Online gambling a bad bet for America, U. of I. expert says

Online gambling a bad bet for America, U. of I. expert says
John W. Kindt, a professor of business and legal policy, says supporters of a renewed push to lift the ban on online gambling are betting that it will pay off in easy new tax dollars, but the stakes are too high. Photo courtesy College of Business

( -- Gambling addictions would soar and an already-sputtering economy could sink into ruin if Congress overturns a decades-old ban on Internet gambling, a University of Illinois professor and national gambling critic warns.

John W. Kindt says supporters of a renewed push to lift the ban, which started with Attorney General Robert F. Kennedy’s wire act against organized crime, are betting that online gambling will pay off in easy new tax dollars, but the stakes are too high.

“The revenue they would get is miniscule compared to the devastation it would bring to financial systems, stock markets, national security and people’s lives,” said Kindt, a professor of business and legal policy.

Rep. Barney Frank, a Massachusetts Democrat who chairs the House Financial Services Committee, plans to introduce legislation next week aimed at overturning the 2006 Unlawful Internet Gambling Enforcement Act, which strengthened the existing ban.

Frank also sought repeal but failed in 2007, just a year after the measure was approved with 80 percent, bipartisan support in Congress and signed into law by then-President Bush.

“It’s outrageous that he’s trying again,” said Kindt, who has studied gambling for more than two decades. “This law was the result of 10 years of congressional hearings, where expert after expert warned of the dangers of gambling on the Internet.”

Kindt, who testified in support of the law, says online gambling would inflame problems already linked to casinos. He says research shows bankruptcies increase 18 to 42 percent in areas with casinos, crime jumps 10 percent and rates for new addicted gamblers double.

“Online gambling is called the crack cocaine of creating new addicted gamblers,” he said. “It places gambling at every school desk, every work desk and in every living room. Does Barney Frank really want to entice people to click their mouse and lose their house?”

Kindt says online gambling also would create a potentially disastrous speculative bubble in U.S. financial markets similar to the dot-com bust a decade ago, spawning fast-growing companies with exaggerated expectations that far outstrip real value.

Global markets already have seen the dire consequences, he said. A Gibraltar-based gaming company saw its London Stock Exchange value plunge from $10 billion to $2.4 billion in one day after the U.S. strengthened the ban on Internet gambling in 2006.

“This would set us up for something worse than the sub-prime mortgage disaster,” Kindt said. “These companies are predicated on speculation, and destabilize the financial system and stock markets worldwide.”

Instead of expanding gambling, Kindt advocates a national rollback, particularly on slot machines. He says a rollback would ease costs to taxpayers that amount to at least $3 for every $1 in benefits because of increased bankruptcies, crime and gambling addictions.

also siphons money away from the traditional consumer economy, where an economic “multiplier effect” triples the value of every dollar spent by creating jobs that supply goods and services, he said.

“All Congressman Frank wants is some new tax revenues, and he’s throwing the country under the bus to get them,” Kindt said.

Provided by University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign (news : web)

Explore further

Ban on betting would boost ailing economy, gambling critic says

Citation: Online gambling a bad bet for America, U. of I. expert says (2009, May 1) retrieved 17 September 2019 from
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

Feedback to editors

User comments

May 01, 2009
Yea, that internet gambling would be so bad because people wouldn't have to go to las Vegas or atlantic city to lose their shirts. They could just do it from the comfort of their own home.

May 03, 2009
Kindt's work is disgraced around the country, along with his colleague Earl Grinols. See OnlineCasinoAdvisory. com, among many websites, that list his flaws and misstatements.

Much of the article shows background coming from Kindt as well, without question from the reporter. For instance, the UIGEA was not passed with bipartisan backing of eighty percent; the National Port Security Bill, a homeland security issue, was, and the UIGEA was hidden inside the bill as a last second addition.

The "research" Kindt quotes is of dubious value, and has been outweighed by properly conducted, objective scientific research. See the results of Harvard Medical School's Division of Addictions study into online gambling, as released by Dr. Howard Shaffer, for actual facts. Also see the empirical data quoted by OCA and other sites exposing this fraud.

May 03, 2009
Isn't this the same article that was posted a few weeks ago?

May 04, 2009
I would point out, that online gambling already exists; much of it originating from beyond the US' shores. The nature of the internet is such that location is irrelevant to services provided.

What I fail to understand here is how things would get any worse for those gambling, from a financial or time spent perspective if the gambling services were hosted inside the US rather than out of it.

All I can see happening is the US gains tax revenue from things that happen anyway.

May 10, 2009
Just remember, you don't need a degree from MIT to count your money! They count cards..
Count money- stats say, that the average person can
guess right 1 and 4 times.
Therefore, Bet X, 3x, 7x, 15x, 31x, etc..
And you'll cover the 1 in 4 guess stat.
Works at the track, keno, 21, etc..
You don't need to be lucky at gambling.. Just good
at counting your money!

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more