A new approach for solving protein structures

September 6, 2012 by Laura Mgrdichian
A new approach for solving protein structures
A native protein structure as determined using the multiple-crystal SAD method. The complex of four protein chains is shown as a ribbon diagram and is colored violet. The anomalously scattering substructure, containing 28 sulfur atoms and three sulfate ions, is represented as spheres (yellow for sulfur, yellow/red for sulfate).

(Phys.org)—Using synchrotron x-ray beams to solve the molecular structures of proteins and other large biological molecules has yielded many advances in medicine, such as drug therapies for cancer. Improvements in the techniques available to scientists could lead to even more exciting advances. Recently, scientists from NSLS, the New York Structural Biology Center and Columbia University discovered a new method to determine molecular structures that would have been difficult or impossible to solve otherwise. Their work is reported in the May 25 online edition of Science.

The process of using to determine protein structures, known as macromolecular crystallography, begins by growing pure crystals of the molecule. Crystals, being regular arrays of these molecules, generate diffraction patterns when exposed to x-rays, and these diffraction data can be measured accurately and used to extract structural information – a very complex task.

When a has similar structure relatives, the process is easier. But when it does not, scientists face the "phase problem," the loss of critical information describing the "phase" of the incident x-rays waves – that is, the waves' positions relative to each other. When a detector records the , it can measure intensity, but not phase, and without phases the structure cannot be completely solved.

When no related structure exists, there are other ways to evaluate the phases. Two of these methods are x-ray crystallographic techniques: multiwavelength anomalous diffraction (MAD), in which x-rays of more than one wavelength are used; and single-wavelength anomalous diffraction (SAD), which uses x-rays of just one wavelength. (MAD and SAD were developed by this study's corresponding author, Columbia biophysicist Wayne Hendrickson.)

Both techniques typically involve adding selenium into the (via the amino acid derivative selenomethionine, which incorporates easily into proteins) and scanning the x-ray beam across the atom's edge. Selenium is a heavier atom than those usually found in proteins – carbon, nitrogen, and oxygen, for example – and it absorbs and re-emits x-rays with element-specific resonance. From the resonant , scientists can determine the phase. (The selenomethionine substitution method for MAD phasing was also developed by Hendrickson.)

Here, working at NSLS beamline X4A, the group developed a way to solve the phase problem without adding a heavy element to the crystal, and instead were able to use proteins in their native state. They used off-resonance scattering from the proteins' own sulfur atoms, which is much feebler than that from selenium, but yet strong enough to be workable. They applied SAD to several crystals (between five and 13 for each protein studied) using lower-than-usual x-ray energies and then combined the relatively weak diffraction signals.

The four proteins they solved varied in size and contained different amounts of sulfur (between three and 28 sulfur sites on each molecule). The group's success with each one suggests that their work has opened a doorway for a potentially vast new landscape of discoveries in macromolecular crystallography.

"The idea of using sulfur SAD phasing is an old one, but its impact has been limited until now," said Hendrickson. "We are excited by the dramatic improvements in signal-to-noise and phasing efficacy that derive from multi-crystal averaging."

At the future NSLS successor, NSLS-II, which will offer an extremely bright x-ray beam and the most advanced synchrotron tools, Hendrickson and his group expect to make further progress with this technique. NSLS-II's x-ray beam will be much smaller and more intense, allowing scientists to use smaller crystals. At the same time, the beam is also more likely to damage a single protein crystal before all the data has been collected. Therefore, a technique that uses multiple crystals could work exceptionally well.

Explore further: Fastest X-ray images of tiny biological crystals

Related Stories

Fastest X-ray images of tiny biological crystals

January 5, 2012

(PhysOrg.com) -- An international research team headed by DESY scientists from the Center for Free-Electron Laser Science (CFEL) in Hamburg, Germany, has recorded the shortest X-ray exposure of a protein crystal ever achieved. ...

New strategy could lead to dose reduction in X-ray imaging

November 22, 2011

For more than a century, the use of X-rays has been a prime diagnostic tool when it comes to human health. As it turns out, X-rays also are a crucial component for studying and understanding molecules, and a new approach ...

Powders show their strength

October 9, 2007

[PIC=:left]Growing a single crystal of a protein can be very difficult. Thanks to recent developments, a powder sample may be enough to solve a structure.

Unveiling the structure of microcrystals

October 4, 2007

Microcrystals take the form of tiny grains resembling powder, which is extremely difficult to study. For the first time, researchers from the European Synchrotron Radiation Facility (ESRF) and the Centre National de Recherche ...

New technique to see crystals like never before

November 30, 2011

An international team of scientists led by the Fresnel Institute and the ESRF (European Synchrotron Radiation Facility) in Grenoble has developed a new technique allowing to observe the nanometer-sized structure of crystalline ...

Recommended for you

Flexible ferroelectrics bring two material worlds together

January 17, 2017

Until recently, "flexible ferroelectrics" could have been thought of as the same type of oxymoronic phrase. However, thanks to a new discovery by the U.S. Department of Energy's (DOE) Argonne National Laboratory in collaboration ...

First-ever X-ray image capture of material defect process

January 17, 2017

From blacksmiths forging iron to artisans blowing glass, humans have for centuries been changing the properties of materials to build better tools – from iron horseshoes and swords to glass jars and medicine vials.

Theory lends transparency to how glass breaks

January 16, 2017

Over time, when a metallic glass is put under stress, its atoms will shift, slide and ultimately form bands that leave the material more prone to breaking. Rice University scientists have developed new computational methods ...

0 comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.