Nexus One with 3G now available for AT&T, but it's a terrible deal

March 18, 2010 By Victor Godinez
The Nexus One smartphone.

From a financial perspective, the quiet launch of the AT&T version of the Nexus One is a spectacularly bad deal for wireless users and I urge any AT&T customers thinking of buying the Nexus One to reconsider. I'll explain why in a minute.

First, here are the details.

With the T-Mobile 3G version of the Google Android-powered , you can either buy the unsubsidized, no-contract version for $529 or, if you're eligible, you can get the subsidized, two-year-contract-required version for $179.

But if you want the AT&T 3G version of the Nexus One, you have only one option right now: the $529 no-contract/no-subsidy model.

Presumably, if you wish to activate this phone on AT&T's network, you'll be required to sign up for standard smart phone voice and data plans, which run, at a minimum, $69 per month.

That's the same monthly rate you pay for a subsidized iPhone, for example, or any other smart phone.

If you opt to buy an unsubsidized AT&T Nexus One, you'll be screwed in two ways: on the monthly plan and on the fact that it's cheaper to get out of a contract than to pay for a phone with no contract all.

First, the whole point of the monthly service plans on subsidized phones is that they recoup the cost of the subsidy for the carrier. In other words, yes, your carrier sells you the phone at a discount, but in return, the carrier eventually recoups that subsidy from you by essentially adding a few extra bucks to your monthly fee.

However, if you don't get a subsidy, but still pay the same monthly rate as someone who does get a subsidy, you're paying money to AT&T for a subsidy that you never received.

In other words, you're giving AT&T money for nothing.

But, you protest, I'm not locked into a contract with the unsubsidized phone! That freedom is worth something to me!

And well it should be. In fact, I can tell you exactly how much that freedom is worth: $175, since that's the across-the-board fee AT&T charges users to get out of their two-year contracts ahead of the actual expiration date. That fee is also reduced by $5 every month over the course of a 24-month contract.

So, in theory, the price difference between the subsidized and unsubsidized version of a phone on AT&T should never be more than $175. If the price difference is greater than that, then you're better off signing up for the subsidized version of the phone and just paying the early termination fee if and when you decide to leave.

So if T-Mobile is selling the subsidized version of the Nexus One for $179, I presume that any AT&T-subsidized version would be $179, as well, just to stay competitive.

So the max anyone should be willing to pay for the AT&T Nexus One is $179 plus $175 (the standard AT&T ETF). In other words, $354.

So the fact that Google is charging $529 for the AT&T 3G Nexus One is a travesty.

Now, I am aware that Google also requires a $150 "equipment recovery fee" on any T-Mobile Nexus One returned within 120 days of purchase. No other wireless device manufacturer does that, as far as I know, and frankly I think that's one reason the Nexus One has been a commercial flop.

Throw that $150 on top of AT&T's $175 ETF and come up with a total "subsidy value" of $325. Add that onto the $179 contract price of the Nexus One, and the unsubsidized handset should therefore cost $504.

In other words, even with Google's and AT&T's fees, it still should be cheaper to buy a Nexus One on contract and cancel, rather than buy the unsubsidized model.

What's more, keep the phone for just three months and Google's $150 fee drops off entirely, making it much cheaper to cancel your contract than to avoid it in the first place.

BUT, Google and AT&T aren't selling a subsidized version of the Nexus One that runs on AT&T's network.

In other words, Google and AT&T are both trying to squeeze far more money out of Nexus One buyers than any other handset manufacturer or carrier, and they're not offering the device in any way that lets you avoid those outsize prices.

How to avoid it? Don't buy it.

Wait for a subsidized version. And try it for three months.

After that, the Google recovery fee is void and all it will cost you is $160 (the pro-rated AT&T termination fee) to walk away.

Explore further: Google reduces fee to break Nexus One contract


Related Stories

Google reduces fee to break Nexus One contract

February 9, 2010

(AP) -- Google Inc. is shaving $200 off the fee that it charges customers of its new Nexus One phone to break a service contract with T-Mobile, as federal regulators continue to probe such fees and the rationale for them.

Report: Google phone $5 less to make than iPhone

January 11, 2010

(AP) -- Google Inc.'s new Nexus One phone costs about $5 less to make than Apple Inc.'s iPhone, partly because Google's device has far less memory, according to new data from research firm iSuppli Corp.

Wireless carriers tell FCC they disclose fees

February 24, 2010

(AP) -- The nation's biggest wireless carriers are telling federal regulators that they give consumers adequate notice about early termination fees that apply when a service contract is broken before it expires.

Google to sell Nexus One, a 'super' mobile phone (Update)

January 5, 2010

(AP) -- Google Inc. began selling its own mobile phone Tuesday, a much-anticipated move aimed at protecting its online advertising empire as people increasingly surf the Web on handsets instead of personal computers.

Recommended for you

Researchers find tweeting in cities lower than expected

February 20, 2018

Studying data from Twitter, University of Illinois researchers found that less people tweet per capita from larger cities than in smaller ones, indicating an unexpected trend that has implications in understanding urban pace ...

Augmented reality takes 3-D printing to next level

February 20, 2018

Cornell researchers are taking 3-D printing and 3-D modeling to a new level by using augmented reality (AR) to allow designers to design in physical space while a robotic arm rapidly prints the work.


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Mar 18, 2010
Your math is absolutely correct. I sell phones for a living, tmobile, att , sprint, and others. The case against att goes way deeper then this though. One can also call out tmobile for their even more plus , it requires you to purchase the phone at near full price (being the 550 $ price), and then pay standard rates. Where as sprint requires a 50$ deposit which you get back in the form of it going towards your bill in 1 yr. Att requires 800 dollar deposit in the specific case I speak of.
not rated yet Mar 22, 2010
The author neglects to mention the fact that with T-mobile you have a lower monthly bill with unsubsidized phones. T-mobile has seperate rate plans for contract/no contract customers. The Nexus one is actually cheaper over a two year period if you pay the 529$ up front through T-mobile.

If AT&T is not offering a lower rate plan for non-contract phones they are cheating people.
not rated yet Apr 20, 2010
The question is though, can it be confirmed that AT&T will recognize the unlocked, unsubsidized version as what it is. Case in pint. They have the E71x that gets a smartphone premium. But, I have an unlocked e71 I bought from Amazon, and I pay normal phone rates. Of course, I did get a free phone, that went to my fiance's Mom, so it was okay that they charged me the subsidy price, but my internet plan for the e71 was $10, because it was not recognized.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.