Whether tweets live or die depends more on network, competition for attention than message or user influence

April 3, 2012, Indiana University
A visualization of meme distribution originating from the #GOP Twitter hashtag about the U.S. Republican Party displays strong polarization between people with opposing views. Credit: Indiana University

On the global social media stage, it's not so much the message but rather network structure and competition for attention that determine whether a meme becomes popular and shows staying power or whether it falls by the wayside, research led by Indiana University has determined.

After analyzing 120 million retweets connected to 12.5 million users and 1.3 million hashtags, the team from IU Bloomington's School of Informatics and Computing was able to model the mechanisms of meme competition in the Twitter social network and show how information spread is shaped. The findings show it's not as much the message as it is the medium, and even memory, that determines whether an Internet meme goes viral or dies without a trace.

The research, published March 29 in Scientific Reports and conducted at the school's Center for and Systems Research, is the first to attempt addressing social media as a series of new, unrestrained epidemics continuously input into a system. IU Bloomington informatics associate professor Alessandro Flammini, one of the paper's authors, said the model is similar to a .

"In an ecosystem you have individuals, which here would be posts, that belong to different species (the memes) that produce in an environment -- in this case our collective attention -- that can sustain only a limited number of individuals," he said. "When individuals belonging to a new species enter, as many individuals die as needed to maintain the sustainability threshold."

Visualization of meme diffusion related to the Arab Spring and the 2011 uprisings from the #Egypt hashtag, which shows strong connectivity and many users linked to one another to form a dense cluster. Credit: Indiana University

It's not that the scientists found the message played no role in the , but it was the mechanisms of competition and the economization of attention that were sufficient for them to generate a complex information landscape in which a number of different meme spreading patterns could be defined. And excluding either social or user finite attention as key ingredients in the information diffusion model led to results that were inconsistent with the empirical data they had.

"At a statistical level, we found that it is not necessary to include external explanations like intrinsic appeal, user influence or external events to observe the global dynamics of memes," said another co-author, IU professor of and computer science Filippo Menczer. "This provides a real stop-and-pause moment for us as it makes information epidemics quite different from the basic modeling and conceptual framework of biological epidemics."

Informaticists have traditionally used the epidemic process as inspiration for representations of information spread, with "infection" spreading along the edges of the social network. But until now they always focused on a single infection (meme) at a time, said IU Ph.D. candidate and lead author Lilian Weng.

"The research calls out for new and different frameworks of analysis of competition among ideas and for new strategies for the optimization or suppression of their spread," she said. "We now know there is no need to assume different intrinsic values among ideas in explaining the massive diversity in the popularity and persistence of memes. At a statistical level, it is competition for limited attention and the social network that can provide the answers."

To identify the extreme diversity of behavior that allows some memes to become popular and persistent while the vast majority die off quickly, the team developed a meme diffusion model with agents (users) that maintained time-ordered posts, each about a specific meme. Neighbors received new memes, a memory mechanism allowed agents to develop interests and focus, and limited attention was included by allowing posts to survive on agents' lists for a finite time period. A retweet model was also employed, and then simulations were conducted taking into account the novelty and number of retweets along with the diversity of user interests, all of which came from the Twitter data.

By scaling down the social network to correspond with a subset of the overall user group (12.5 million users/1.3 million hashtags) and simulating stronger or weaker competition for limited attention by modulating the time that posts were allowed to be retained by agents, the team was able to develop a model focused solely on competition mechanisms that allowed for the evaluation of making attention more scarce or abundant.

Explore further: Researcher presents latest work on tracking ideas in social media

More information: Co-author with Weng, Menczer and Flammini on "Competition among memes in a world with limited attention" was Alessandro Vespignani, Sternberg Distinguished Professor of Physics, Computer Science and Health Sciences at Northeastern University.

Related Stories

Yahoo is Going Portuguese Hound to Outwit Twitter

May 15, 2009

Brazil, a Portuguese speaking country is the 10th largest economy in the world and Yahoo has decided to get in on the action by coming up with a clone Twitter. The economic down-turn has affected Brazil to some degree, but ...

New model for epidemic contagion

January 11, 2012

Humans are considered the hosts for spreading epidemics. The speed at which an epidemic spreads is now better understood thanks to a new model accounting for the provincial nature of human mobility, according to a study published ...

Technology on way to forecasting humanity's needs

July 23, 2009

Much as meteorologists predict the path and intensity of hurricanes, Indiana University's Alessandro Vespignani believes we will one day predict with unprecedented foresight, specificity and scale such things as the economic ...

Recommended for you

Unprecedented study of Picasso's bronzes uncovers new details

February 17, 2018

Musee national Picasso-Paris and the Northwestern University/Art Institute of Chicago Center for Scientific Studies in the Arts (NU-ACCESS) have completed the first major material survey and study of the Musee national Picasso-Paris' ...

Using Twitter to discover how language changes

February 16, 2018

Scientists at Royal Holloway, University of London, have studied more than 200 million Twitter messages to try and unravel the mystery of how language evolves and spreads.


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

1 / 5 (1) Apr 03, 2012
I'm sorry, I don't mean to sound overly harsh...But this is the most ridiculous and useless claptrap I have encountered in quite some time. (And I have encountered plenty of late.)
not rated yet Apr 03, 2012
so, can i hire them to make my meme viral?
not rated yet Apr 03, 2012
This is what I have suspected for years now, we are not a rational species. That we are capable of reason to varying degrees has little impact on our behavior. We are all born with the ability to sprint yet except for a few freaks none of us do. The same is true for thinking.

It's not just that most Christians aren't very Christ-like and miss the whole "It's the message stupid". It's every religion, every news organization every political group. It's all of us.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.