EU moves to 'green' its farms in reform effort

October 12, 2011 by Yann Ollivier
The EU has called for a greener, fairer farm policy as it moved to radically overhaul its Common Agricultural Policy (CAP) by capping subsidies and tying them to environmental concerns.

The EU called for a greener, fairer farm policy on Wednesday as it moved to radically overhaul its Common Agricultural Policy (CAP) by capping subsidies and tying them to environmental concerns.

"The CAP must be redefined," EU Agriculture Commissioner Dacian Ciolos told the , outlining a sweeping plan to reform the EU's controversial farming subsidies from 2014 -- a plan set to trigger months of heated debate.

Among his proposals to rethink the CAP, which traditionally accounts for about 40 percent of the bloc's annual spending of nearly 140 billion euros, is a call for 30 percent of EU direct farm subisidies to be conditional on respect for the environment.

The measures include , maintaining permanent pastures and creating ecological fallows that are havens for plants, animals and on at least seven percent of arable land.

Ciolos said the reforms would lead to an agricultural U-turn, putting Europe's 12 million farms on the road to "" after years of free for all.

To even out subsidies in the interests of , Ciolos wants to cap payouts to farmers at 300,000 euros ($424,000) per year. In addition, levies would be applied progressively on all payments exceeding 150,000 euros.

While highly-mechanised large farms would be hit, those using a large number of workers could win exemptions as salaries could be deducted from the handouts.

EU Agriculture and Rural Development commissioner Dacian Ciolos speaks at a news conference on the adoption by the EC of the legislative proposals for the Common Agriculture Policy (CAP) after 2013 at the European headquarters in Brussels. The EU has called for a greener, fairer farm policy as it moved to radically overhaul CAP by capping subsidies and tying them to environmental concerns.

Germany, the Netherlands and Britain -- where the royal family are major beneficiaries of the subsidies -- strongly oppose capping subsidies on the grounds it could lead to a carve-up of large farms.

Large farms remain the rule across Europe, with EU data this week showing that over the last seven years, the number of farms has decreased 20 percent but the average size has come down only two percent.

Likewise in the interests of the environment, Ciolos is proposing to gradually favour extensive rather than by progressively calculating subsidies per hectare (acre) from 2014 to 2019, rather than basing payments on production, as has often been the case.

The proposals are intended also to address squabbling between member states on their respective quotas, with newer members from eastern Europe complaining more money goes to founder states.

However, while France, currently the top beneficiary, would see a 1.5 percent fall in the 2014-2019, it would remain the largest recipient.

Romania, Bulgaria and the three Baltic nations would see an increase -- in Romania's case of 33.7 percent. But eastern EU members would continue to be behind the older EU members, with Latvia notably 54 percent below the average.

"Politics, especially at the European level, is the art of what is possible," Ciolos said. "The most important thing is to launch movement in the right direction."

Responding to criticism from the EU's Court of Auditors, the commission proposals also seek to ensure go only to "active farmers" -- rather than to airports or golf-clubs, as has sometimes been the case.

Activists of the Friends of the Earth Europe environmental group stage a protest on October 12 in front of EU headquarters in Brussels. The EU has called for a greener, fairer farm policy as it moved to radically overhaul its Common Agricultural Policy (CAP) by capping subsidies and tying them to environmental concerns.

The reform proposals will have to be approved by both the parliament and all member states before taking effect.

But critics are already making their voices heard, with an angry response from Europe's leading farmers' organisation, Copa-Cogeca.

"At a time when the Chinese are massively purchasing land in Africa, we are being asked to leave seven percent of our land fallow," said German Copa-Cogeca official Gerd Sonnleitner.

The group said the reform would leave six to seven million hectares idle.

Bio-innovation leader Novozymes meanwhile said the proposals failed to go far enough.

"A bio-based economy can foster the transition of Europe's agriculture towards an economically and environmentally competitive sector," it said in a statement.

"However, we are disappointed that the current proposal falls short in delivering concrete measures."

Explore further: Brussels plans green EU farming policy

Related Stories

Brussels plans green EU farming policy

October 7, 2011

In a radical overhaul of its controversial Common Agricultural Policy (CAP), the EU plans a greener, fairer farm policy by tying subsidies to environmental concerns, according to documents seen by AFP.

Green Europe eyes farming revolution

November 18, 2010

In a radical overhaul of Europe's controversial Common Agricultural Policy (CAP), the European Commission on Thursday suggested a greener, fairer farming policy for the future, including a rethink of subsidies.

Europe bids to 'halt' biodiversity loss

May 4, 2011

Europe set new targets Tuesday to halt a mainly man-made loss of species costing billions each year as campaigners called for tougher environmental demands on farmers.

Heated fight breaks out over E. coli farm payments

June 7, 2011

(AP) -- Big fruit and vegetable producers Spain, Italy and France angrily demanded compensation Tuesday for farmers who have been blindsided by huge losses in the E. coli outbreak, forcing the EU farm chief to increase his ...

Recommended for you

Hot spot at Hawaii? Not so fast

August 18, 2017

Through analysis of volcanic tracks, Rice University geophysicists have concluded that hot spots like those that formed the Hawaiian Islands aren't moving as fast as recently thought.

Supervolcanoes: A key to America's electric future?

August 16, 2017

Most of the lithium used to make the lithium-ion batteries that power modern electronics comes from Australia and Chile. But Stanford scientists say there are large deposits in sources right here in America: supervolcanoes.

Greenland ice flow likely to speed up

August 16, 2017

Flow of the Greenland Ice Sheet is likely to speed up in the future, despite a recent slowdown, because its outlet glaciers slide over wet sediment, not hard rock, new research based on seismic surveys has confirmed. This ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.