Noise pollution appears to cause some birds to change their songs making them less attractive

August 31, 2011 by Bob Yirka report
Great Tit, Parus major. Image: Wikipedia

( -- Most everyone knows that modern pollution causes a lot of problems for the other animals trying to exist on this planet. Chemicals in the air and water make animals sick or kill them; urban sprawl allows them fewer places to live and now apparently it seems that even the noise we humans create causes animals to suffer in previously unknown ways. Wouter Halfwerk, a behavioral ecologist at Leiden University in the Netherlands and his colleagues have published a paper in the Proceedings of the National Academy of the Sciences that shows that some birds find themselves forced to change their mating songs as they compete with noise pollution which results, in some cases, in the male birds being cheated on by their supposed mates.

In a prior study, Halfwerk had found that certain that were forced to compete with often resorted to singing higher in order to be heard. Whether doing so was having a positive or negative impact on the birds as a whole wasn’t so clear however, so this time around he and his team decided to look closer by studying not just the change in songs, but in discovering who was actually mating with whom as a result.

To find out what was going on, Halfwerk and his team chose to study the , the same species studied in his earlier work; a bird that is capable of changing the frequency of its songs. They recorded the songs of 30 random male birds during the mating season in the Netherlands. In doing so, they found that the males sang at their very lowest just before the females began laying their eggs, indicating it was the low frequency songs that really made the difference for the females.

After the eggs hatched, the researchers conducted paternity tests on the newborn great tits to see which males had won out in the end, but also to see which males were actually also being duped into raising the young of another male. The results showed that those males that had been forced to sing higher than they would have liked, wound up losing out to those that stuck with the lower frequency songs, which means other males had swooped in at the last moment with their low songs enticing the females out of the nest for one last tango just in time to fertilize her eggs.

To further confirm their findings that team also took a more direct approach; they played both high and low pitched prerecorded male songs to females sitting in their nest boxes to see which would cause them to emerge and found that the low frequency songs were more effective. This all changed when they pumped low frequency background noise into the environment, however, making it difficult for the females to hear the songs; only then did they go for the males singing the higher frequency tunes.

This all shows, the team says, that can have a on bird populations, putting serious dents in the process of allowing the female birds to be fertilized by the best available mates, which could in the end, put the species at risk.

Explore further: Cities change the songs of birds

More information: Low-frequency songs lose their potency in noisy urban conditions, PNAS, Published online before print August 29, 2011, doi:10.1073/pnas.1109091108

Many animal species communicate with their mates through acoustic signals, but this communication seems to become a struggle in urbanized areas because of increasing anthropogenic noise levels. Several bird species have been reported to increase song frequency by which they reduce the masking impact of spectrally overlapping noise. However, it remains unclear whether such behavioral flexibility provides a sufficient solution to noisy urban conditions or whether there are hidden costs. Species may rely on low frequencies to attract and impress females, and the use of high frequencies may, therefore, come at the cost of reduced attractiveness. We studied the potential tradeoff between signal strength and signal detection in a successful urban bird species, the great tit (Parus major). We show that the use of low-frequency songs by males is related to female fertility as well as sexual fidelity. We experimentally show that urban noise conditions impair male–female communication and that signal efficiency depends on song frequency in the presence of noise. Our data reveal a response advantage for high-frequency songs during sexual signaling in noisy conditions, whereas low-frequency songs are likely to be preferred. These data are critical for our understanding of the impact of anthropogenic noise on wild-ranging birds, because they provide evidence for low-frequency songs being linked to reproductive success and to be affected by noise-dependent signal efficiency.

Related Stories

Cities change the songs of birds

December 4, 2006

By studying the songs of a bird species that has succeeded in adapting to urban life, researchers have gained insight into the kinds of environmental pressures that influence where particular songbirds thrive, and the specific ...

Blue whales singing with deeper voices

December 8, 2009

( -- Blue whales, the largest animals on earth, are singing with deeper voices every year, but scientists are unsure of the reason.

Female birds boost up their eggs when hearing sexy song

June 8, 2006

In a new study published in the latest issue of Ethology researchers show that female songbirds can alter the size of eggs and possibly the sex of their chicks according to how they perceive their mate’s quality.

'Virtual mates' reveal role of romance in parrot calls

August 3, 2010

Parrots are famed for their ability to mimic sounds and now researchers have used 'virtual mates' to discover if female parrots judge male contact calls when deciding on a mate. The research, published in Ethology, challenges ...

Female Birds Boost Up Their Eggs When Hearing Sexy Song

July 17, 2006

In a new study published in the latest issue of Ethology researchers show that female songbirds can alter the size of eggs and possibly the sex of their chicks according to how they perceive their mate's quality. The researchers ...

Night lights affect songbirds' mating life

September 16, 2010

In today's increasingly urbanized world, the lights in many places are always on, and according to a report published online on September 16 in of Current Biology, a Cell Press publication, that's having a real impact on ...

Recommended for you

Tasmanian tiger doomed long before humans came along

December 12, 2017

The Tasmanian tiger was doomed long before humans began hunting the enigmatic marsupial, scientists said Tuesday, with DNA sequencing showing it was in poor genetic health for thousands of years before its extinction.

Searching for the CRISPR Swiss-army knife

December 12, 2017

Scientists at the University of Copenhagen, led by the Spanish Professor Guillermo Montoya, are investigating the molecular features of different molecular scissors of the CRISPR-Cas system to shed light on the so-called ...

1 comment

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Aug 31, 2011
Hence why corvids seem to shout above the din.

I have also noticed most birds seem to automatically tune out background noise which masks predatory animals. Birds are also very sensitive to vibrations, believe it or not, in an urban area where noise pollution is at a high, they cannot use this natural sensory mechanism well, if at all.

This study highlights another commonality between humans and non-humans, imo. In a quiet neighborhood you are much more likely to not get run over by a car as you hear them coming from a distance, in a city, not so much.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.