Seeing the forest through the trees

February 21, 2011 By Shelley Littin, University of Arizona

Leonardo Da Vinci was the first to accurately describe trees' branching rules. He created sketches of trees in a page of his notebook based on the rule that daughter branches and twigs have the same combined cross-sectional area as the branch from which they originated. Credit: Brian Enquist
( -- University of Arizona researcher Brian Enquist and his colleagues have discovered the secret of patterns within individual trees that can be used to describe the structure and functioning of the world's forests.

Imagine you are walking through a . All around you are of different species, age, size and height. It looks pretty random, right? Wrong.

In research funded by the National Science Foundation, Brian Enquist of the department of ecology and at the University of Arizona and his team have discovered a secret in the trees: Hidden among and within the architecture of the branches are fundamental rules that link the size, shape, age and in fact everything about a single tree to all the trees in a forest.

"Everyone knows more or less what a tree looks like, or what a looks like," said Enquist. "And it turns out that those architectures, even though they look very diverse and different, are being generated by very simple and common rules across all plants. These rules basically govern how plants branch, when they branch and the sizes and shapes of those branches, and the structure and functioning of forests across the globe."

Understanding these rules has allowed Enquist and his team to make accurate predictions about how plants and even whole forests work, in particular how they flux . "If you know something about the branching network, you can make predictions about the whole plant's functioning. Then you can extend that to understand the ecology of the entire forest."

Plant vascular networks could help predict how whole forests will respond to a changing world, said Enquist. Credit: Brian Enquist

The rules appear both in the external branching architecture, or how the branches are arranged, and in the internal structure of the tissues that transport nutrients throughout the tree.

"The rule is basically ‘grow so much and then branch, and then grow so much and then branch,'" said Enquist. "The rule governs what the dimensions of the branches have to be. That is, ‘grow until your branch is such and so much length, or so much in width.' Repeating this rule as a plant grows results in a tremendously complicated but beautiful form such as a tree, but it ultimately can stem down to a very efficient code."

This rule or code reoccurs as the tree grows, creating a fractal – a repeating pattern – like a spiral of daughter branches emanating from the mother branch or tree trunk.

These rules hold true across species, so the ratios of lengths and radii of a mother branch to daughter branches are the same for almost all trees. But palm trees don't count: "That's basically one big branch with a bunch of leaves at the end," said Enquist.

But imagine you're standing in a forest again: the trees around you probably all look pretty different. "There're different flavors of the rule, and that's why you have different types of trees," said Enquist.

If you take a pine tree and a maple tree and look at the dimensions of radii and lengths between the nodes, or places where a new branch grows off an old one, "you'll have a very difficult time separating out the differences between species even though the form itself looks very different," said Enquist. The difference in species is part of what creates the apparent diversity of tree forms that you see in a forest.

"There are additional branching rules that can also kick in," said Enquist. "You can still follow these basic branching rules of radii and lengths, but if you change the angles at which you branch that gives you a tremendously different looking tree."

"And you know who actually the first person was to point this out? Leonardo Da Vinci. He discovered that if you have these constant branching ratios you're able to draw a realistic tree," said Enquist. "Some of these rules are known as Leonardo's rules, but few have really explored the functional implication of Leonardo's rules in plants."

Until now.

In a series of recent studies all published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, Enquist and his team determined that the same rules that govern when a tree branches and the dimensions of that branch also govern the structure of internal vascular tissues, called xylem and phloem, that transport nutrients throughout the plant. The studies have showed how these branching rules then go on to underlie the structure and function of the world's forests.

So why do these rules exist in the first place?

Enquist and his collaborators predicted that natural selection would select for shapes of trees that, as it grew from seedling to adult plant, solved two important problems: taking in as much resources such as light, water and nutrients as possible but yet transporting resources within the plant with as little work as possible. "There are these two conflicting pressures, and we call these a tradeoff in biology," said Enquist.

It's like when you're hungry and tired, and you want food but don't want to walk far to get it, so you pick the shortest route to the nearest fast-food joint – OK, so maybe you just use the drive-thru. But plants face the same type of scenario without the drive-thru option: how to get food, or resources, with as little work as possible.

For plants, work is transporting nutrients and water through internal tissues called xylem and phloem, and the less energy they have to expend to transport nutrients, the more they have for growth and reproduction.

Ultimately, natural selection has fine-tuned the rules that govern plants' internal and external frameworks to a simple repeating pattern coded for by their DNA.

