New form of sulfur discovered in geological fluids

February 28, 2011, CNRS
Artist's impression of the S3- molecule in a diamond anvil cell. This form of sulfur may well be one of the key factors in the formation of veins of gold and copper (represented here by a photo of a mine in the background of the image). Credit: Pokrovski & Dubrovinsky

Sulfur is the sixth most abundant element on Earth and plays a key role in many geological and biological processes. A French-German team including CNRS and the Université Paul Sabatier has identified, on the basis of laboratory measurements, a novel form of sulfur present in geological fluids: the S3- ion. The discovery calls existing theories about the geological transport of sulfur into question, and could provide ways of identifying new deposits of precious metals such as gold and copper. These findings are published in the 25 February 2011 issue of the journal Science.

Until now, geochemists believed that inside the , only two forms of molecules contained sulfur: sulfides (based on H2S or S2-) and sulfates (based on H2SO4 or SO42-). Yet they had no way of directly plunging a probe into the hydrothermal fluids(2) that flow through rocks to verify this theory. To get round this problem and test their hypothesis, the French-German team first created fluids similar to those in the Earth's crust and mantle, i.e. aqueous solutions containing elementary sulfur (S) and thiosulfates (molecules containing the S2O32- ion). They then used a diamond anvil cell to bring the fluids to the temperatures and pressures found at depths of several kilometers (several hundred degrees and tens of thousands of atmospheres).

The researchers used an optical method known as Raman spectroscopy to identify the , and they were astounded to discover not two, but three forms of sulfur, the third being the trisulfur ion S3-. This was a double surprise: although S3- was already known to chemists (it is found in sulfur-containing silicate glass and ultramarine pigments for instance), it had never been observed in an aqueous solution.

The detection of S3- during these experiments means that sulfur must be considerably more mobile in hydrothermal fluids in the Earth's crust than was previously thought. This is because, unlike sulfides and sulfates, which attach to minerals as soon as they appear in fluids, S3- proves to be extremely stable in the aqueous phase. In other words, below ground these ions must flow for long distances in dissolved form, taking with them the noble metals to which they may be bound. This chemical species may therefore be the main metal transporting agent in two major types of gold and copper deposits: Archaean greenstone belts and subduction zone magmas.

This discovery could provide additional indicators in the search for new deposits, by helping geologists to identify the pathways along which metals travel prior to forming veins. In addition, the presence of S3- in hydrothermal fluids could affect isotope fractionation models (a sort of equivalent to the carbon-14 dating technique), which until now have taken no account of this chemical species. These new findings could for instance help scientists to find out more about the geological conditions in the Earth's crust and on its surface shortly after the appearance of life.

Explore further: Rich Ore Deposits Linked to Ancient Atmosphere

More information: The S3- Ion Is Stable in Geological Fluids at Elevated Temperatures and Pressures. Gleb S. Pokrovski and Leonid S. Dubrovinsky. Science. 25 February 2011.

Related Stories

Rich Ore Deposits Linked to Ancient Atmosphere

November 19, 2009

( -- Much of our planet's mineral wealth was deposited billions of years ago when Earth's chemical cycles were different from today's. Using geochemical clues from rocks nearly 3 billion years old, a group of ...

Origins of sulfur in rocks tells early oxygen story

April 16, 2009

( -- Sedimentary rocks created more than 2.4 billion years ago sometimes have an unusual sulfur isotope composition thought to be caused by the action of ultra violet light on volcanically produced sulfur dioxide ...

New way to measure sulfate particles

October 7, 2005

The University of Maryland and the National Institute of Standards and Technology created an improved technique to measure sulfur isotopic ratios.

Canada experts to study alien-like spring

June 14, 2006

Canadian scientists will soon visit Ellesmere Island in Canada's High Arctic, where unusual sulfur springs may point to how life evolves on other planets.

Hot Fluids and Deep Earthquakes

May 8, 2007

Fluids in the Earth's lower crust are an underlying force in shaking things up where continental plates slip under each other, according to a study recently published in Nature. Donna Eberhart-Phillips, a UC Davis researcher ...

Recommended for you

Sierra snowpack could drop significantly by end of century

December 11, 2018

A future warmer world will almost certainly feature a decline in fresh water from the Sierra Nevada mountain snowpack. Now a new study by the Department of Energy's Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory (Berkeley Lab) that ...

A glimpse into future oceans

December 11, 2018

Something peculiar is happening in the azure waters off the rocky cliffs of Ischia, Italy. There, streams of gas-filled volcanic bubbles rising up to the surface are radically changing life around them by making seawater ...

1 comment

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Mar 01, 2011
This is the most exciting chemistry story this month.

Does O3- exist as a stable ion as well?

There would be many interesting metal or organic S3- interactions to investigate

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.