New research finds promiscuousness results in genetic 'trade-up,' more offspring

New research finds promiscuousness results in genetic 'trade-up,' more offspring
An adult female junco is pictured here defending a nest that contained three nestlings sired by an extra-pair male partner. Credit: Nicole Gerlach, Indiana University

It's all about the grandkids! That's what a team led by an Indiana University biologist has learned about promiscuous female birds and why they mate outside their social pair.

Many humans find the idea of for life a romantic ideal, but in the natural world, non-monogamous relationships may have their benefits. According to new research published online today (Aug. 31) in , IU postdoctoral research associate Nicole Gerlach and colleagues have uncovered one of the benefits of this promiscuity: more grandkids!

In dark-eyed juncos (Junco hyemalis), individuals that were sired by a male other than their mother's pair-bonded partner grew up to have higher than did individuals whose mother stayed faithful to her partner. This study on a population of wild represents the first time that an individual's paternity has been shown to affect its reproductive success as an adult.

"There are a lot of species that form monogamous social pairs but are decidedly promiscuous when it comes to mating and having offspring, and the question of what females gain from these extra-pair matings has puzzled scientists for a long time. What we've found is that, at least in juncos, these females are doing it for their kids, and for their kids' kids," Gerlach said of the work with IU Distinguished Professor of Biology Ellen Ketterson, former doctoral student of Ketterson's Joel McGlothlin, now at the University of Virginia, and Patricia Parker of the University of Missouri, St. Louis.

"In the long run, females are likely to have twice as many grandchildren if they mate with an extra-pair male than if they remain truly monogamous."

Sons of extra-pair fathers are also more likely to become extra-pair fathers themselves, suggesting that females may be straying from their social mates based on whether the new male will produce attractive or otherwise high-quality offspring. "However, it's not just sons that are reaping the benefits of having an extra-pair dad," Gerlach added. "The daughters benefit just as much."

Scientists have long believed that females mate with extra-pair males in order to produce offspring of higher quality, either by mating with the best possible males, or with males whose genes form good combinations with the female's own. Many previous studies have tested this hypothesis by comparing offspring produced with a female's pair-bonded partner to those sired by an extra-pair male. But the results of these studies have been equivocal, perhaps because they were focused on the first year of an offspring's life.

"What was needed to really answer the question of offspring quality were direct measures of their reproduction as adults," Gerlach noted. "But that's not something that you can get in a year or two's worth of research." In fact, their results were more than 18 years in the making; Gerlach and her colleagues conducted paternity tests on almost 2,200 nestlings that hatched between 1990 and 2007. "Because we could look at these patterns over many years and many generations, we were able to find strong support for the idea that extra-pair mating by females does produce better offspring… but that they need to grow up before that higher quality starts to show."

"This is the first case that we know of in which extra-pair has been shown to increase lifetime reproductive success of adult offspring in a free-living songbird," Gerlach said.

The results -- that extra-pair offspring themselves produce more offspring than within-pair -- suggest that females are using their extra-pair matings to "trade-up" to males that are superior to or more genetically compatible than their social mate.

Still to be determined are what characteristics females are using to pick their extra-pair mates. "We don't yet know whether some males are universally attractive, or if every female junco has her own ideal match," said Gerlach. Future research will determine whether the positive contributions from extra-pair males are a result of their universally favored alleles, or "good genes," or whether are selecting extra-pair males that are a good genetic match.

Explore further

Study fuels debate about why female birds seek extra mates

More information: "Promiscuous mating produces offspring with higher lifetime fitness," Proceedings of the Royal Society B, Aug. 31, 2011; rspb.royalsocietypublishing.or … .1098/rspb.2011.1547
Provided by Indiana University
Citation: New research finds promiscuousness results in genetic 'trade-up,' more offspring (2011, August 31) retrieved 22 July 2019 from
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

Feedback to editors

User comments

Aug 31, 2011
"Scientists have long believed that females mate with extra-pair males in order to produce offspring of higher quality, either by mating with the best possible males, or with males whose genes form good combinations with the female's own."

-Well of course. It is in a females best interests to select the best possible donor for each and every child she wishes to bear. In humans this is obviously detrimental to a tribe which depends on cohesiveness and mutual trust among its males.

A tribe whose males are constantly competing over females, which may be the preferred state as far as the females are concerned, will be easier to beat by a tribe whose males are focused on cooperation and teamwork.

And paradoxically, the females will have chosen who the better males are, as they will be absorbed into the victors tribe and begin to bear children with them. So a tribe which can suppress the female mandate to induce competition among males will tend to be victorious on the battlefield.

Aug 31, 2011
And if we look at the development of civilization up until very recently, we can see this dynamic at the very core of it.

The stable family unit is directly counter to this female prerogative. Women have been suppressed throughout history, their physical attributes and intelligence consistently hidden and unavailable to entice men.

Marriage was mandatory and extramarital relations was the gravest of sins. These mores were always enforced by RELIGION and in fact are the central tenet of every one of them.

Cultures with the strongest of these conditions could produce the largest, most cohesive, and most disciplined of military forces; as well as social harmony and economic productivity. They are the ones which usurped all others and swept the world.

The jews were the first people to record this system in writing; the torah. Later improvements to suit changing conditions and lessons learned include the new testiment and the quran.

Aug 31, 2011
And this is why religion is so dangerous to the world today. Civilization has encompassed the world. Religion is a doomsday machine which will continus to churn out excess people and compel them to fight despite the fact that there is no longer any reason to do so.

The world is conquered. The only resistance to a universal state of Order and Stability are those obsolete religions specifically created to establish it by giving people irresistible reasons to fight in very Orderly and Manageable ways. Constructive ways. Wildly beneficial Ways.

This is why women have had their Prerogative returned to them. Pandoras box has been opened, the world again belongs to the female. The New World Order. The Magdalene is laid to rest in the eternal city, underneath the louvre. A city named after a hero who was enticed by a woman to start a great war.

And next door, germany has a female chancellor.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more