How foamy is spacetime?

February 10, 2006, feature
How foamy is spacetime?
This image is a linear combination of two images first observed by Perlman et al. for research studying the relationship between this quasar and its galaxy. In the image, the ring surrounds the nucleus of the galaxy, making it look iris-like rather than just pseudo-point-like. Image courtesy of Eric Perlman.

Maybe not as foamy as some scientists thought, as a fresh look at a quasar first observed in 1998 by the Hubble Space Telescope (HST) shows. Physicists observed a diffraction pattern called an Airy ring around the image of a distant quasar-like object. This ring persuades physicists that the light from this distant object has traveled through a relatively calm – rather than extremely frothy – spacetime.

The idea that space is composed of ever-changing arrangements of bubbles, called spacetime foam, dates back to the 1960s. On a small (Planck) scale, foamy bubbles result from the uncertainty principle, which allows virtual particles to spontaneously pop into and out of existence. Although quantum foam violates the law of conservation of energy on ultra-short timescales, nanoscale devices have measured the effects of these tiny virtual particles on the vacuum in other contexts. Further, many physicists believe that some model of quantum foam must exist in any theory of quantum gravity, which unites quantum mechanics and general relativity.

“The detection of spacetime foam will give us a glimpse of the ultimate structure of spacetime,” said Y. Jack Ng, member of the team that observed the ring. “The observational results may also point physicists to the correct theory of quantum gravity.”

Ng and his colleagues, W.A. Christiansen and H. van Dam from the University of North Carolina, have narrowed down the possible models of quantum foam into the least foamy variations. The team compared two spacetime foam models based on quantum fluctuations in spacetime geometry. The first model is consistent with the holographic principle, which stipulates that the maximum amount of information that any region of space can store is proportional to its surface area instead of its volume, like a hologram. The second model, called the random-walk model, stipulates that successive fluctuations are random, totally uncorrelated. The holographic model enables a less turbulent spacetime compared with the random-walk model, which involves greater fluctuations.

The team chose to analyze the quasar-like object PKS1413 + 135 to search for an Airy ring because the presence of a ring limits the amount of light scattering that could be caused by spacetime foam. The quasar is 1.2 gigaparsecs – or about 4 billion light years – away from the Milky Way, allowing the physicists to accumulate the effects of the fluctuations over a distance, necessary for amplifying the tiny effects of the foam.

“Searching for spacetime foam effects is limited to point-like objects like PKS1413 +135 because objects greater than point-like size – such as galaxies – can contain an intrinsic structure that masks the effects of quantum foam,” said Christiansen.

The HST’s high-resolution image of the Airy ring surrounding the quasar ruled out the random-walk model, but lacked sufficient resolution to test the holographic model.

“By using this image, they’ve shown that the archives of all the great telescopes -- both the interferometers as well as single telescopes like the HST -- can be used to make very fundamental measurements about the structure of our universe,” said Eric Perlman, physicist at the University of Maryland who initially observed the quasar.

Telescopes currently being built could capture even higher resolution images for future studies.

“In the next few years, interferometers – such as the Very Large Telescope Interferometer in Chile or the Keck Interferometer in Hawaii – could test the holographic model by observing more distant quasars with their large apertures and long baselines,” said Christiansen.

Cosmological Implications

However, the team didn’t depend on further observations to deduce another cosmological implication in addition to measuring quantum foam.

Observationally ruling out the random-walk model, coupled with restrictions from computational physics, has repercussions on the matter of spacetime. Because ordinary matter only contains an amount of information dense enough to map out spacetime at a level consistent with the random-walk model, the physicists suggest that “there must be other kinds of matter or energy with which the Universe can map out its spacetime geometry (to a finer spatial accuracy than is possible with the use of conventional matter).

“This line of reasoning strongly hints at the existence of dark matter and dark energy, independent of the evidence from recent cosmological observations.”

Although the universe may not be quite as foamy as some scientists previously suspected, the team has put constraints on the foaminess of spacetime, and supplied another parameter with which to probe unconventional matter and energy. The group has also holds high hopes for learning more about spacetime structure in the near future.

“I think there is a close relation between quantum foam and dark matter and dark energy,” said Ng. “More work on holographic-foam-inspired cosmology is now in progress. Stay tuned.”

Citation: Christiansen, W.A., Ng, Y. Jack, and van Dam, H. Probing Spacetime Foam with Extragalactic Sources. Physical Review Letters. 96, 051301 (2006).

By Lisa Zyga, Copyright 2006

Explore further: NASA telescopes set limits on space-time quantum 'foam'

Related Stories

NASA telescopes set limits on space-time quantum 'foam'

May 28, 2015

A team of scientists has used X-ray and gamma-ray observations of some of the most distant objects in the universe to better understand the nature of space and time. Their results set limits on the quantum nature, or "foaminess," ...

Metamaterials used to mimic the Big Crunch

July 29, 2011

Spacetime analogs is an emerging field of physics in which scientists investigate systems having mathematical links with general relativity, and test their theories about the early behavior of the universe. The latest in ...

Our Universe: A Quantum Loop

April 25, 2006

“There are two classical branches of the universe connected by a quantum bridge. This connects the former collapse with the current expansion.” While Abhay Ashtekar and his colleagues, Tomasz Pawlowski and Parampreet ...

The universe, where space-time becomes discrete

April 22, 2016

In quantum gravity, classical physics and quantum mechanics are at odds: scientists are still uncertain how to reconcile the quantum "granularity" of space-time at the Planck scale with the theory of special relativity. In ...

Recommended for you

Coffee-based colloids for direct solar absorption

March 22, 2019

Solar energy is one of the most promising resources to help reduce fossil fuel consumption and mitigate greenhouse gas emissions to power a sustainable future. Devices presently in use to convert solar energy into thermal ...

Paleontologists report world's biggest Tyrannosaurus rex

March 22, 2019

University of Alberta paleontologists have just reported the world's biggest Tyrannosaurus rex and the largest dinosaur skeleton ever found in Canada. The 13-metre-long T. rex, nicknamed "Scotty," lived in prehistoric Saskatchewan ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Jan 11, 2009
There may be a hidden snag:
the foaminess may manifest differently if there are particles present or not, meaning that voids might /appear/ smoother than matter-cluttered spaces, wonking up tests of this nature, to some degree.
Mar 26, 2009
This comment has been removed by a moderator.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.