Probing Question: Is the death penalty on the decline in America?

December 17, 2009 By Jesse Hicks, Pennsylvania State University
Probing Question: Is the death penalty on the decline in America?

In November, the Commonwealth of Virginia executed John A. Muhammad, the infamous “D.C. sniper” responsible for 10 murders seven years earlier. On the eve of his execution, a Washington Post poll found 66 percent of Virginians supporting the death penalty and 31 percent opposed. Though still high, these numbers represent a drop in support for capital punishment in the state of Virginia from four years ago, when 72 percent of likely voters said they favored the policy. Despite this recent high-profile case, 2008 saw the fewest executions in the state since 1999.

Does this mean the is on the decline in America?

Yes, said Suzanna Linn, professor of political science at Penn State.

“Although a majority still supports the death penalty in the abstract,” Linn said, “fewer and fewer defendants are being sentenced to death both because prosecutors are less likely to seek the death penalty and juries are less likely to mete out a death sentence.”

A growing number of high-profile death-row exonerations have further undercut public confidence, Linn said (135 Americans have been released from death row upon re-examination of their cases). Investigative feature stories, such as the recent article in The New Yorker magazine, "Trial by Fire: Did Texas execute an innocent man?", are likely to focus on a defendant’s struggle to obtain justice within an often dysfunctional legal system.

This is a new development in the United States, said. Linn. Capital punishment has a long history in the United States: colonial governments brought the idea from their mother countries. In 1976, the modern era of the death penalty began in this country, with a series of decisions clarifying its constitutionality and setting clear guidelines for its application. In modern times, Linn explained, public support increased through the 1990s, peaking at about 80 percent of Americans. However, since the mid-90s that number has decreased dramatically. So, too, has the number of executions per year, from a height of 98 in 1999 to 37 in 2008.

Linn, along with colleagues Frank Baumgartner and Amber E. Boydstun, authored the recent book "The Decline of the Death Penalty and the Discovery of Innocence." In it, she argues that the decline is predicated by a shift in how Americans talk about the death penalty. While a majority still finds capital punishment morally defensible, the debate has shifted toward whether it can be enforced fairly, with no chance of executing an innocent person.

“The 'innocence frame' is one way to look at the death penalty debate,” she said. “It is composed of arguments that the system is broken, that a human-run system cannot avoid making mistakes and that the defendant sometimes has been denied sufficient access to evidence like DNA.”

This way of framing the debate puts the emphasis on judicial practice rather than on moral abstractions, she said, and has gradually eroded support for the death penalty.

The American Bar Association (ABA) has entered the debate by conducting a three-year study on state death penalty systems.

"After carefully studying the way states across the spectrum handle executions," wrote Stephen F. Hanlon, chair of the ABA Death Penalty Moratorium Implementation Project, "it has become crystal clear that the process is deeply flawed. The death penalty system is rife with irregularity, supporting the need for a moratorium until states can ensure fairness and accuracy.”

Although 35 states still have death penalty statutes, some states already have declared moratoria on executions, Linn said, and the Supreme Court has found the death penalty unconstitutional for the mentally handicapped and for juvenile offenders. Linn sees this trend away from capital continuing as more people adopt the innocence frame.

“The argument that a system run by bureaucrats will make mistakes doesn't challenge the deep-seated moral position in favor of the death penalty,” she said. “Regardless how one feels morally, no one wants to execute innocent people.”

Explore further: New study shows race significant factor in death penalty cases

Related Stories

Death Penalty Does Not Deter Murder, According to New Study

June 17, 2009

Eighty-eight percent of the country's top criminologists do not believe the death penalty acts as a deterrent to homicide, according to a new study published today in Northwestern University School of Law's Journal of Criminal ...

Legal counsel affects death penalty cases

October 27, 2009

Legal counsel is a matter of life and death in Houston, but it is not necessarily tied to a defendant's socioeconomic status, according to new research by Scott Phillips, associate professor of sociology and criminology at ...

Journal defends accused medical workers

October 26, 2006

The scientific journal Nature says it has concluded six medical workers who face the death penalty in Libya are probably innocent of charges.

Recommended for you

Unprecedented study of Picasso's bronzes uncovers new details

February 17, 2018

Musee national Picasso-Paris and the Northwestern University/Art Institute of Chicago Center for Scientific Studies in the Arts (NU-ACCESS) have completed the first major material survey and study of the Musee national Picasso-Paris' ...

Humans will actually react pretty well to news of alien life

February 16, 2018

As humans reach out technologically to see if there are other life forms in the universe, one important question needs to be answered: When we make contact, how are we going to handle it? Will we feel threatened and react ...

Using Twitter to discover how language changes

February 16, 2018

Scientists at Royal Holloway, University of London, have studied more than 200 million Twitter messages to try and unravel the mystery of how language evolves and spreads.


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.