Bending light the 'wrong' way

August 18, 2011, Vienna University of Technology

Bending light the 'wrong' way
So far, it only exists as a montage: This is what a liquid with a negative refractive index could look like (right), as opposed to regular water (left).
( -- Scientists have tried this with sophisticated meta-materials, but at the Vienna University of Technology (TU Vienna) it has now been done with simple metals; materials with a negative refractive index bend light the "wrong" way.

The effect can be seen just by poking a stick into the water; at the , the changes its direction, the stick appears to be bent. This tilt is described by the . For years, scientists have been trying to create special materials with a negative refractive index – their optical properties are quite different from those of normal materials. Researchers at the TU Vienna could now show that even common metals can have a negative refractive index, if they are placed in a magnetic field.

Different Kind of Diffraction for Better Optics

When we drive a car into the snow at the edge of the road, the wheels on the road may turn faster than the wheels on the snow. This changes the direction of the car and it starts skidding. Something quite similar happens to beams of light that travel through the interface between two materials, in which light travels at different speeds – such as air and glass. "The refractive index measures, how strongly the light is deflected", explains Andrei Pimenov, Professor at the Institute for Solid State Physics at the TU Vienna. For years there have been speculations about the properties of possible materials with a negative refractive index. Entering such a material, light would bend in the opposite direction. Scientists believe that this could lead to completely new optical effects and technologies.

Bending light the 'wrong' way
The beam of light enters the metal and is refracted into the opposite direction (left) compared to the usual behavior of light in materials (right).
Metal Bends Light

It was believed that these effects can only be achieved using so called "meta-materials". Such materials are constructed from small intricate structures, which diffract the light in special ways on a microscopic level. At the TU Vienna, scientists found out that with simple tricks even quite common metals such as cobalt or iron can exhibit a negative refractive index. "We place the metal in a strong magnetic field and irradiate it with light of precisely the correct wavelength", Andrei Pimenov explains. He uses microwave radiation, which can penetrate thin foils of metal. Due to magnetic resonance effects in the metal, the light is bent drastically at the surface. Within the metal, it turns into the other direction, as if there was a mirror inside the .

The Perfect Lens

Recently, materials with a negative diffractive index have attracted a great deal of attention, because their peculiar behavior could allow for completely new kinds of optical lenses. The resolution of regular lenses is limited by the wave length of light. With long radar waves, it is impossible to take a picture of a butterfly, with visible light, nobody can depict an atom. "But using a material with a negative refractive index, one could theoretically get infinitely high resolution", says Andrei Pimenov. Being able to use simple metals instead of complicated meta-materials makes things a lot easier. However, before optical lenses with a negative refractive index can be built, scientists have to find ways to compensate for the absorption of the light in the material.

Explore further: Practical Cloaking Devices On The Horizon?

More information: Negative refraction in natural ferromagnetic metals, EPL, 95 (2011) 37005. DOI:10.1209/0295-5075/95/37005

It is generally believed that Veselago's criterion for negative refraction cannot be fulfilled in natural materials. However, considering imaginary parts of the permittivity (ε) and permeability (μ) and for metals at not too high frequencies the general condition for negative refraction becomes extremely simple: Re(μ)<0⇒Re(n)<0 and may be fulfilled for such natural ferromagnetic metals as nickel, iron, or cobalt. Here we demonstrate experimentally that in pure cobalt and Fe/Co alloy the negative values of the refractive index can indeed be achieved close to the frequency of the ferromagnetic resonance. Large values of the negative refraction can be obtained at room temperature and they can easily be tuned in moderate magnetic fields.

Related Stories

Practical Cloaking Devices On The Horizon?

August 10, 2008

( -- Invisibility cloaks get a step closer to realization, with the demonstration of a new material that can bend (visible) light the 'wrong' way for the first time in three dimensions.

Negative Index Materials: From Theory to Reality

June 6, 2006

Kent State University researchers are leading a team of scientists from eight institutions, who have been awarded a $5.5 million Multidisciplinary University Research Initiative (MURI) from the Air Force Office of Scientific ...

Physicists rotate beams of light

April 5, 2011

Controlling the rotation of light – this amazing feat was accomplished at the Vienna University of Technology (TU Vienna), by means of a ultra thin semiconductor. This can be used to create a transistor that works with ...

Stars Locations are Uncertain

August 5, 2004

Whether viewed dimly through the haze and lights of a city or in all their glory in a pristine wilderness, the stars that surround the Earth are magnificent, and one day Earthlings will travel to some of the new planets that ...

Recommended for you

Correlated nucleons may solve 35-year-old mystery

February 20, 2019

A careful re-analysis of data taken at the Department of Energy's Thomas Jefferson National Accelerator Facility has revealed a possible link between correlated protons and neutrons in the nucleus and a 35-year-old mystery. ...

CMS gets first result using largest-ever LHC data sample

February 15, 2019

Just under three months after the final proton–proton collisions from the Large Hadron Collider (LHC)'s second run (Run 2), the CMS collaboration has submitted its first paper based on the full LHC dataset collected in ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

1 / 5 (3) Aug 18, 2011
The negative refraction index is not any mystery. In most materials the so called normal dispersion occurs: they contain a more dense blobs of matter (molecules), which exhibit a positive refraction index. To construct material with negative refraction index, you'll need to use material, which appears like cheese and it contains cavities. Such materials aren't indeed easy to prepare, because atoms of matter doesn't behave like the bubbles. But the spaces between atoms can behave like such a cavities for the light of certain wavelength. Therefore for every coloured material the area of negative refraction index exist, unfortunately it's just connected with the location of absorption peak strongest absorption.

Even the rain behaves as a material with negative refraction index, because the secondary rainbow is deflected outside of the path of incoming light. In this situation the light is bouncing BETWEEN rain droplets, so that the secondary rainbow is observable during heavy rain only.
not rated yet Aug 18, 2011
I wonder if this means that light can now be focused onto a much smaller width. If so the next wave of optical etching for CPU imprinting may be solved as well.
not rated yet Aug 18, 2011
CQD's should be able to fulfill the extreme polarization constants required for meta-phase refraction or even compounding of photons for lasing. Great work on base metal alloys however!
not rated yet Aug 18, 2011
I wonder if this means that light can now be focused onto a much smaller width. If so the next wave of optical etching for CPU imprinting may be solved as well.

I believe this has already been accomplished.
not rated yet Aug 18, 2011
True negative refraction probably doesn't exist. The negative refraction claims to date all are accomplished using a material that guides the light wave in the opposite direction of true refraction. They are nothing more than waveguides for extremely short electromagnetic waves.
1 / 5 (1) Aug 20, 2011
5 / 5 (3) Aug 22, 2011
Zepyr/Rawa/Callippo, all the same person, made this botch:
n this situation the light is bouncing BETWEEN rain droplets
No. Its a secondary reflection within the drops.

so that the secondary rainbow is observable during heavy rain only.

Try doing some actual observation instead of using multiple sockpuppets, in this case within a single thread. I have seen double bows many times ALWAYS with light rain.

5 / 5 (1) Aug 23, 2011
I love it when trolls comment on these articles trying to match their criticisms (based entirely on speculation, of course) against tangible results that real scientists are achieving in a lab. I guess the trolls want to feel important too.
5 / 5 (1) Aug 23, 2011
What tangible results? The article didn't claim any.

Got a link?


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.