Panel told no guarantee against unethical research

March 1, 2011 By MIKE STOBBE , AP Medical Writer

(AP) -- The nation has a "leaky system" for protecting patients in medical research, and it's possible - though unlikely - that the kind of unethical studies done in the past could occur again, bioethics experts told a presidential panel Tuesday in Washington.

The meeting was triggered by the government's apology last fall for federal doctors infecting prisoners and mental patients in Guatemala with 65 years ago.

The Presidential Commission for the Study of Bioethical Issues was told to explore the question of whether such a study could ever happen again. On Tuesday, the commission held its first public meeting on the topic and heard testimony from bioethicists, researchers and a historian.

Speakers noted that over the last several decades, as many as 1,000 ethical rules, regulations and guidelines have been enacted globally to ensure the ethical conduct of medical research. In the United States, there are rules to protect people in every study done by federal scientists, funded by federal agencies or those testing a product requiring federal approval to be sold.

But that oversight is inconsistent - ethical rules can vary among federal agencies. What's more, if federal funding or review is not involved, an unethical study could be done and no one in authority would ever know about it.

"We have a leaky system," said Eric Meslin, director of the Indiana University Center for Bioethics.

Dr. Robert Califf, Duke University's vice chancellor for clinical research, agreed there are weaknesses.

"It's night and day and what you could do in the `good old days' with no one knowing about it. But there's no 100 percent guarantee. There still will be bad things that will happen," he said.

The commission, ordered to report to President by September, was given two tasks:

-Examine federally funded international studies to make sure research is being done ethically. The commission named a 14-member international panel of experts to study the question.

-Take a more intensive look at the Guatemala study. More than a dozen commission investigators have already started poring through hundreds of boxes of old government documents.

What they will turn up is unknown, but there are doubtless more unethical studies from the past that have never been publicly reported, said Susan Lederer, a medical historian at the University of Wisconsin.

On Sunday, The Associated Press reported on dozens of studies from the past - most of them between 40 and 80 years ago - involving researchers deliberately infecting people to study the effects of diseases or to see if an experimental treatment might work.

The AP investigation itself was triggered by the Guatemala study.

At Tuesday's commission meeting, Lederer was the most pessimistic of five guest speakers about whether that kind of research could happen again.

"I don't think you should look to historians for optimism," she said.

Explore further: Guatemala STD study was 'wrong': US panel

More information: The Commission Web site:


Related Stories

Guatemala STD study was 'wrong': US panel

March 1, 2011

The head of a bioethics commission convened by President Barack Obama said on Tuesday that a 1940s study of STDs using patients in Guatemala was wrong and that a US probe was continuing.

US apologizes for '40s syphilis study in Guatemala

October 1, 2010

(AP) -- American scientists deliberately infected prisoners and patients in a mental hospital in Guatemala with syphilis 60 years ago, a recently unearthed experiment that prompted U.S. officials to apologize Friday and ...

Past medical testing on humans revealed

February 27, 2011

(AP) -- Shocking as it may seem, U.S. government doctors once thought it was fine to experiment on disabled people and prison inmates. Such experiments included giving hepatitis to mental patients in Connecticut, squirting ...

Feds to look at Apple policy on programming tools

May 4, 2010

(AP) -- Federal regulators plan to examine whether Apple Inc. is violating antitrust rules by requiring software developers to use Apple programming tools to create applications for the iPhone and iPad.

House member urges approval of Comcast, NBC deal

August 2, 2010

(AP) -- The head of the House subcommittee that deals with communications issues is calling on federal regulators to approve Comcast's plan to buy a controlling interest in NBC Universal with a handful of conditions attached ...

Recommended for you

Egypt archaeologists discover mummy in Luxor

December 9, 2017

Egyptian archaeologists have discovered a mummy in one of two previously unexplored tombs across the Nile from the southern city of Luxor, the antiquities ministry said Saturday.

1 comment

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Mar 02, 2011
-You- have human rights violations done everyday as part of the treatment plan for mental health clients? This offical policy of the mental health industry is allowed because these supposed mental health professionals have lost any humanity for the mentally ill or mentally challenged etc.? When you loose -Full Time- personal touch with the clients and your bureaucratic approach to mental illness with all your advanced degrees? -You- have created a form of inbreeding that allows you to experiment on mental health clients and you don't realize or care about the suffering you cause? For many years I worked as a non professional in a mental health rehabilitation facility (FH) in northern new jersey and also interacted with another dozen mental heath facilities in the northeast? We interacted full time with the clients and gained their -Trust- and started to realize the horror of the mental health industry? Think twice before you get involved with the mental health industry?

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.