Evidence contradicts idea that starvation caused saber-tooth cat extinction

Evidence contradicts idea that starvation caused saber-tooth cat extinction
This shows Larisa DeSantis preparing dental molds of saber-tooth cat teeth at the La Brea Tar Pits in Los Angeles. Credit: Courtesy of Larisa DeSantis, Vanderbilt University

The latest study of the microscopic wear patterns on the teeth of the American lions and saber-toothed cats that roamed North America in the late Pleistocene found that they were living well off the fat of the land in the period just before they went extinct.

In the period just before they went extinct, the American lions and saber-toothed that roamed North America in the were living well off the fat of the land.

That is the conclusion of the latest study of the microscopic wear patterns on the teeth of these great cats recovered from the La Brea tar pits in southern California. Contrary to previous studies, the analysis did not find any indications that the giant carnivores were having increased trouble finding prey in the period before they went extinct 12,000 years ago.

The results, published on Dec. 26 in the scientific journal PLOS ONE, contradicts previous dental studies and presents a problem for the most popular explanations for the Megafaunal (or Quaternary) extinction when the great cats, mammoths and a number of the largest that existed around the world disappeared.

Saber-toothed cats in California were not driven to extinction by lack of food
Sabertoothed cats were not limited by food in California during the late Pleistocene. Citation: DeSantis LRG, Schubert BW, Scott JR, Ungar PS (2012) Implications of Diet for the Extinction of Saber-Toothed Cats and American Lions. PLoS ONE 7(12): e52453. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0052453 Credit: Mauricio Anton
"The popular theory for the Megafaunal extinction is that either the at the end of the or human activity – or some combination of the two – killed off most of the large mammals," said Larisa DeSantis, assistant professor of earth and environmental sciences at Vanderbilt, who headed the study. "In the case of the great cats, we expect that it would have been increasingly difficult for them to find prey, especially if had to compete with humans. We know that when food becomes scarce, carnivores like the great cats tend to consume more of the they kill. If they spent more time chomping on bones, it should cause detectable changes in the wear patterns on their teeth."

In 1993, Blaire Van Valkenburgh at UCLA published a paper on tooth breakage in large carnivores in the late Pleistocene. Analyzing teeth of American lions, saber-tooth cats, dire wolves and coyotes from La Brea, she found that they had approximately three times the number of broken teeth of contemporary predators and concluded, "...these findings suggest that these species utilized carcasses more fully and likely competed more intensely for food than present-day large carnivores."

The latest study uses a new technique, called dental microwear texture analysis (DMTA), developed by co-authorPeter Ungar at the University of Arkansas. It uses a confocal microscope to produce a three-dimensional image of the surface of a tooth. The image is then analyzed for microscopic wear patterns. Chowing down on red meat produces small parallel scratches. Chomping on bones adds larger, deeper pits. Previous methods of dental wear analysis relied on researchers to identify and count these different types of features. DMTA relies on automated software and is considered more accurate because it reduces the possibility of observer bias.

Evidence contradicts idea that starvation caused saber-tooth cat extinction
This is a skeleton of a saber-toothed cat exhibited at the Page Museum at the La Brea Tar Pits in Los Angeles. Credit: Courtesy of Larisa DeSantis / Vanderbilt University

DeSantis and Ungar, with the assistance of Blaine Schubert from East Tennessee State University and Jessica Scott from the University of Arkansas, applied DMTA to the fossil teeth of 15 American lions (Panthera atrox) and 15 saber-tooth cats (Smilodon fatalis) recovered from the in Los Angeles.

Their analysis revealed that the wear pattern on the teeth of the American lion most closely resembled those of the present-day cheetah, which actively avoids bones when it feeds. Similarly, the saber-tooth cat's wear pattern most closely resembled those of the present-day African lion, which indulges in some bone crushing when it eats. (This differs from a previous microwear study using a different technique that concluded saber-tooth cats avoided bone to a far greater extent.)

The researchers examined how these patterns changed over time by selecting specimens from tar pits of different ages, ranging from about 35,000 to 11,500 years ago. They did not find any evidence that the two carnivores increased their "utilization" of carcasses throughout this period. If anything, their analysis suggests that the proportion of the carcasses that both kinds of cats consumed actually declined toward the end.

