Lunar water may have come from comets - scientists

January 9, 2011
The image of the moon is courtesy of NASA.

Water on the Moon came in large part from comets which bombarded the lunar surface in its infancy, a study published on Sunday suggests.

For decades, the was thought to have been as dry as it was void of life and atmosphere.

This assumption, though, has been revisited after findings by last year of significant traces of frozen water in a permanently shadowed crater.

Astrophysicists led by James Greenwood of Wesleyan University in Connecticut analysed rock samples collected during the Apollo expeditions, looking in particular at variations in hydrogen isotopes in a water-loving mineral called apatite.

The signature, they say, points to three potential sources: from the sub-surface lunar mantle, from protons brought by the "solar wind" of particles blasted from the Sun -- and from comets.

The isotope measurements in the apatite were similar to those previously found in three well-known comets: Hale-Bopp, Hyakutake and Halley.

Comets have been described as frozen reservoirs of water orbiting the Sun, for they contain vast quantities of ice in their heads.

Under a "giant impact" theory dating back to the 1970s, the Moon was formed from part of Earth, after our planet collided with a or planet some 4.5 billion years ago.

"Significant delivery" of cometary water occurred after the Moon-forming event, suggests Greenwood's team.

Comets also provided Earth with some of its lavish endowment of water as well as key chemicals to kickstart life, according to some hypotheses.

The paper is published online by the journal Nature Geoscience.

Explore further: Researchers discover water on the moon is widespread, similar to Earth's

More information: … t/full/ngeo1050.html

Related Stories

3 questions: Ben Weiss discusses what a wet moon might mean

September 30, 2009

Last week, NASA and other agencies announced results from instruments aboard three different spacecraft which all indicate that there is water present in the surface soil, or regolith, of the moon. Although the amount is ...

Mimicking the moon's surface in the basement

August 6, 2010

( -- A team of scientists used an ion beam in a basement room at Los Alamos National Laboratory to simulate solar winds on the surface of the Moon. The table-top simulation helped confirm that the Moon is inherently ...

We owe it all to comets

April 28, 2009

Comets have always fascinated us. A mysterious appearance could symbolize God's displeasure or mean a sure failure in battle, at least for one side. Now Tel Aviv University justifies our fascination -- comets might have provided ...

Recommended for you

NASA telescope studies quirky comet 45P

November 22, 2017

When comet 45P zipped past Earth early in 2017, researchers observing from NASA's Infrared Telescope Facility, or IRTF, in Hawai'i gave the long-time trekker a thorough astronomical checkup. The results help fill in crucial ...

Uncovering the origins of galaxies' halos

November 21, 2017

Using the Subaru Telescope atop Maunakea, researchers have identified 11 dwarf galaxies and two star-containing halos in the outer region of a large spiral galaxy 25 million light-years away from Earth. The findings, published ...

Cassini image mosaic: A farewell to Saturn

November 21, 2017

In a fitting farewell to the planet that had been its home for over 13 years, the Cassini spacecraft took one last, lingering look at Saturn and its splendid rings during the final leg of its journey and snapped a series ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

1 / 5 (6) Jan 10, 2011
Questions, questions, questions:
1. So comets existed 4.5 billion years ago[infancy of moon]. Why are they still around because as far as I know no comet lasts for more than a few hundred years at best.
There is no Oort cloud that we can detect with current technology and even if the reports of vapoury objects out there in the outer reaches of space is true, there is far too few to give the right number and size of comets required to show up here.

2. How long would water last on the moon? 4.5 billion years? With such a low gravity? Maybe there's a way to keep the water trapped that I've not considered. Or maybe it's only on a side that never gets any sun?

3. Just how do we know that comets provided earth with some of it's water? Is there any substantiating evidence for this? Or is this simply a guess-o-fact?
4. Just how many miracles does it take? First the giant impact [for which no evidence exists] then the comet[s] smashing into the moon?
1 / 5 (6) Jan 10, 2011
OK, the real reason that the water has to have come from comets is that with the giant impact theory, any and all water pesent at any point in time should have been vapourised by the impact heat. This was a satisfactory state of affairs whilst the moon was supposedly dead and dry. Now suddenly there's water on the moon so an adhoc explanation has to be found to keep the giant impact theory intact.

Have fun guys.
5 / 5 (4) Jan 10, 2011
as far as I know no comet lasts for more than a few hundred years at best.

Halley's comet (and all others) would beg to differ.

2. There is no side of the moon that never gets any sun (only a side of the moon that always faces earth and one that doesn't). Although there may be parts that are shelterd from direct sunlight. with no atmosphere to disperse the heat any part that is continually in shadow (e.g. an overhang or a cave) is permanently below freezing point for water. Sublimation can still lead to loss of water.

3. Prevalence of isotopes in comets/asteroids and earthbound water (though that ratio points more to asteroids than to comets)

4. None. Miracles don't occur beause we live in a real universe. If you look the composition of the moon and the earth they are rather similar - leading to a theory about a common origin (e.g. by giant impact). It would be highly unlikely that two so similar objects just happened to be caught in a newtonian lock by chance.
3.3 / 5 (7) Jan 10, 2011
Why are they still around because as far as I know no comet lasts for more than a few hundred years

I think we all know that as far as your knowledge goes that it barely registers on the nano-scale.
5 / 5 (3) Jan 10, 2011
Regions of the moon in permanent shadow have temperatures around 40 Kelvin so there is almost no energy to kick a water molecule free. It takes a miracle for enough energy to be concentrated in one molecule it to break free (humor) - roughly a 20 sigma event, so most remain for billions of years.

It is very likely that the impactor that created the moon came from L4 or L5 - these are stable enough to have accumulated a lot of mass when planets were forming, and the best models of the moon formation involve a low-speed collision implying something in a similar orbit to earth's orbit.

The are many comet-like bodies in the Kupier belt, with Pluto being one of the biggest known. These orbits are stable over long periods (billions of years) until passing stars nudge them into resonance with inner planets, destabilize orbits and letting them trickle in.

You could find these things out for yourself, Kevin, by keeping an open mind while reading.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.