about brinicles, which are of ice that can grow to several yards in length around streamers of under pack ice. That's because brinicles are difficult to study. The scientists set out to gather more information on the topic with an analysis of the growth process of brinicles.

They are shown to be analogous to a "chemical garden," a standby demonstration in chemistry classes and children's chemistry sets, in which tubes grow upward from metal salts dropped into silicate solution. But brinicles grow downward from the bottom of the ice pack.

The analysis concluded that brinicles provide an environment that could well have fostered the on Earth billions of years ago, and could have done so on other planets. "Beyond Earth, the brinicle formation mechanism may be important in the context of planets and moons with ice-covered oceans," the report states, citing in particular two moons of Jupiter named Ganymede and Callisto.

The article is titled "Brinicles as a Case of Inverse Chemical Gardens."

Explore further: 'Chemical gardens' could hold the key to understanding the origins of life on Earth

More information: Brinicles as a case of inverse chemical gardens, Langmuir, Just Accepted Manuscript DOI: 10.1021/la4009703

Brinicles are hollow tubes of ice from centimetres to metres in length that form under floating sea ice in the polar oceans when dense, cold brine drains downwards from sea ice into sea water close to its freezing point. When this extremely cold brine leaves the ice it freezes the water it comes into contact with; a hollow tube of ice —- a brinicle —- growing downwards around the plume of descending brine. We show that brinicles can be understood as a form of the self-assembled tubular precipitation structures termed chemical gardens, plant-like structures formed on placing together a soluble metal salt, often in the form of a seed crystal, and an aqueous solution of one of many anions, often silicate. On one hand, in the case of classical chemical gardens, an osmotic pressure difference across a semipermeable precipitation membrane that filters solutions by rejecting the solute leads to an inflow of water and to its rupture. The internal solution, generally being lighter than the external solution, flows up through the break, and as it does so a tube grows upwards by precipitation around the jet of internal solution. Such chemical-garden tubes can grow to many centimetres in length. In the case of brinicles, on the other hand, in floating sea ice we have porous ice in a mushy layer that filters out water, by freezing it, and allows concentrated brine through. Again there is an osmotic pressure difference leading to a continuing ingress of sea water in a siphon pump mechanism that is sustained as long as the ice continues to freeze. Since the brine that is pumped out is denser than the sea water, and descends rather rises, a brinicle is a downwards growing tube of ice; an inverse chemical garden.

Related Stories

The water reservoir in a young planetary system

November 15, 2011

( -- Astronomers once thought that the process of star formation was more-or-less controlled by the simple coalescence of material by gravity, leading eventually to a new star. But they have come to realize that ...

A comprehensive study of ice

June 19, 2012

A group composed of 17 scientists from 11 different countries has published the most comprehensive study ever done on ice in the world. The study addresses the most important contemporary issues in a field of research that ...

Recommended for you

Biologists' new peptide could fight many cancers

January 16, 2018

MIT biologists have designed a new peptide that can disrupt a key protein that many types of cancers, including some forms of lymphoma, leukemia, and breast cancer, need to survive.

Insulating bricks with microscopic bubbles

January 16, 2018

The better a building is insulated, the less heat is lost in winter—and the less energy is needed to achieve a comfortable room temperature. The Swiss Federal Office of Energy (SFOE) regularly raises the requirements for ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Apr 24, 2013
Interesting, but a little light on details.
not rated yet Apr 25, 2013
You can find the full article by googling for:
"Brinicles as a case of inverse chemical gardens filetype:pdf"

(I can't post the link here because it contains a lot of russian characters and that for some reason messes up the copy and paste feature. But the article is in english)

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.