The researchers acknowledge the high rate of tooth breakage reported in the previous study, but they argue that it is more likely the result of increased breakage when taking down prey instead of when feeding.

"Teeth can break from the stress of chewing bone but they can also break when the carnivores take down prey," DeSantis pointed out. Species like hyenas that regularly chew and crack bones of their kills are as likely to break the rear teeth they use for chewing as their front canines. Species like the cheetah, however, which avoid bones during feeding are twice as likely to break canines than rear teeth. This suggests that they are more likely to break canines when pulling down prey.

The researchers report that previous examinations of the jaws of the American lions and saber-tooth cats from this period found that they have more than three times as many broken canines and interpret this as additional evidence that supports their conclusion that most of the excess tooth breakage occurred during capture instead of feeding.

In addition, the researchers argue that the large size of the extinct carnivores and their prey can help explain the large number of broken teeth. The saber-toothed cats were about the size of today's African lion and the American lion was about 25 percent larger. The animals that they preyed upon likely included mammoths, four-ton giant ground sloths and 3,500-pound bison.

Larger teeth break more easily than smaller teeth. So larger carnivores are likely to break more canine teeth when attempting to take down larger prey, the researchers argue. They cite a study that modeled the strength of canine teeth that found the canines of a predator the size of fox can support more than seven times its weight before breaking while a predator the size of lion can only support about four times its weight and the curved teeth of the saber-toothed cats can only support about twice its weight.

"The net result of our study is to raise questions about the reigning hypothesis that "tough times" during the late Pleistocene contributed to the gradual extinction of large carnivores," DeSantis summarized. "While we can not determine the exact cause of their demise, it is unlikely that the of these cats was a result of gradually declining prey (due either to changing climates or human competition) because their teeth tell us that these cats were not desperately consuming entire carcasses, as we had expected, and instead seemed to be living the 'good life' during the late Pleistocene, at least up until the very end."

Explore further

Why you should never arm wrestle a saber-toothed tiger

More information: DeSantis LRG, Schubert BW, Scott JR, Ungar PS (2012) Implications of Diet for the Extinction of Saber-Toothed Cats and American Lions. PLoS ONE 7(12): e52453. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0052453 dx.plos.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0052453
Journal information: PLoS ONE

Citation: Evidence contradicts idea that starvation caused saber-tooth cat extinction (2012, December 26) retrieved 17 June 2019 from https://phys.org/news/2012-12-evidence-contradicts-idea-starvation-saber-tooth.html
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

Feedback to editors

User comments

Dec 26, 2012
Why does everything happen about 12,000 years ago, and why doesn't anyone mention the connection between this, "The Legend of Atlantis," and Gobekli Tepe? All of these events supposedly happened about the same time.

Further, why would you necessarily expect a slow starvation event to kill off saber tooth cats? They could just as easily be finished off by a bacteria or virus. Maybe they got toxoplasmosis and it drove them nuts and they jumped in the tar pits or something.

Maybe they were killed by smarter breeds of cat, dog, or heyena.

Dec 27, 2012
Maybe we do need to revisit the less popular hypotheses. If it wasn't humans directly, it could have been zoonoses (seen from the viewpoint of the fauna), from humans and their dogs if any.

@ Lurker: Obviously because there is absolutely no connection between a biological event, myths and constructions on the opposite side of the world. Besides, the Göbekli Tepe was not around until 1000 years later, so that suggestion is pure erroneous. [ http://en.wikiped...kli_Tepe ]

Why one would predict and test for starvation, and why it is a main hypotheses, is described in the article.

Jan 12, 2013
Lurker, you are asking the right questions, which takes some brass on this topic. Also this time period saw many other animals go extinct such as over 20 species of elephant, we have the disappearence of north american ice sheets and clovis man, dramatic rises in sea level, mammoths freezing in Siberia, younger dryas climate change, and a layer of impact nanodiamods and iridium......... this is not a problem of evidence, it is of human psychology.

Gobekli Tepe may well have been a memmorial built by the descendents of the survivors.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more