Via smartphone, college students give final debate to Obama

October 24, 2012
Via smartphone, college students give final debate to Obama
Credit: Amber Boydstun/UC Davis graph

By a margin of more than two to one, college students nationwide said President Obama won Monday night's final presidential debate, according to a smartphone polling application co-designed at the University of California, Davis.

The app allows, for the first time, live reaction to a debate on a large scale. During the final debate, more than 2,300 students from 40 states used the app, clicking "agree," "disagree," "spin" or "dodge" as Obama and Republican challenger Mitt Romney squared off on foreign policy.

Participants gave Obama his third-strongest "agree" spike of the night when he said: "Well, Governor, we also have fewer horses and bayonets…" in response to Republican challenger Mitt Romney's criticisms about the military strength of the United States.

Obama received the most "spin" clicks during his discussion about his trips to the Middle East, mentioning his visit to the Holocaust museum in Yad Vashem.

Romney received the most "dodge" clicks of the night when he dismissed a question about Israel's potential to bomb Iran as "hypothetical."

"This has been a tremendous experience to see how students react when watching the debate live," said Amber Boydstun, an assistant professor of political science at UC Davis who co-designed the app with colleagues at UC Davis; the University of Maryland, College Park; and the University of Arkansas, Little Rock. She cautioned that while immediate reactions can be fleeting, researchers learned a lot from instant reactions.

"Most exciting will be looking at the data in more detail, identifying the specific types of debate cues that vitalize or alienate different types of voters. These findings will inform our understanding of , with implications for candidate debate strategies as well," she said.

Thousands of students from more than 270 classes in about 75 different colleges and universities across the country participated in field tests of the app during the vice presidential debate and three presidential debates.

At UC Davis, students used the debate viewing app at their own locations in apartments and dormitories, but also at debate viewing parties organized for both the first debate Oct. 3 and Monday's final debate. Similar gatherings were held at colleges throughout the country.

Following the final debate, 8 percent of participants said they had changed their minds about whom to vote for, with about two-thirds switching to Obama. Slightly more than a third shifted to Romney. Most of those who shifted their votes had been undecided at the beginning of the debate.

More than half of the participants said they were Democrats and about a third said they were Republicans. Nearly 60 percent said they intended to vote for Obama. More than half of all participants were male.

When broken down by ethnicity, 65 percent of participants were white, 12 percent were Hispanic, 9 percent Asian, and 9 percent African American. Five percent described themselves as "other."

A slide show breaking down response by state, race, gender and other factors is available at the React Labs Educate website:

ReactLabs Educate is a collaborative research project designed to track people's real-time responses to the presidential debates.

Philip Resnik, a professor of linguistics and computer science at the University of Maryland and Boydstun's collaborator, has developed a startup company to commercialize the underlying technology.

Explore further: One in 10 college students changed their minds after debate, smartphone app data finds

Related Stories

Biden won debate, student poll app finds

October 15, 2012

Six in 10 college students say Joe Biden outperformed Paul Ryan in Thursday's vice presidential debate, according to a nationwide poll conducted with a smartphone application developed by Professor Phil Resnik at Maryland ...

Smartphone app will allow instant polling for debate

October 3, 2012

When President Obama and Republican challenger Mitt Romney square off in their first debate Wednesday (Oct. 3), college students across the country will pilot test a new smartphone application that promises to make live polling ...

3Qs: Who won the first debate?

October 5, 2012

Alan Schroeder, a pro­fessor in the School of Jour­nalism in the Col­lege of Arts, Media and Design and one of the nation's fore­most experts on pres­i­den­tial debates, offers an analysis of the first of three match-​​ups ...

Recommended for you

Averaging the wisdom of crowds

December 12, 2017

The best decisions are made on the basis of the average of various estimates, as confirmed by the research of Dennie van Dolder and Martijn van den Assem, scientists at VU Amsterdam. Using data from Holland Casino promotional ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.