Study shows depleted fish stocks can come back from the brink

April 18, 2013, Rutgers University
Study shows depleted fish stocks can come back from the brink
Olaf Jensen, assistant professor of marine science

( —Nature is a lot more resilient than we sometimes think. A study by Rutgers marine scientists published recently in Science shows that species of fish that have been overfished for decades can often be brought back more easily than expected once fisheries managers put limits on the exploitation.

It turns out, in fact, that the – the ability to recover from – of a is enhanced, not hurt, even if it has been moderately overexploited for decades, offering the possibility of swift recovery if sensible catch limits are placed on it. Philipp Neubauer, a postdoctoral scholar, and Olaf Jensen, an assistant professor of marine and , say the key is in the adaptation of fish to over-fishing. A fish stock is over-fished if its numbers fall below half the level needed to sustain maximum harvest.

This is good news because scientists had thought overfishing over a long time might compromise the ability of stocks to rebound to healthy levels. A species overfished for decades, they believed, would be harder to bring back because so many of its largest and oldest members, those that contribute most to reproduction, are caught in fishing nets. However, the opposite seemed the case, and Neubauer and Jensen hypothesize that many overfished species have adapted to being overfished and mature at an earlier age, allowing them to recover fairly quickly if managers restrict catches and give them time to catch up.

"Recovery of overexploited would be a 'win-win' for fisheries and conservation, easing pressure on wild populations and associated ecosystems, and ultimately enhancing catches, revenues and ," Neubauer and Jensen wrote.

Neubauer was among the scientists who thought that decades of overfishing would lead to slow recovery once fishing was reduced. "My , based on prior studies, was that marine stocks that had been overexploited for a long time would have a harder time coming back," Neubauer said. "So this was a bit of a surprise."

Neubauer, Jensen and their co-authors, Jeffrey Hutchings of Dalhousie University in Nova Scotia and Julia Baum of the University of Victoria in British Columbia, examined 153 fish and invertebrate stocks around the world that had declined to less than 50 percent of their maximum sustainable yield. They used all available data from fisheries managers from all over the world. "We actually used a statistical method borrowed from medicine, called survival analysis," Neubauer said. "What medical researchers do is look at how long it takes, under a particular treatment, to recover from a disease. We looked at fish stocks as if they were patients undergoing treatment and examined the data to determine how long it would take each stock to recover."

The bad news is that species that have been intensely over-exploited for a brief time have a much harder time coming back. The same thing may be true for fish that reproduce slowly and have been severely overfished, such as Atlantic halibut. The challenge for fisheries managers, Jensen and Neubauer said, is to recognize over-exploitation early and put effective limits on the catch. Summer flounder in the U.S. mid-Atlantic region, for example, have bounced back, thanks largely to stricter limits on fishing.

"Nature is not as fragile as we might suppose," Jensen said. "Just because a fish stock has been overexploited for a long time doesn't mean we should give up on it."

Explore further: New method for measuring biomass reveals fish stocks are more stable than widely believed

More information:

Related Stories

EU keeps controversial fishing subsidies

October 24, 2012

The EU agreed on Wednesday to maintain controversial fishing subsidies, sparking a sharp response from environmental groups who say the payments contribute to overfishing of already stressed stocks.

Deep-sea fish in deep trouble

September 7, 2011

A team of leading marine scientists from around the world is recommending an end to most commercial fishing in the deep sea, the Earth's largest ecosystem. Instead, they recommend fishing in more productive waters nearer ...

30% of fish stocks overexploited: UN agency

July 9, 2012

Almost 30 percent of fish stocks monitored by the UN's food agency are overexploited, undermining the crucial role sustainable fisheries play in providing food and jobs for millions, a report said Monday.

Recommended for you

High vinculin levels help keep aging fruit fly hearts young

July 17, 2018

Our cells tend to lose their shape as we grow older, contributing to many of the effects we experience as aging. This poses particular problems for the heart, where aging can disrupt the protein network within muscle cells ...

1 comment

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

5 / 5 (3) Apr 18, 2013
This shouldn't come as a surprise. A single fish often lays dozens, if not hundreds of eggs at one time.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.