US mulls approval of genetically engineered salmon

September 6, 2010 by Rob Lever
A size comparison of an AquAdvantage® Salmon (background) versus a non-transgenic Atlantic salmon sibling (foreground) of the same age. US authorities have begun to consider approval for the first time the sale of genetically engineered salmon, a move that some say could open the door to more transgenic animals on American dinner tables.

US authorities have begun to consider approval for the first time the sale of genetically engineered salmon, a move that some say could open the door to more transgenic animals on American dinner tables.

A US panel has set a hearing for September 19-20 to consider a proposal by Massachusetts-based AquaBounty Technologies for production and sale of a new Atlantic with a growth hormone gene from the Chinook salmon that allows it to grow faster.

The company said the allows the fish to grow to market size in half the time of conventional salmon but that in all other respects, its AquAdvantage salmon "are identical to other ."

The new strain of salmon can help meet rising demand for fish and reduce pressure on wild , the firm contends. It says it can avoid the pollution, disease and other problems associated with saltwater fish farms by raising the salmon at inland facilities.

"The benefit of this technology is that because the fish grows more efficiently it can be grown faster and closer to population centers," says Ron Stotish, chief executive of the group, which is publicly traded in London.

Stotish, who said the firm hopes to sell its salmon eggs in the US, Canada and elsewhere, argues that new technologies are needed for a global population quickly depleting fish and other food supplies.

"I think this technology can be a tremendous aid to assuring a safe and sustainable food supply," he told AFP.

But environmental and groups are raising fierce objections, saying this could not only endanger wild salmon but open the door to other kinds of genetically modified animal foods that may pose health or environmental dangers.

If approved, the salmon would be the first transgenic animal allowed for US human consumption, although officials have approved a goat with to produce an anti-clotting treatment.

Critics of the new salmon say approval could exacerbate the problem of farmed fish escaping from tanks and breeding with wild counterparts, with unpredictable results.

Jaydee Hanson, a policy analyst at the Center for Food Safety, a Washington-based watchdog group, said the company was basing its application on the "fiction" that introducing genes into an animal is the same as using drugs.

"Because the company is claiming this is a drug it has to demonstrate this is safe in the animal, but it doesn't have to show it is safe for people to eat," he told AFP.

The center was among a coalition of 31 groups urging the FDA to reject the application, and Hanson said approval could open the door to a variety of other kinds of genetically engineered animals ranging from tilapia to pigs to cows.

AquaBounty has pledged safeguards that include only using land-based facilities instead of ocean pens to prevent accidental release, and breeding that leads to sterile females.

Stotish said the new salmon are "the most studied fish in the world" and that regulators have considered a variety of scenarios.

"AquaBounty has taken unprecedented steps to assure that the fish cannot interact with wild populations," he said. "Not only are they all sterile females, as a condition of approval they will be raised in land-based contained aquaculture systems -- making escape into the wild an impossibility."

The FDA, in a preliminary assessment on the risks, said the likelihood of escape into the wild is "extremely small." As a result, it said the new salmon "are highly unlikely to cause any significant effects on the environment."

Critics remain unconvinced of the merits of transgenic salmon, derided by some as "Frankenfood."

"We all know there is a great appetite for salmon, but the solution is not to farm' genetically engineered versions to put more on our dinner tables; the solution is to work to bring our wild salmon populations back," says Jonathan Rosenfield, president of the SalmonAID Foundation, a coalition of commercial, tribal, and sports fishing interests.

If the FDA approves the request, it will then consider whether to label the salmon as genetically modified -- a move which might lead consumers to shun the fish.

But Hanson of the Center for Food Safety said that a special label would be warranted.

"Our position is that given the data we've seen it shouldn't be approved but if it is approved, it should be labeled," he said.

"If they don't label it, all other US farmed salmon is going to be assumed to be genetically engineered, so it would damage the industry."

Explore further: Salmon marked 'wild' may be farm-raised

Related Stories

Salmon marked 'wild' may be farm-raised

June 30, 2006

Salmon labeled "wild" may actually be "farm-raised" and can be costly besides being wrongly packaged, New-York based Consumer Reports says.

Norway may halt salmon fishing season

April 18, 2008

Norwegian wildlife management officials said stocks of wild salmon have dropped so low they may have to halt the salmon fishing season.

Scientists wonder where salmon are

July 7, 2005

Biologists and fish and wildlife experts in Washington State say only about 100,000 sockeye salmon have returned to spawn and they want to know why.

Recommended for you

Recovering predators and prey

February 27, 2017

If you build it, they will come. That's historically been a common approach to species recovery: Grow the prey population first and predators will quickly return. As it turns out, that's not quite the case. A new study has ...

Taking aim at a key malaria molecule

February 27, 2017

The iron-containing molecule heme is necessary for life. Cells require heme to perform the chemical reactions that produce energy, among other critical tasks.

1 comment

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Sep 06, 2010
Salmon is delicious, we need more of it. I approve of genetically engineering salmon!

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.