Building cement 'prison' for old radioactive waste

January 11, 2011 By Sandra Chung, Idaho National Laboratory
Bacteria and hard water can give heavy metals a hard time. Scientists coax underground microbes to turn calcium-rich water and urea into a stony underground trap for contaminants.

The Cold War ended long ago, but its radioactive legacy still lingers in the water and soil of the western United States. Between 1950 and 1990, nuclear weapons materials production and processing at several federal facilities generated billions of gallons of water contaminated with radioactive byproducts.

These sites have since updated their waste treatment practices to keep new contamination from entering the water supply. But some old contamination is still present.

Though public drinking water near Department of Energy sites in Washington and Idaho doesn't contain strontium-90 at concentrations above the EPA's safe drinking water limit, some monitoring wells at the sites do. At least some contamination in the monitoring wells is strontium-90 that slowly leached out of the soil.

"It's not something you want to leave to wash out," says James Henriksen, an INL microbiologist.

Researchers at Idaho National Laboratory, the Center for Advanced Energy Studies, and other national labs and universities are working together to test an inexpensive method to sequester strontium-90 where it lies. The researchers can coax underground microbes to form calcite, a white mineral form of and the main ingredient in cement. And calcite should be able to trap strontium-90 until long after it has decayed into harmless zirconium. Strontium-90 has a nearly 30-year half-life, which means that a sample of the stuff will take around 300 years to decay more or less completely.

"Three hundred years is nothing for calcite," Henriksen says.

When people consume strontium-90 in or drinking water, the can replace some of the calcium in living bone. The bone-bound strontium-90 acts as a long-term source of damaging radiation that can spawn deadly cancers of blood, bone and skin.

A magnified view of microbially generated calcite crystals reveals pill-shaped impressions left by the microbes.

Cleaning strontium-90 out of the ground and water hasn't been easy. "There have been heroic efforts that cost enormous amounts of money," Henriksen says. Some of the most contaminated dirt was excavated, but digging up all the contamination would be astronomically expensive. And a project to pump out and treat contaminated groundwater only removed a tenth as much strontium-90 as did natural decay during the same period.

Pumping the groundwater wasn't effective because most of the contamination was stuck on solid surfaces underground, says INL environmental researcher Yoshiko Fujita. Remove the strontium-90 from the water, and more leaches off the solids to replace it.

So instead of trying to strip strontium-90 out of the ground, Fujita, Henriksen and their colleagues are trying to coax microbes to set a trap for it in the ground. The researchers are betting that the same chemical similarity that draws strontium-90 to bone will bind it into a microbe-made calcite "prison."

Doing hard time in a hard water prison

Calcium is an essential ingredient for calcite. Fortunately, there's no shortage of calcium in the ground at most sites with old radioactive contamination. Much of the groundwater in the arid American West contains so much dissolved calcium that crusty deposits of the mineral often clog water pipes near the DOE's Washington and Idaho sites.

Getting that calcium to turn into calcite on location and on demand requires molasses, urea and a little help from microbes. First, the microbes chow down on molasses and multiply, swelling their numbers by tenfold or more. A second course of urea, a cheap nitrogen fertilizer, prompts part of the expanded microbe population to generate calcite. They do so by using a protein called urease, to convert urea and water to carbonate and ammonium. The carbonate then joins with calcium in the ground and groundwater to form calcite.

Ammonium, on the other hand, performs the critical function of scrubbing strontium-90 ions off solid surfaces. The contaminant tends to cling to dirt and rock and resists efforts to extract it from soil. But ammonium, like strontium-90, carries a positive charge, which helps it boot off the surfaces of solids.

The research team has screened the Washington and Idaho sites to see if microbially generated calcite might offer a solution at contaminated sites in the West. Fujita and her colleagues describe the results of testing samples from the Washington site in a September 2010 paper in the journal Environmental Science & Technology . In addition to containing enough calcium and the right chemical conditions to support long-lived calcite formation, the water and soil at that site contained plenty of bacteria that could make urease and calcite — as many as several thousand such microbes in a drop of water or a gram of sediment.

Earlier studies of molasses and urea injections into the groundwater near INL showed that the microbes there will make calcite, too. Indeed, many places around the world contain all the ingredients to make microbial calcite. For example, urea and microbes have been used to make sustainable bricks from sand in Abu Dhabi, and have been proposed as a way to repair stone surfaces in Europe.

Clogged pipes and shifting streams

Before researchers can use the technique to clean up contamination in the ground, they need to show that they can control and predict microbial calcite formation. That's easy enough to do in a laboratory beaker, but reining in bacteria and chemical reactions in a complex underground environment has posed many practical and scientific challenges.

For instance, in one of their first field experiments, Fujita and her colleagues generated so much calcite that they clogged their injection well and burned out a pump. "What a success!" Fujita recalls collaborator and University of Idaho geochemist Robert Smith saying upon hearing the news. "He was only half-joking," Fujita says. The clog made it difficult for the researchers to measure how much calcite they'd made or how much bacterial growth they'd stimulated.

