E-mail use model appears to follow "Clash of Civilizations" prediction

March 8, 2013 by Bob Yirka weblog
The Mesh of Civilizations. Source: Yahoo! email dataset. Rescaled densities. Only top 1,000 densities displayed. Credit: arxiv.org/abs/1303.0045

(Phys.org) —Researchers at Stanford University have built a model based on the frequency of e-mail interactions between groups of users of Yahoo! e-mail throughout the world. In studying their results, they have found, as they report in their paper they've uploaded to the preprint server arXiv, it appears to adhere to societal boundaries as described by Samuel Huntington's 1992 book "The Clash of Civilizations."

Huntington famously suggested in his book that future wars would revolve around cultural and religious differences and even offered a list of groups of people in them: Sinic, Hindu, Islamic, , Western, Orthodox, African and Buddhist.

The researchers at Stanford, led by Bogdan State, didn't set out to create a model that would reflect Huntington's vision, but instead found it came about on its own after the data was compiled and graphed. Their model is based on over ten million e-mail messages sent from Yahoo! users the world over. To show the degree of interaction between groups, the team used nodes and lines between them—the more transactions between groups, the closer they appear together on the model. They also carefully note that only Yahoo! users that agreed to have their data used in the study were included. To form geographic areas, the team compared IP numbers attached to messages with the location noted in a user's profile, using only those that coincided.

The resulting color-coded graphic model offers near instant visual clues regarding groups bound together by culture and perhaps religion. Perhaps more importantly it also shows boundaries, which State and his team claim, resemble the model first proposed by Huntington. Western nodes are clustered to form a single group with just a few outliers, for example, as are others such as those deemed Islamic, or South American.

The doesn't hint at tensions between groups of course, but does seem to indicate that groups tend to communicate more via with others in their same group than they do with others from other groups, even if they share a physical border. Other patterns that show up indicate what would seem natural—that people who speak the same language tend to send more e-mails to each other than to people who don't. People in Great Britain for example, appear to send more e-mails to people in Australia than to people in other, much closer, European countries.

Explore further: Yahoo tries to entice users with e-mail facelift

More information: The Mesh of Civilizations and International Email Flows, arXiv:1303.0045 [cs.SI] arxiv.org/abs/1303.0045

In The Clash of Civilizations, Samuel Huntington argued that the primary axis of global conflict was no longer ideological or economic but cultural and religious, and that this division would characterize the "battle lines of the future." In contrast to the "top down" approach in previous research focused on the relations among nation states, we focused on the flows of interpersonal communication as a bottom-up view of international alignments. To that end, we mapped the locations of the world's countries in global email networks to see if we could detect cultural fault lines. Using IP-geolocation on a worldwide anonymized dataset obtained from a large Internet company, we constructed a global email network. In computing email flows we employ a novel rescaling procedure to account for differences due to uneven adoption of a particular Internet service across the world. Our analysis shows that email flows are consistent with Huntington's thesis. In addition to location in Huntington's "civilizations," our results also attest to the importance of both cultural and economic factors in the patterning of inter-country communication ties.

via Arxiv Blog

Related Stories

Scientists show how to make peace

October 19, 2011

Can science predict peace? Can scientific modeling help to end crises in today’s war-torn regions? New research from the New England Complex Systems Institute (NECSI) says yes.

Reports of e-mail's death have been greatly exaggerated

October 14, 2010

All the ballyhoo that social networking sites such as Twitter and Facebook are diminishing our need for e-mail can be best summarized by paraphrasing Mark Twain: Reports of e-mail's death have been greatly exaggerated.

Recommended for you

Startup Pi out to slice the charging cord

September 19, 2017

Silicon Valley youngster Pi on Monday claimed it had developed the world's first wireless charger that does away with cords or mats to charge devices.

A solar cell you can put in the wash

September 18, 2017

Scientists from RIKEN and the University of Tokyo have developed a new type of ultra-thin photovoltaic device, coated on both sides with stretchable and waterproof films, which can continue to provide electricity from sunlight ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

3.4 / 5 (10) Mar 08, 2013
People in Great Britain for example, appear to send more e-mails to people in Australia than to people in other, much closer, European countries.

It never ceases to amaze me how damned stupid researchers are.

Why do people need an entire team of "experts" to understand this? It's about as simple a concept as exists as it regards humanity.

You communicate more with friends and family than with strangers, most of the time anyway.

You communicate more with strangers who speak the same language than you do with strangers who don't.

Obviously, if you can't understand one another without a computer translator, you don't do much communicating. Using translators often doesn't work anyway, so they end up being a hassle.

What's the big deal? This is like 3rd or 4th grade kiddie common sense knowledge.
not rated yet Mar 08, 2013
Gotta admit this conclusion really sounds trivial. Also, I'm not sure emails are such a good indicator of communications on internet. What about forums?
3 / 5 (2) Mar 08, 2013
Huntington's book delineates 'fractures'. This study validates even his particular fractures.

The book was written in 1996 after Huntington served on Carter's National Security Council. The conclusion is that Huntingtons thesis is corroborated by more than anecdotal commonsensical observation (two idiots anecdotes do not data make).

WWII was across the fracture separating Allied and Axis. WWIII will be fought across one of these culture fractures.
1 / 5 (3) Mar 08, 2013
Wars are funded by banksters and the reasons are created by same for the intended annexing. Ancillary reasons such as religion or appeal to authority or social polarization (appeal to 'patriots') molds the public mindset. http://www.youtub...EBupAeo4
not rated yet Mar 08, 2013
This just in: People are more likely to talk to people close to them rather than other people across the planet.
not rated yet Mar 09, 2013
The above commentary is fracture. Stemming from language. The same language. The same culture. The same origin.
With all this in common one reader notes:
"You don't do much communicating..."
not rated yet Mar 09, 2013
This is probably the most pathetic reading of empiric information i have ever seen in my life.
ArXiv and Phys.org should be ashamed in even showing it to the public and Stanford University should seriously consider to bann this "researches" from using its name for publishing nonsense like this.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.