Transportation fuels expert says policy makers need to think about practical ways to reach new energy goals

December 8, 2011
Transportation fuels expert says policy makers need to think about practical ways to reach new energy goals
Sandia’s Dawn Manley, who testified in front of the State of California’s Senate Transportation and Housing Committee, urges policymakers to consider practical issues when enacting aggressive transportation energy policies. (Photo courtesy of The California Channel).

( -- A transportation fuels expert from Sandia National Laboratories says policy makers should consider such practical issues as the number of gas stations selling ethanol and how long it takes to get new transportation technologies to market as they introduce aggressive federal and state energy policies.

“Policymakers need to have ways to think about the evolution from the current state of transportation energy to the desired future state,” Dawn Manley said. “It is one thing to set aggressive targets on emission reductions, but you need to examine options for reaching desired future states in order to get there,” she told California’s Senate Transportation and Housing Committee on Oct. 24.

State lawmakers are examining the long-term viability of available fuels to meet the state’s transportation demands, particularly those related to AB 32, a much-publicized California law that aims to reduce greenhouse gas emissions to 1990 levels.

According to the state Air Resources Board (ARB), which is implementing AB32, transportation accounts for 38 percent of greenhouse gas emissions in the state, hence the committee’s focus on .

As an example of the difficulties that can arise when trying to execute new energy goals, Manley pointed to the Renewable Fuels Standard, a federal requirement that sets targets for biofuel production and volume. Specifically, a potential mismatch between the amount of ethanol biofuel that would be produced and the infrastructure to both absorb and distribute it could produce delays.

Currently, only 3 to 5 percent of the U.S. transportation fleet is composed of flex-fuel vehicles, which can operate on gasoline blends containing up to 85 percent ethanol (E85). About 2,400 gas stations in the U.S. – only a fraction of the 160,000 gas stations in the country – can dispense E85.

Two possible solutions are to have either higher blend requirements for all vehicles or more flex-fuel vehicles that can accept up to 85 percent ethanol, she said.

Even the seemingly modest policy change of going from 10 to 15 percent ethanol (approved last year) required waivers from the Environmental Protection Agency, Manley said. Also necessary was testing to demonstrate that higher blends are safe and free from higher emissions, and education of consumers who need to know when and how to use E15 ethanol.

The proposed changes in policies, she said, are just one example of how a shift to advanced transportation technologies such as electric vehicles, fuel cells and other biofuels pose enormous challenges.

Many in the transportation policy community want electric vehicles to become a standard in the U.S. transportation fleet. But, even if the assertion proves true that a vast majority of vehicles in the year 2050 will use some form of electrification, Manley echoed a recent op-ed article in the Washington Post (authored by Bob Carling, director of Sandia’s Transportation Energy Center) and reminded the committee that most of those vehicles likely will still be using a combination of electric and combustion engines since an all-battery-powered vehicle fleet is unlikely by then.

“We need to realize that there is still much to be gained with the combustion engine,” Manley said. “Even with all the exciting new technologies out there, a good chunk of electric vehicles are still going to be making use of the combustion engine.”

She also emphasized that speed and scale are key in terms of advanced technology development, since it takes 15 to 20 years to change over the transportation fleet. “We all tend to think that hybrids are a mature transportation technology, but the fact is that they still only make up about 5 percent of all vehicle sales today,” she said. “We still have a long way to go.”

Manley also reflected on a recent visit to China and suggested that decision makers in the U.S. can learn some lessons from their counterparts in Asia.

“When making decisions about transportation energy investments and technology development, the Chinese have described their strategy in terms of points, lines and areas,” she explained. “’Points’ refers to dense urban areas, and they consider the kinds of vehicles that will make the most sense there. ‘Lines’ are what connect those urban areas, so the Chinese think about the transportation strategies that are most effective in doing that. Finally, ‘areas’ are the broader, rural and agricultural regions of the country, so again, they look at the unique transportation needs in these areas and build their strategies around them.”

No one technology or policy will fit every transportation need, Manley said.

Explore further: Ethanol vs. Electricity: Biomass converted into electricity could be more efficient than ethanol (w/Video)

Related Stories

Argonne helps China create cleaner Beijing for 2008 Olympics

October 9, 2007

The U.S. Department of Energy's Argonne National Laboratory is working closely with Chinese scientists and policy makers toward the goal of creating a cleaner Beijing and developing sustainable technologies for the 2008 Olympic ...

Report presents best policy options to reduce petroleum use

June 23, 2011

It will take more than tougher fuel economy standards for U.S. transportation to significantly cut its oil use over the next half century. It will likely require a combination of measures that foster consumer and supplier ...

Recommended for you

US faces moment of truth on 'net neutrality'

December 14, 2017

The acrimonious battle over "net neutrality" in America comes to a head Thursday with a US agency set to vote to roll back rules enacted two years earlier aimed at preventing a "two-speed" internet.

The wet road to fast and stable batteries

December 14, 2017

An international team of scientists—including several researchers from the U.S. Department of Energy's (DOE) Argonne National Laboratory—has discovered an anode battery material with superfast charging and stable operation ...

Microbes help turn Greek yogurt waste into fuel

December 13, 2017

Consumers across the world enjoy Greek yogurt for its taste, texture, and protein-packed punch. Reaching that perfect formula, however, generates large volumes of food waste in the form of liquid whey. Now researchers in ...

1 comment

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Dec 08, 2011
PV cells on homes could be devoted to both recharging electric vehicles and slowly setting up the use of electric heating elements,dryers,and stoves.Supplementing home production with more efficient renewable energy streams entering the present grid structure would give utilities and opportunity to maintain their present obligations.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.