Simplifying the process of detecting genuine multiparticle entanglement

May 20, 2011 by Miranda Marquit feature
The structure of multiparticle entanglement for three particles. The team approximates the set of unentangled states (shown in blue) by a larger set (shown with a thick, red border), which has the advantage that the latter is much easier to handle theoretically. This idea leads to an efficient, easily implementable criterion for multiparticle entanglement. The figure was drawn by Bastian Jungnitsch.

( -- The ability to entangle particles is considered essential for a number of experiments and applications. While we have seen evidence for quantum entanglement, it is still difficult to detect unambiguously. Multiparticle quantum correlations are especially important for work with optical lattices, superconducting qubits and quantum information processing. "Entanglement in large qubit systems is becoming more important," Bastian Jungnitsch tells "Unfortunately, the characterization of multiparticle entanglement is difficult."

Jungnitsch, a Ph.D. student at the Institute for and at the Austrian Academy of Sciences in Innsbruck, Austria, has been working on a way to simplify the way that multiparticle is characterized. Along with Tobias Moroder and Otfried Gühne from the University of Siegen in Germany, Jungnitsch created criteria that can be easily implemented in experiments. Their work is published in Physical Review Letters: “Taming Multiparticle Entanglement.”

To thank our 25,000 fans in the Facebook community, this story was posted on the FB page a few hours before going live on the main site
“We developed a criterion that can easily be implemented so that others can use it,” Jungnitsch says. “Experimentalists can download it from the Internet and use it to measure entanglement. It provides results that others can understand, helping to let them know that these are really entangled.”

The team from Austria and Germany used what they call “suitable relaxations” to develop their criteria. The method involves first considering a quantum state involving three particles. If the state can be separated out using different partitions, it is called biseparable. When in a biseparable state, the system is not considered to be entangled. If, however, the quantum state is not biseparable, it can be thought of as genuinely multiparticle-entangled, meaning that all particles are entangled and not only some of them.

“There are many states that are entangled in some sense,” Jungnitsch points out, “but it’s not easy to see if they are genuinely entangled. We relaxed the definition a bit, and it still works pretty well. Our method won’t work for all , but you can still catch the phenomena of entanglement pretty well.”

“The point is to make sure that your particles are in a genuinely entangled state,” Jungnitsch continues. “In many cases, you want to know if all of the items prepared are entangled.” Otherwise, for some operations, you might not get the desired results. “When particles are genuinely entangled, they can be useful for a number of operations. Our criteria can help experimentalists verify that the state really is entangled. It’s something useful and practical.”

Jungnitsch says that they have already provided the code for download. “It can be used in experiments now,” he says. “We wrote the code and put it on the Internet. Experimentalists can download and then run the code on their own computers as part of their efforts to see whether or not their multiparticle systems are entangled.”

Some refining is still possible, however. “We have been working on applying the code to specific states – important states.” Because there are some applications that require certain quantum states, being able to detect whether or not particles have reached those states is important. With some adjustments to the code, it should be possible to characterize such entangled states even more accurately.

“Of course, the long view is always quantum computers,” Jungnitsch acknowledges. “But there are other applications for as well. The first step to many of these applications, and to improving , is to verify entangled states. Our efforts can help with that.”

Explore further: Entanglement can help in classical communication

More information: Bastian Jungnitsch, Tobias Moroder, Otfried Gühne, “Taming Multiparticle Entanglement,” Physical Review Letters (2011). Available online:


Related Stories

Entanglement can help in classical communication

March 30, 2011

( -- When most of us think of entanglement, our minds jump immediately to quantum communication. "Entanglement has become very well known and useful in quantum communication," Robert Prevedel tells ...

Physicists describe method to observe timelike entanglement

January 24, 2011

( -- In "ordinary" quantum entanglement, two particles possess properties that are inherently linked with each other, even though the particles may be spatially separated by a large distance. Now, physicists S. ...

A solid case of entanglement

January 11, 2010

Physicists have finally managed to demonstrate quantum entanglement of spatially separated electrons in solid state circuitry.

Recommended for you

Probe for nanofibers has atom-scale sensitivity

January 20, 2017

Optical fibers are the backbone of modern communications, shuttling information from A to B through thin glass filaments as pulses of light. They are used extensively in telecommunications, allowing information to travel ...

Magnetic recording with light and no heat on garnet

January 19, 2017

A strong, short light pulse can record data on a magnetic layer of yttrium iron garnet doped with Co-ions. This was discovered by researchers from Radboud University in the Netherlands and Bialystok University in Poland. ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Jun 03, 2011
Our efforts can help with that

Even more helpful is when the entire science community starts using the correct translation for Erwin's "Verschränkung.": 'Shared enclosure', NOT "entanglement". The state of many minds using the false translation.
not rated yet Jun 09, 2011
"The Theory of Rips" predicts that Quantum Entanglement is facilitated by Gravity Tubes. Rip Theory predicts that Gravity Tubes run between all particles, and it is these Gravity Tubes that facilitate entanglement and gravitational attraction. Rip Theory also predicts that the Graviton of the Standard Model does not exist in nature. Rip Theory proposes that Gravitons are a mere mathematical representation of the smallest cross-sectional area of the Gravity Tube between the masses being monitored. Rip Theory predicts that the total mass of the multiple Gravitons used in calculating Gravitational Force actually represent the cross-sectional area of the True Space that constructs the Gravity Tube. Since Gravity Tubes represent True Space, the communication/energy/information relayed through Gravity Tubes is somewhat instantaneous

© Copyright 2011 Thomas A. Sullivan

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.