Yield from organically grown crops globally 20% lower than in conventional farming

March 1, 2012

Globally speaking, the yield from crops from organic farming is on average twenty percent lower than from crops grown according to conventional farming methods. This is the finding of a so-called meta-study carried out by researchers at Wageningen University, part of Wageningen UR.  The study involved comparing 362 pieces of scientific research published over the past 25 years to ascertain the yield gap between organic and conventional crops. The researchers stress that the study in no way forms a basis for arguments for or against organic or conventional farming, as differences in the burden on the environment, for example, were not taken into account.

The debate about whether can contribute to global food issues tends to revolve around one main topic: whether organic methods can produce enough food to feed a growing world population. In 2050, it is estimated that the world population will have reached nine billion. Moreover, this population will be making higher demands of its food.

Over the last few years, various studies have been carried out to compare yields from organic farming with those from conventional farming. The findings varied greatly with yields in the organic farming sector of 50 percent lower to 20 percent higher.

The meta-study, which was published in this month’s Agricultural Systems, is the first large-scale study to use only data of the highest quality.

All the relevant literature databases compiled over the past 25 years threw up more than a thousand scientific publications. After thorough screening for data quality, 362 crop yield comparisons in organic and conventional farming remained. The data covered 68 different and came from 43 different countries. This comprehensive research shows that when compared with conventional farming, current crop yield from organic farming, for which the criteria include not using artificial fertilisers or synthetic crop protection agents, are on average 20 percent lower. In countries where conventional agriculture is well-developed, such as the Netherlands and Denmark, this figure is higher, i.e. 26 percent.

However, in the light of social and scientific debate about the part played by both types of farming in global food issues, the researchers make a number of comments regarding the significance of the findings. The gap noted applies solely to the so-called crop level. The researchers suspect that the gap in yield could be higher than twenty per cent at farm, regional and global level. Their arguments are based on the fact that in organic farming, plants nutrients are largely dependent on animal manure and the planting of leguminosae, which are sometimes rotated with grain crops as a means of green manure, and therefore do not contribute directly to food production.

Another important proviso is the dire lack of reliable data from developing countries, which are the very areas with low soil fertility and high disease and pest pressure. The extent of intensity in conventional farming possibly partly explains the regional differences in yield gap found. In addition, some crops are not as suited to organic farming techniques as others: the researchers discovered that tuberous and root vegetable crops, including potatoes, show a larger gap between the two methods, while pulses, including soya, feature a smaller gap.

The researchers think that irrespective of the size of the gap in yield, there can still be good reasons for choosing organic farming. These may include reducing the burden on the local environment, the exhaustibility of natural resources and biodiversity, but also ethical reasons relating to animal welfare and genetically modified organisms. Another reason could be the relative scarcity or affordability of artificial fertilisers and crop protection agents. Organic agriculture can also be valuable as an experimental site for testing more sustainable conventional farming techniques.

The conventional agriculture sector will have to become more efficient and cleaner, and in this respect, has a lot to learn from farming on the cutting edge: with little or no synthetic crop protection agents, such as in organic farming, or with a lot of organic fertilisers. However on the basis of these results, the researchers conclude that if organic farming methods are used, more land is needed to produce the same amount of food.

Explore further: Organic farming improves pollination success in strawberries

More information: Tomek de Ponti, et al., The crop yield gap between organic and conventional agriculture, Agricultural Systems 108 (2012) 1-9

Related Stories

Organic farming shows limited benefit to wildlife

May 5, 2010

Organic farms may be seen as wildlife friendly, but the benefits to birds, bees and butterflies don't compensate for the lower yields produced, according to new research from the University of Leeds.

Recommended for you

Scientists create first stable semisynthetic organism

January 23, 2017

Life's genetic code has only ever contained four natural bases. These bases pair up to form two "base pairs"—the rungs of the DNA ladder—and they have simply been rearranged to create bacteria and butterflies, penguins ...

New steps in the meiosis chromosome dance

January 23, 2017

Where would we be without meiosis and recombination? For a start, none of us sexually reproducing organisms would be here, because that's how sperm and eggs are made. And when meiosis doesn't work properly, it can lead to ...

Research describes missing step in how cells move their cargo

January 23, 2017

Every time a hormone is released from a cell, every time a neurotransmitter leaps across a synapse to relay a message from one neuron to another, the cell must undergo exocytosis. This is the process responsible for transporting ...

Lab charts the anatomy of three molecular channels

January 23, 2017

Using a state-of-the-art imaging technology in which molecules are deep frozen, scientists in Roderick MacKinnon's lab at Rockefeller University have reconstructed in unprecedented detail the three-dimensional architecture ...

Immune defense without collateral damage

January 23, 2017

Researchers from the University of Basel in Switzerland have clarified the role of the enzyme MPO. In fighting infections, this enzyme, which gives pus its greenish color, produces a highly aggressive acid that can kill pathogens ...

Provocative prions may protect yeast cells from stress

January 23, 2017

Prions have a notorious reputation. They cause neurodegenerative disease, namely mad cow/Creutzfeld-Jakob disease. And the way these protein particles propagate—getting other proteins to join the pile—can seem insidious.


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.