Web delivery firm says Comcast taking toll on data

November 30, 2010 By JOELLE TESSLER , AP Technology Writer
File photo of a Comcast Corporation service truck a street in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. A dispute between US cable giant Comcast and a networking company that streams online movies from Netflix is being cast as a potential battle for an open Internet.

Level 3 Communications Inc., an Internet backbone company that supports Netflix Inc.'s increasingly popular movie streaming service, complained Monday that cable giant Comcast Corp. is charging it an unfair fee for the right to send data to its subscribers.

Comcast replied it is being swamped by a flood of data and needs to be paid.

Level 3 said it agreed to pay under protest, but that the fee violates the principles of an "open Internet." It also goes against the Federal Communications Commission's proposed rules preventing broadband Internet providers from favoring certain types of traffic, it said.

" is effectively putting up a toll booth at the borders of its broadband Internet access network, enabling it to unilaterally decide how much to charge for content," said Level 3's chief legal officer, Thomas Stortz, in a statement.

Comcast called Level 3's position "duplicitous" and said a previous deal for the companies to handle traffic for each other had become unbalanced in Level 3's favor.

The spat reflects the complicated commercial relationships of the Internet, where it's not always clear who should be paying whom.

Level 3's main business is carrying Internet traffic across the country, charging Internet service providers like Comcast fees to connect to Web sites and other ISPs.

However, it is moving into the business of distributing Internet content such as movies for companies including . Under that business model, it is acting like a content-delivery network, which usually pays ISPs for fast access to their networks.

Level 3, which is based in Broomfield, Colo., is now pushing to Comcast five times the traffic that goes the other way.

"When one provider exploits this type of relationship by pushing the burden of massive traffic growth onto the other provider and its customers, we believe this is not fair," Comcast's senior vice president Joe Waz said in a statement.

The dispute comes at a sensitive time for Comcast Corp., which is trying to get regulatory clearance to buy majority control of NBC Universal from General Electric Co. for cash and assets worth $13.75 billion.

The government is examining the deal, especially around concerns that the nation's largest cable TV provider could wield undue power in the distribution of online video once it takes control.

Level 3 said Comcast made a take-it-or-leave-it demand last week and it only agreed to the terms under protest to prevent consumer disruptions. Comcast said it is meeting with Level 3 later this week to discuss a new solution.

The fight is related to a heated policy dispute in Washington over proposed rules governing Internet traffic.

FCC Chairman Julius Genachowski has been pushing to adopt so-called "network neutrality" rules for more than a year, arguing that they are necessary to prevent phone and cable giants from using their broadband monopolies to become online gatekeepers.

Public interest groups were quick to jump on Level 3's complaint Monday to argue that premium services should not be allowed.

"Comcast's request of payment in exchange for content transmission is yet another example of why citizens need strong, effective network neutrality rules that include a ban on such 'paid prioritization' practices," Andrew Jay Schwartzman, senior vice president of Media Access Project, said in a statement.

The FCC had no comment.

It's not the first time Comcast, which is based in Philadelphia, has been accused of unfairly regulating Web traffic.

In 2008, the FCC ordered the cable giant to stop slowing and blocking its subscribers from accessing an online file-sharing service called BitTorrent, which lets people swap movies and other big files over the Internet.

For Netflix, the dustup could affect its popular video-streaming offering, to which it is pushing customers to save on the cost of sending rental DVDs in the mail.

Netflix declined to comment.

Starting next year, Level 3 will become Netflix's primary network for piping Internet video, although Netflix also will continue to rely on systems run by Limelight Networks Inc. and Akamai Technologies Inc.

If Level 3 is forced to pay more to send movies to homes that rely on Comcast for Internet service, it eventually could try to pass on the costs to Netflix and its subscribers.

As more of its 17 million subscribers embrace Internet streaming, Netflix's service has emerged as the biggest source of Internet traffic in the U.S. during peak evening periods, according to a recent study by Sandvine Inc.

Explore further: Comcast settles data discrimination lawsuit


Related Stories

Comcast, FCC take net neutrality dispute to court

January 8, 2010

(AP) -- The Federal Communications Commission staked out new ground nearly three months ago when it began drafting rules that would require Internet providers to give equal treatment to all data flowing over their networks.

FCC chairman says 'open Internet' rules are vital (Update 2)

September 20, 2009

(AP) -- Wireless carriers shouldn't be allowed to block certain types of Internet traffic flowing over their networks, the chairman of the Federal Communications Commission chairman said Monday in a speech that got a cool ...

FCC loses key ruling on Internet 'neutrality'

April 6, 2010

(AP) -- A federal court threw the future of Internet regulations into doubt Tuesday with a far-reaching decision that went against the Federal Communications Commission and could even hamper the government's plans to expand ...

Comcast online video trial grows to 23 networks

July 14, 2009

(AP) -- CBS Corp. and 17 cable networks said Tuesday they are joining an online video trial by Comcast Corp., a move that tacitly acknowledges advertising isn't enough to support shows streamed over the Internet.

Recommended for you

A not-quite-random walk demystifies the algorithm

December 15, 2017

The algorithm is having a cultural moment. Originally a math and computer science term, algorithms are now used to account for everything from military drone strikes and financial market forecasts to Google search results.

US faces moment of truth on 'net neutrality'

December 14, 2017

The acrimonious battle over "net neutrality" in America comes to a head Thursday with a US agency set to vote to roll back rules enacted two years earlier aimed at preventing a "two-speed" internet.

FCC votes along party lines to end 'net neutrality' (Update)

December 14, 2017

The Federal Communications Commission repealed the Obama-era "net neutrality" rules Thursday, giving internet service providers like Verizon, Comcast and AT&T a free hand to slow or block websites and apps as they see fit ...

The wet road to fast and stable batteries

December 14, 2017

An international team of scientists—including several researchers from the U.S. Department of Energy's (DOE) Argonne National Laboratory—has discovered an anode battery material with superfast charging and stable operation ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

3.7 / 5 (3) Nov 30, 2010
People who pay Comcast for Internet access are paying for Internet access, not Comcast access.

By charging for content, Comcast is defrauding its customers who already paid for that access.

The FCC stopped this practice before. Lets hope it continues to require open access.

Perhaps Comcast's bid to aqcuire NBC Universal should be blocked due to unfair practices.
5 / 5 (1) Nov 30, 2010
I wouldn't need high-speed internet if it weren't for Netflix... perhaps not a smart move by Comcast
5 / 5 (2) Dec 01, 2010
I'm getting pretty sick and tired of company's acting like they are being hindered by people using the service they've paid for.

Comcast is an ISP
They provide internet
I pay for that internet
I should have access to any system on the network

If what I'm accessing is causing comcast trouble then they should fix their network to handle it, or get out of the business of providing it.

If not, well Ill find someone else, and take them out of the business of it.
5 / 5 (1) Dec 01, 2010
Did comcast turn a profit this year? Yep, record profit.

Did comcast roll out any network upgrades to address bandwidth needs? Nope, not a one.

They did take the time to "rebrand" themselves and come up with a spiffy new name to try to compete with FiOS and get back the customers they alienated prior.

Comcast can suck it. If they were smart, they'd upgrade their networks and focus on attracting more content contracts. Setup a deal with netflix for revenue sharing. Be cooperative rather than stuck in a 1990's delivery mechanism. They'll be left behind if they don't smarten up.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.