For their next set of field experiments, the team upgraded to multiple wells and moved to the Vadose Zone Research Park at the INL desert Site. Having more than one well meant they could create their own water flow and study how far they could get the injected urea to go. But they had trouble getting the urea and molasses injections to go the way they wanted.

Henriksen describes the problem by sketching an underground stream taking a tortuous route through hidden gravel pits and around impermeable layers of basalt and clay before finally draining into the Snake River Plain Aquifer. "It's really complicated and dynamic," Henriksen says. "You can't just reach down there and make the water go where you want."

In addition, the amount and rates of water moving through the ground at the park can change. Fujita and colleagues spent their first year at the research park studying underground water movement. The team showed up the next year with many carefully planned experiments, only to find that the park water conditions had drastically changed. One well was even completely dry. The experiments had to be scrapped.

But Fujita, Smith, and Henriksen haven't yet given up on microbial calcite. They took care to locate their latest experiment at a well-studied DOE research site at an old uranium ore processing facility in Rifle, Colo. Henriksen and his colleagues are evaluating the effect of their molasses and urea injections on the local microbe community and working with hydrologists to help them understand Rifle's underground dynamics. The INL researchers couldn't dig up enough of the ground to look directly at how much calcite they'd generated and where, so they enlisted geophysicists to help them detect those things remotely with ground radar and by measuring any effects the underground reactions might have had on the ground's capacity to conduct electric current.

The forthcoming results of the Rifle experiment should get INL researchers closer to being able to predict the results of future efforts to stimulate microbial calcite formation. The researchers would like to expand their knowledge of the process with more and larger scale tests at contaminated locations, such as a pilot study at the Washington site, Fujita says.

Despite the frustration of thwarted experiments, Henriksen remains enchanted by the complexity of studying and manipulating microbes in the environment.

"Most people don't think about the bacteria everywhere around them or about utilizing the amazing capabilities bacteria have," Henriksen says. "They can do a lot of things we can't. Now we have the tools to work with them."

Explore further: Compound removes radioactive material from power plant waste

Related Stories

Compound removes radioactive material from power plant waste

March 13, 2008

Strontium 90 is a common radioactive by-product of fission in nuclear power plants. When extracted from the reactor along with other isotopes, a mixture is created made up of the radioactive material and inert ions like sodium ...

Calcium carbonate and climate change

August 30, 2010

( -- What links sea urchins, limestone and climate change? The common thread is calcium carbonate, one of the most widespread minerals on Earth. UC Davis researchers have now measured the energy changes among ...

How Solid Is Concrete's Carbon Footprint?

May 18, 2009

( -- Many scientists currently think at least 5 percent of humanity's carbon footprint comes from the concrete industry, both from energy use and the carbon dioxide (CO2) byproduct from the production of cement, ...

Recommended for you

Gauging the effects of water scarcity on an irrigated planet

April 20, 2018

Growing global food demand, climate change, and climate policies favoring bioenergy production are expected to increase pressures on water resources around the world. Many analysts predict that water shortages will constrain ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Jan 12, 2011
Observing Results . . .
Are measurements of 'Strontium 90' levels taken at each well site prior to Urea-Molasses injections?
One could then compare 'before and after levels to extrapolate Calcite formation. Cumulative 'quantification of All measurements from All sources/methods, should 'affirm' validity of 'method' for judging whether levels of S/90 are reduced sufficiently to justify 'prudent deployment' in the most severe S/90 contaminated areas.
The S/90, left untreated, seems an unacceptable option; given the relatively 'benign' effects of 'molasses-Urea' injections.
Given the viscosity levels, how do you 'coax' the 'molasses' to 'flow' in the first place?

Regarding Man-Made Radioactive
Waste . . . Is not such 'Waste' the 'dirty' constituent in 'Dirty Bombs'?

Keep up the Good/Great Work!
Roy J Stewart,
Phoenix AZ
not rated yet Jan 17, 2011
It Is about time that the media et al stopped promulgating the bull about radioactivity.

Put bluntly everything in the environment is radioactive to some extent and there is nothing we can do about it. The soil contains natural Uranium, Thorium, Potassium, Radium and all the other nuclides associated with them. Bananas contain radioactive Potassium as K40 among others, Brazil Nuts contain Radium, levels and nuclides absorbed depend on the makeup of the soil in which they are grown and the fertilisers used. The Buildings we live and work in are radioactive and the probability is that the Radiation comes not from the ancient bomb tests but from the natural materials used to build them. Ok Sr90 is a man made isotope that I grant you. But when some of the very people whining on about the dangers of radiation in the environment think nothing of using LoSalt (KCl), as a substitute for Common Salt (NaCl) I wonder whether they really know what they are talking about...

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.