Taking some guesswork out of high-energy physics

August 7, 2012 by Lori Ann White, SLAC National Accelerator Laboratory
SLAC theoretical physicist Stan Brodsky, right, and colleague Xing-Gang Wu, who demonstrated the Principle of Maximum Conformality in a recently published paper. (Photo by Matt Beardsley)

(Phys.org) -- SLAC theorist Stan Brodsky and his collaborator Xing-Gang Wu of Chongqing University have just made the lives of high-energy particle theorists the world over a bit easier. They've demonstrated a way to literally take some of the guesswork out of predictions from quantum chromodynamics (QCD). QCD is the theory explaining the behavior of quarks, which in groups of three form protons and neutrons, and gluons, which carry the strong force that "glues" the quarks together.

In the realm of QCD, interactions are the thing. It's not enough to know which make up a particle; just as important is their dynamics: how those quarks bounce off each other and what messages the carry between them as they jostle about. Eavesdropping on quarks is not easy.

To make matters worse, "virtual" particles from the effects of keep popping in and out of existence, changing the discussion. It's as if you're trying to talk to a friend in the midst of a crowd of chatty strangers; of their chatter keep floating over to you and your friend, some from close by – some from farther away – redirecting your train of thought.

Fortunately, thanks to the property of "asymptotic freedom," the closer together the particles, the quieter the conversation. All that extra chatter has a real effect in QCD, and up until now, theorists could only guess as to how many of the interlopers were in an interaction, how loud they were and how they changed the conversation.

In a paper published last week in the journal Physical Review Letters, Brodsky and Wu demonstrated the "Principle of Maximum Conformality," (PMC) a mathematical technique that enables theorists to accurately set the number of virtual chatterboxes and their loudness. The critical variable that controls the effects of quantum corrections is called the "renormalization scale of the QCD running coupling," which, in this analogy, would equate to where the volume dial is set.

According to Brodsky and Wu, PMC has the important feature of giving the same prediction independent of theoretical conventions used to define the QCD coupling. In other words, theorists hear the same conversation no matter where they initially set the volume.

Brodsky and Wu tested their technique on a puzzle that theorists have been scratching their heads over since 2010. The CDF collaboration at Fermilab reported that top quark-anti-top quark pairs spraying out of collisions at the Tevatron didn't precisely follow the trajectories predicted by theorists. The original QCD calculations were based on a guess for the renormalization scale.

However, using PMC to set the scale removed the discrepancy, predicting just what the Tevatron experimentalists observed (within acceptable amounts of error). The PMC method was developed in collaboration with Leonardo di Giustino of the University of Parma, based on earlier work by Brodsky with collaborators G. Peter Lepage of Cornell University and Paul Mackenzie of Fermilab.

Brodsky and Wu said that now that PMC has been demonstrated to work, it can be used to eliminate a major systematic uncertainty in QCD predictions, allowing the theory to be tested more precisely. Their method can also be applied to quantum electrodynamics, the quantum theory explaining the behavior of electrically charged particles.

Even more important, they say, PMC can increase the sensitivity of collider and other experiments to new physics beyond the Standard Model.

"When we use this technique we can have more confidence in our predictions," Brodsky said. "And when we find a discrepancy, it may really expose new physics."

Explore further: Gravity-like theories give insight into the strong force

More information: prl.aps.org/abstract/PRL/v109/i4/e042002

Related Stories

Gravity-like theories give insight into the strong force

June 7, 2010

A new computation of the constant that describes the strength of the force between the quarks in a proton may help theorists tackle one of the most challenging problems of physics: analytically solving the theory of QCD and ...

Hunting the unseen

July 15, 2011

A better knowledge about the composition of sub-atomic particles such as protons and neutrons has sparked conjecture about, as yet, unseen particles. A tool based on theoretical calculations that could aid the search for ...

Describing particle coupling in condensed matter

June 22, 2012

The seemingly countless recent discoveries and predictions of particle physics are spurred by increasingly sophisticated mathematical theories and predictions. European researchers made important contributions to descriptions ...

Scientists build GPU cluster for subatomic calculations

February 14, 2012

The latest addition to computing power at DOE’s Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory is a 45-teraflop cluster of graphics processing units that scientists use to explore the properties of the strong nuclear force. The ...

Glasgow scientists predict mass of new particle

January 26, 2010

(PhysOrg.com) -- A team of physicists from the University of Glasgow has predicted the mass of a new particle which would help explain one of the fundamental forces of the universe.

Recommended for you

Scientists create diodes made of light

March 16, 2018

Photonics researchers at the National Physical Laboratory (NPL) have achieved the extra-ordinary by creating a diode consisting of light that can be used, for the first time, in miniaturised photonic circuits, as published ...

Quantum speed limits are not actually quantum

March 15, 2018

Quantum mechanics has fundamental speed limits—upper bounds on the rate at which quantum systems can evolve. However, two groups working independently have published papers showing for the first time that quantum speed ...

The view from inside supersonic combustion

March 15, 2018

In a jet engine, the flow of air is slowed down to increase the temperature and pressure for combustion—burning fuel with the right ratio of fuel and air to conquer drag allows for acceleration.


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

5 / 5 (4) Aug 07, 2012
We need to know more! Please write a longer follow up article.
Aug 07, 2012
This comment has been removed by a moderator.
1 / 5 (4) Aug 07, 2012
To make matters worse, "virtual" particles from the effects of quantum field theory keep popping in and out of existence, changing the discussion. It's as if you're trying to talk to a friend in the midst of a crowd of chatty strangers; snippets of their chatter keep floating over to you and your friend, some from close by some from farther away redirecting your train of thought.

By the way, one more crucial inescapable problem (which is not often mentioned) is the infinite amount of vacuum energy arisen from virtual particles concept! May be this understandable concept (below) could solve the problem.


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.