The humanities in America -- an endangered species?

February 4, 2011 By Cynthia Haven, Stanford University
From left, Geoffrey Galt Harpham, president and director of the National Humanities Center; Debra Satz, senior associate dean for the humanities; Russell Berman, humanities professor; and Caroline Winterer, history professor.

( -- In a world that is becoming more fast-paced and technological, the humanities are under fire to defend their time-honored centrality in Western culture and education. In the world of iPhone apps and the Tweet, is there a role for the slow-cooked thoughts of the humanities?

Is there still room for literature, history, and art?

Geoffrey Harpham, president and director of the National Humanities Center and author of The Humanities and the Dream of America, argued in a recent appearance at Stanford that American notions of humanities are uniquely linked with nationhood – in fact, he went so far as to argue that the humanities were "made in America," circa 1945.

In other nations, humanities were "never conceived as a democratic program. The genius of this country is a program of for all its citizens. It's not an expansion of scale, it's a completely different understanding."

Harpham pointed to the rhetoric in influential postwar reports and policy recommendations. One 1964 report even claimed that "the humanities are not merely our, but the world's, best hope," and concluded that "world leadership of the kind which has come upon the United States cannot rest solely upon superior force, vast wealth or preponderant technology. Only the elevation of its goals and the excellence of its conduct entitle one nation to ask another to follow its lead. These are things of the spirit."

What Harpham described as "the shotgun marriage of national defense and things of the spirit" was destined for a comedown in a more cynical era.

The rationale for the humanities "slipped into incoherence in the mid-1960s," he said. American notions of patriotism, duty, sacrifice and a common destiny gave way to "the American daydream of personal gratification" and the "meretricious fantasy of consumption."

Humanities may be in even more trouble in Britain, "land of Shakespeare and Austen and Masterpiece Theatre," as Harpham put it. England is facing severe cutbacks in humanities, with recommendations for 100 percent cuts in state funding.

He said such extreme measures "are still inconceivable here, despite inroads."

If the humanities relinquish their claims to wisdom, they might "also sacrifice the questing or exploratory aspect that makes us care about them," he said.

Russell Berman, a professor in the humanities and director of the Introduction to the Humanities program for Stanford's incoming freshmen, decried the "research narcissisms" and "follow your passion" ethos that have driven the humanities away from their central charge. "Our dignity is in the classroom, pursuing that mission of edification," he said.

Philosopher Debra Satz, Stanford's senior associate dean for the humanities, praised the humanities' role not only in "cultivating critical imagination, sympathetic understanding," but in drawing together people from diverse backgrounds working toward common concerns.

Professor Caroline Winterer challenged Harpham's World War II genesis for the creation of the humanities in the United States. She agreed that the humanities were born in a moment of crisis, "but it was essentially the crisis of the Industrial Revolution."

On one point, the two seemed to concur: The humanities flourish in crisis.

"Lucky for us, there seems to be no end of crises in sight," Harpham said.

Explore further: Japanese stem cell researcher wins Balzan prize

Related Stories

Japanese stem cell researcher wins Balzan prize

September 6, 2010

(AP) -- The Balzan Foundation says its prize for the biology of stem cells has gone to a Japanese researcher for discovering a way to transform adult cells into cells with the characteristics of stem cells.

Is the Internet lying to us?

November 25, 2010

( -- University of Alberta scholars talk about the relativity of truth on the World Wide Web.

Google Books may advance humanities research, scholars say

August 5, 2010

When scholars seek to understand long-ago cultures, they tend to draw conclusions from the handful of famous writers and thinkers whose works endure today. John Stuart Mill and Thomas Carlyle peppered their books with words ...

'Digging into Data Challenge' grant awarded

December 4, 2009

A professor at Tufts University will lead a team of international researchers to explore how humanities scholars can use data analysis to track topics about the Greco-Roman world as they appear in a million documents, spanning ...

Linguist uses Internet to study how we say things

January 4, 2010

( -- Mats Rooth, a Cornell linguist, will use software to study distinctions of prosody (rhythm, stress and intonation) in language by hunting for word patterns on the Internet.

Unstated assumptions color Arctic sovereignty claims

May 28, 2009

Settling the growing debate over ownership of Arctic Ocean resources is complicated by the fact that the various countries involved have different understandings of the geography of the place.

Recommended for you

Lifting barriers to citizenship for low-income immigrants

January 15, 2018

Taking the Oath of Allegiance at a naturalization ceremony is an emotional moment for many immigrants, and for good reason: it is the culmination of an often arduous process and many years of striving. Citizenship also opens ...

1 comment

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Feb 04, 2011
It is a false dichotomy to say that the humanities stand in stark contrast to the technologies. Who do you think is going to set the tone for holographic Sharon Apple e-idols? Who will hammer out the legal changes that arise when philosophies of the soul and agency clash with the very first android?

Obviously the technologists will have a keen interest in tackling these problems. It's up to the humanities to decide if they want to participate.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.