Review: Chromebook improves, but still doesn't beat PC


Google has done a good job of improving its Chrome OS software. But the flagship Chromebook doesn't fulfill the software's potential.

OS is a PC operating system that competes with Microsoft's Windows and Apple's OS X. It's based on Linux and built around Google's Chrome browser. Everything you do on a - the moniker given to laptops running Chrome OS - is done through the Chrome browser, including sending email, changing settings and .

I've been testing the Samsung Chromebook, which is the first Chrome computer to feature a chip based on technology from ARM, rather than an . Thanks in part to that change, the new Chromebook is cheaper, lighter and thinner, and its battery lasts longer than its predecessors.

Those are all good things, but I found the new Chromebook to be a disappointing device. It performs OK if all you want to do is view a Web page or two. But if you try to use it like a regular office PC, with multiple applications or browser windows running at once, it's sluggish and frustrating.

The Chromebook is unremarkable in its appearance. Its silver-colored plastic shell is thin, but not as slim as the new Windows-based ultrabooks. And it's lightweight; at less than 2 { pounds, it's almost as light as Apple's featherweight Air.

What sets it apart is its operating system.

When Google launched Chrome OS more than two years ago, it was buggy, lacked many features and sported a radical new interface that included neither windowed applications nor a traditional desktop. But Google has updated the software repeatedly since then, making it much more reliable and satisfying to use. Because it's simpler than a traditional operating system, Chrome starts up, shuts down and resumes from sleep quickly.

Chromebooks don't run traditional programs and don't have access to many popular PC apps, such as Apple's or . Instead, they run Web-based applications, which number in the thousands and can in many cases replace traditional PC programs. You can't yet run many sophisticated PC games, but you can edit photos, write letters and even design 3-D objects in a browser window.

The other big distinction of the new Chromebook is its Samsung-built ARM chip. ARM processors, which are known for being extremely power-efficient, dominate the world of smartphones and tablets, but are just starting to show up in PCs.

says the new Chromebook should run for more than 6 hours on a single charge and that's about what I experienced. ARM chips can also run without fans, which makes the Chromebook exceptionally quiet.

But I found the new Chromebook to be underpowered. Just going through my Gmail inbox seemed to tax the device. Loading each new message took noticeably longer than it did on my Windows-based , which is by no means a power machine.

And when I tried to do my regular work on it, the Chromebook felt even more inadequate. I frequently have a dozen or more browser tabs open, displaying my inbox, my Facebook news feed, my Twitter stream, my calendar, articles I've looked up in my research, and more.

My office laptop balances all these tabs well enough. I can usually flip from tab to tab quickly. And I can easily see if I've gotten new email or instant messages.

The Chromebook, by contrast, struggled to keep up with even half the tabs I typically have open. As I flipped from tab to tab, it frequently would have to reload the nominally open Web pages. That was frustrating when I flipped to pages of news articles, not only because I had to wait for the pages to reload, but also because I typically would lose my place on the page.

The reloading was even more frustrating when I was trying to write a blog entry or type in a word processing window. Not only would the browser window reload, but I'd often lose my place in the document and would have to scroll back to where I'd just been writing.

I had intended to write this review on the Chromebook. But pressed for time, I gave up and went back to my PC. It may be more complicated, but it got the job done much faster.



-Likes: Inexpensive. Quick to start up, shut down and resume from sleep. Easy to maintain. New desktop-like windowed interface easier to use than before.

-Dislikes: Slow to load pages. Sluggish when using multiple tabs. Can't run many popular PC programs.

-Specs: Dual-core 1.7 GHz ARM-based Samsung chip, 2GB of memory, 16 GB flash drive, 11.6-inch screen.

-Price: $250


Explore further

Samsung Series 5 Chromebook irons out kinks

More information: Troy Wolverton is a technology columnist for the San Jose Mercury News.

(c)2013 San Jose Mercury News (San Jose, Calif.)
Distributed by MCT Information Services

Citation: Review: Chromebook improves, but still doesn't beat PC (2013, January 31) retrieved 6 December 2021 from
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

Feedback to editors