The internal vascular network governs how water and nutrients are transported within a tree, which influences how much carbon the plant can take in. The external branching network governs a plant's shape, which determines the number of leaves on a tree, which then also influences how much carbon is fluxed within the tree.

"This work is all about the organization and design of biological networks," said Enquist. "They're all around us – we have cardio-vascular systems, we have neural systems, we have plant vascular networks. Biology is basically built around the geometry of vascular networks."

"Vascular networks flux resources, and resources are basically what maintain us," said Enquist. "The speed at which you're able to flux resources will then influence the speed of your physiology: How fast you grow, how long it will take you to reach reproductive maturity, how long ultimately organisms live."

And in the case of trees: "How much carbon dioxide you are able to absorb from the atmosphere."

"Vascular networks are important because ultimately an organism is going to be obtaining resources from the environment and converting that within the body to do work: Make babies or defend territories, all the lovely things that organisms do. That's all fueled ultimately through vascular networks, as vascular networks take resources from one area and shunt them to where they're needed. If you understand the organization of vascular networks you can actually predict an enormous amount about the functioning of organisms."

Because nearly all plants grow by the same network rules, Enquist and his team can scale up to make accurate predictions about the functioning of an entire forest.

In a forest, where resources such as sunlight and water are limited, trees compete with each other to get as much of what they need to live and grow as possible. The result is a fractal-like filling of the forest space, with a few large trees taking up most of the resources and many small trees filling in the cracks. The ratio of big trees to little trees in a forest turns out to be the same as the ratio of big branches to little branches on a single tree from that forest. So Enquist and his team can determine anything they want to about the entire forest by analyzing just one tree.

"If we know something about these rules that govern branching networks, we can start saying something about what may happen in the future," said Enquist. "These branching patterns are so prevalent that they will govern and influence how plants respond in a changing world."

Explore further: Probing Question: Can logging be done sustainably?

Related Stories

Probing Question: Can logging be done sustainably?

April 3, 2008

In an era of ever-increasing environmental awareness, few industries receive more scrutiny than logging. For decades, environmental groups have claimed that commercial logging practices result in devastating consequences, ...

Some trees 'farm' bacteria to help supply nutrients

July 29, 2010

Some trees growing in nutrient-poor forest soil may get what they need by cultivating specific root microbes to create compounds they require. These microbes are exceptionally efficient at turning inorganic minerals into ...

Faster koa tree growth without adverse ecosystem effects

March 27, 2008

U.S. Forest Service scientists with the Institute of Pacific Islands Forestry have completed a study on ways to make high-value koa trees grow faster, while increasing biodiversity, carbon sequestration, scenic beauty and ...

Ants are friendly to some trees, but not others

November 6, 2009

Tree-dwelling ants generally live in harmony with their arboreal hosts. But new research suggests that when they run out of space in their trees of choice, the ants can get destructive to neighboring trees.

Can you rescue a rainforest? The answer may be yes

March 27, 2008

Half a century after most of Costa Rica's rainforests were cut down, researchers from the Boyce Thompson Institute took on a project that many thought was impossible - restoring a tropical rainforest ecosystem.

Biologists study rainforest host-plant associations

August 19, 2010

The widening of the Panama Canal currently underway has created a rare opportunity to study the insects that inhabit the plants of environmentally sensitive Central American rain forest habitats. Dr. Amy Berkov, Professor ...

Recommended for you

Archaeologists discover Incan tomb in Peru

February 16, 2019

Peruvian archaeologists discovered an Incan tomb in the north of the country where an elite member of the pre-Columbian empire was buried, one of the investigators announced Friday.

Where is the universe hiding its missing mass?

February 15, 2019

Astronomers have spent decades looking for something that sounds like it would be hard to miss: about a third of the "normal" matter in the Universe. New results from NASA's Chandra X-ray Observatory may have helped them ...

What rising seas mean for local economies

February 15, 2019

Impacts from climate change are not always easy to see. But for many local businesses in coastal communities across the United States, the evidence is right outside their doors—or in their parking lots.

The friendly extortioner takes it all

February 15, 2019

Cooperating with other people makes many things easier. However, competition is also a characteristic aspect of our society. In their struggle for contracts and positions, people have to be more successful than their competitors ...

1 comment

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Feb 21, 2011
Ummmm, am I missing something here? Brian Enquist doesn't know about the 40 years worth of work by Benoit Mandelbrot in this field?

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.